Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: W Perimeter Rd, Coldspring, NY
Phone: (716) 354-5401
Website: https://www.facebook.com/Horseshoe-Inn-157777210947291/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Horseshoe Inn | Frewsburg NY – Facebook
Horseshoe Inn, Frewsburg. 4464 likes · 55 talking about this · 1857 were here. Friendly Atmosphere, Friendly People, Great Food… what else is there?
Horseshoe Inn – Cozy Restaurant in Coldspring, NY
Located on W Perimeter Rd in Coldspring, NY, Horseshoe Inn offers a distinctive dining experience that combines warm hospitality with a charming, eclectic …
Horseshoe Inn – South Valley
… New York State. Cattaraugus County Tourism, 303 Court Street, Second Floor, Little Valley, NY 14755. Chautauqua-Allegheny Tourism Region · I Love New York. ® I …
Reviews
Zach Tucker
Everything about this place was great from start to finish! What a cool place for a nice quiet dinner. The atmosphere was amazing and the views were cool. Can’t wait to stop back in the summer time.
… moreDavid Starks
My family and I of 4 went here for dinner my wife and I have been here multiple times over the years this place was always great it seems like every time we go back it just keeps slipping further and further and further down so my wife and I and two children went in my son ordered a basket of buffalo wings and fries it came out on a plate he had maybe four or five boneless wings which there was no chicken in them it was just crunchy breading in a small pile of fries For $15.95 Then my daughter had a side salad that she turned into a wrap which was still no more than a side salad with chicken added she got very little chicken in the wrap that was also $15.95 My wife got the hot roast beef sandwich which is just chipped beef that’s very hard to mess up but it wasn’t that great it tasted like it was out of a can and I got a 10 ounce black Angus steak medium rare this steak came out blacker than black I took two bites of it it had a sour taste to it it was very very very well done I thought once I got to the middle of it it would pink it up it did not it was so charred that it looked like he burnt the crap out of it because the steak was bad it had that sour taste like it was bad the waitress asked me if I liked it and I told her no I absolutely disliked it it was the most disgusting thing I’ve ever had I’ve ever tasted so their way of making it up to me was taking $10 off my bill so therefore I paid $16.95 For a baked potato and a side salad this place is disgusting I propose to my wife here 20 years ago it was the best place At the time I had the best food now I wouldn’t send my dog in there to get the leftovers because I would be afraid that my dog would get sick oh yeah and by the way I had an upset stomach all night long so I recommend that people stay clear of this place it’s up for sale and obviously there’s a reason it’s up for sale because it’s obviously going downhill and my family and I will never step foot in this place ever again oh yeah and I also forgot we also ordered a basket of onion rings when it came to the table there was five onion rings five I repeat five onion rings For $5.95 this place is a joke this place is a rip off do not be disappointed like my family was that was over $100 bill that I paid for absolutely garbage food and we got home and my kids and my family were still hungry because the food was so disgusting nobody ate yup and she took $10 off the bill wow really
… moreAutumn Jells
This was such a cute, eclectic little place! The decor alone was awesome to take in. Had such a fantastic experience! Staff was friendly with such speedy service. The Fish Fry was very tasty. The “House” clam chowder was very unique & flavorful.
… moreJoelene Lasanta
I highly recommend stopping if in the area. This isn’t my first time, but it was my first time trying the mussels and they were delicious. The Seafood Chowder is always a must for me and it never disappoints. Love this place and the staff is always accommodating and so friendly.
… moreSteven Worthington
Went out to dinner with several friends over Labor Day weekend. This restaurant is remote but the food is outstanding. The restaurant setting is very casual and the people are friendly. You will encounter everyone from business owners to a group of bikers out for a ride dining here. If eating out is about the food for you…make the trip!
… moreJordan
If i could put zero stars I would. I am a person of color & I have never felt more disrespected in my life. I go out for dinner with my god family & get served the coldest rawest steak of my life when I ordered a medium well queen rib eye. And when I bring up how poorly it was made with a server, I get laughed at about the quality of the steak. New staff or a cook needs to be hired because theirs no way I should’ve left that place feeling as awful as I do now.
… moreLJ Metzger
Mind blowing pizza stuffed mushrooms with garlic bread!!! Best stuffed mushrooms in the area!
Amazing horseshoe cheeseburger! Perfect fries! Okay boneless wings(tiny portion and not enough sauce for the price). Great ranch.
… moreAmazing horseshoe cheeseburger! Perfect fries! Okay boneless wings(tiny portion and not enough sauce for the price). Great ranch.
Rob Inserra
First time there, and let me just say the food was outstanding!!! Very reasonably priced, and kid friendly. Our waitress Shawna was amazing. Will definitely be going again.
… moreDavid Covert
Scallops were great. My wife had the Delmonico steak, which was also great. Service was outstanding.
… moreTracey Miceli
Such a cozy place! Food and drunks were great, Atmosphere is laid back, very country but that’s a good thing! Lots to look at and read for sure. We will be going back. Thank you
… more