Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 31455 Main Rd, Cutchogue, NY 11935
Phone: (631) 298-0230
Website: https://www.romapizzeriacutchogue.com/?utm_source=gbp
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Roma Pizzeria – Cutchogue, NY – 31455 Main Rd – Hours, Menu …
Roma Pizzeria is currently located at 31455 Main Rd, Cutchogue, USA, 11935. Order your favorite pizza, pasta, salad, and more, all with the click of a button.
Roma Pizzeria – 31455 Main Rd, Cutchogue, NY 11935 – Slice
Roma Pizzeria · Pizza · Gourmet Pizza · Pizza By The Slice · Appetizers · Soups · Salads · Calzones & Rolls · The Parms. Chicken Parm. $16.00. Shrimp Parm. $ …
Roma Pizzeria | Cutchogue NY – Facebook
Roma Pizzeria, Cutchogue. 367 likes · 120 were here. At Roma Pizzeria in Cutchogue we offer the best Pizza variety as well as the best Italian food in town!
Reviews
J B
UPDATE: Same night after eating the pizza, both me and wife have had upset stomachs and have been in and out of the bathroom. She only had the pizza and knots, I had a little of everything. From 2 to 1 stars, avoid this place.
Cheese pizza – $20
Meatball parm – $12
Garlic knots – $4
Pickup: When picking up, pizza took an extra 10 minutes.
Food:
Pizza – pizza was a little overcooked, sauce was sweet rather than robust, which im not personally a fan of. Crust was breaded underneath and on the edges, similar to dominoes, but lacked any significant flavor. Cheese felt and tasted low quality, slices were rather stiff and sauceless. Not terrible but not worth $20.
Meatball parm – Meatballs were slimy on the outside and had weird consistency, very little sauce, nearly nothing on the first half. Cheese left a lot to be desired, had weird pockets of snot-consistency which I assume was grease? Definitely needed more sauce.
Garlic knots – Had zero garlic, parmessian, or flavor. It was just toasted bread…
I wouldn’t really recommend this place as there are cheaper and better options out there. Maybe we caught them on an off night as its my first time trying Roma Pizza, but it’ll likely be my last.
… moreCheese pizza – $20
Meatball parm – $12
Garlic knots – $4
Pickup: When picking up, pizza took an extra 10 minutes.
Food:
Pizza – pizza was a little overcooked, sauce was sweet rather than robust, which im not personally a fan of. Crust was breaded underneath and on the edges, similar to dominoes, but lacked any significant flavor. Cheese felt and tasted low quality, slices were rather stiff and sauceless. Not terrible but not worth $20.
Meatball parm – Meatballs were slimy on the outside and had weird consistency, very little sauce, nearly nothing on the first half. Cheese left a lot to be desired, had weird pockets of snot-consistency which I assume was grease? Definitely needed more sauce.
Garlic knots – Had zero garlic, parmessian, or flavor. It was just toasted bread…
I wouldn’t really recommend this place as there are cheaper and better options out there. Maybe we caught them on an off night as its my first time trying Roma Pizza, but it’ll likely be my last.
mike power
It was overpriced and absolutely horrible . 10.50 for 2 of the worst pepperoni slices i ever had. With that cheap fake pepperoni. And why is there also a Spanish food menu? If you can’t do the thing you’re supposed to descent…….pizza case was empty. Staff looked miserable. . I would avoid this place. …
… moreMae Raynor
The pizza tonight was the best pizza I have ever had! Something changed and I love it! The website is impressive and set up to give you ETA, and if they are busier than normal it texts you immediately. Keep up the good work new pizza dude!
Something digressed since the incredible pizza I had this day. It’s ok, but not as good as it was.
… moreSomething digressed since the incredible pizza I had this day. It’s ok, but not as good as it was.
Chris W
Very friendly staff, excellent appetizers and unique pizza gives you a taste of the north fork, 10/10 recommend
… moreKimberly Aurelio
Celebrated my Mother in laws 80th Birthday this weekend at Roma Liz and Willy and the entire staff were very accommodating the food was delicious and my mother in law was so happy ❤️ Thank you Liz and Willy
… moreJohn French
I walked in for a quick regular slice last night,the girl said the pie just came out. The few pieces left were next to other types of pizza. She handed me a cold slice. Then didn’t know how to make proper change. I was gonna go back in and say something but I decided to never go back again
… moreFrancesco Pizzolla
Terrible. Just terrible. Cheese tastes disgusting, dough not cooked on the bottom. Not keeping up the standard of Michelangelo’s. Do your tastebuds a favor and go somewhere else.
… moreMark Osmer
We’ve had multiple deliveries to our home delivery fees for a reasonable deliveries, always on time food is absolutely delicious and generously proportioned one entrée usually feeds my wife and I for two meals great value great food. Highly recommended.
Mark and Mona Osmer
… moreMark and Mona Osmer
Morgan Kowalchuk
We’ve been coming here for years and our pizzas last week were horrible and incorrect. They gave us the wrong pizza so we had to go back and it still was mediocre and not worthy of New York.
We let that go and came to dine in this evening. We usually love dining in, as the food is great and the ambiance was nice with white table clothes and candles. We knew they didn’t have an abc license, so we were told we could bring our own wine in from next door or anywhere else with no corkage fee.
We came in tonight to a dirty table, with pizza boxes stacked on other booths, and no table cloths. We had to ask to have our table cleaned, and the girl wiped it off with a dry paper napkin into her hand with grease smeared. Thankfully she let us know that there would be a $30 corkage fee for wine, when they don’t even sell it.
This was all unacceptable so we unfortunately walked out. There must be a new owner and not for the best. We were upset by the two situations with pizza last week, and now we have a third. Sadly we will not return.
… moreWe let that go and came to dine in this evening. We usually love dining in, as the food is great and the ambiance was nice with white table clothes and candles. We knew they didn’t have an abc license, so we were told we could bring our own wine in from next door or anywhere else with no corkage fee.
We came in tonight to a dirty table, with pizza boxes stacked on other booths, and no table cloths. We had to ask to have our table cleaned, and the girl wiped it off with a dry paper napkin into her hand with grease smeared. Thankfully she let us know that there would be a $30 corkage fee for wine, when they don’t even sell it.
This was all unacceptable so we unfortunately walked out. There must be a new owner and not for the best. We were upset by the two situations with pizza last week, and now we have a third. Sadly we will not return.
Nicole Gomez
They have pretty desserts on display, but when I ordered a tiramisu from them the guy who works there went to the back and gave me a smaller freezer burned cake. I asked and they don’t even make their own desserts it’s shipped and frozen and cost 10 dollars. The lady is also kind of rude. I only say that because it’s been second time she hasn’t been nice and given me weird looks. I really don’t recommend their desserts; pizzas are average
… more