4.8 – 188 reviews • Bakery
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Take out
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Reviews
Heather Novak
Wonderful baked goodies! Breads, cookies, cinnamon rolls, and pies! Get there early, a line will form before opening! They take cash or card. A hidden gem for sure. Check hours before going. Fridays 1:00-5:00 Mid-May until Labor Day. Saturdays April-December 8:00-5:00.
… moreDavid Vande Vyver
A great place to grab some unique treats and homemade bread and pies with flavors you won’t find in other places. There a bit out of the way though so it’s good to look up and GPS there address but there definitely worth the little sidetrack of 117 to grab some awesome breads as well as potato doughnuts!!! I’ll definitely be checking them out in the future!!
… moreKaren Bruesewitz
We had not visited Yoder’s for some time and our visit was somewhat quick. We did notice some new sweet roll offerings but I didn’t ask about them. We walked away with a lemon poppyseed bread, snickerdoodle cookies, a combination plate of cookies, cheese bread, and my all time favorite, potato donuts. Wish we lived closer and Yoder’s was open more often, but then it wouldn’t be such a treat!
… moreChris S.
Worth the drive, no matter how far! The best baked goods you’ll ever have the pleasure of eating. 11/10 stars!
… moreKaren Engvall
The bakery smelled amazing! LaVon Yoder was so friendly and kind! I had a hard time choosing baked goods, so I purchased 6 different items!
… moreBen
Their donuts are amazing! I can’t wait to try more baked goodies from here
… moreThomas Sutphin
I bought several things from here – the bread, oatmeal cream pies, and cookies and they were all phenomenal. It’s nice ordering food from the Amish because it’s not full of garbage like most American foods. The bread might not last long without preservatives, but it’s so good. The people are so nice and helpful as well.
… moreK Buntin
1st time here, absolutely fantastic!! Get there early because the line forms out the door. Bakery is exceptional especially their potato donuts. Very reasonably priced.
… moreTim Schmidt
Wish we would have known they close for the winter before driving all the way there craving some of their famous potato donuts. Please update the hours so more people don’t waste money on gas and half their day expecting some baked goodness only to have their day ruined. Really sucks dealing with crying kids for 2 hours home when everywhere you look says Open except for the sign in the parking lot. Would expect a business of this caliber to do better.
… moreCraig L
Excellent baked goods, but you need to get there early because everything is so good. Their pies are the best around! If you are looking for your next guilty pleasure, get there early for some cream sticks mmm mmm.
… more … View more