Neeta Renner
We had such a great experience at Brooklyn Joe’s in Milton! Abby took incredible care of our party of 11, all with a smile, even while she was clearly in the weeds. She was so attentive to my vegetarian needs & made sure everything was perfect. She arranged a cheeseless pizza for us & put together an eggplant & green olive angel hair dish (so perfect!), which was absolutely delicious. I probably ate way too much, but I’m already wanting to go back! Abby was pleasant, patient, & an absolute standout. Highly recommend Abby & this location!
… moreAlex Fiser
Brooklyn Joe’s is EXCELLENT.
The portions are big and the service is excellent. Our server Topper was great.
The atmosphere is pizzeria/sports bar and cozy. The establishment is clean with a great selection of beer and wine.
We had mozzarella stocks and fried zucchini to start. Both were very good. For dinner, we had pizza, chicken parm, Alfredo, and wings. Everything was served hot and was delicious. We will definitely be com8ng back!
… moreWalter F
As a Brooklyn guy myself, I have yet to find a single pizza place that has a NYC name that tastes at all like NYC Pizza or Pasta. This is the first that actually tastes like someone from NYC taught the staff. My family and I had a great meal and really enjoyed the meal! Our server, young lady lady with glasses and tattoos, was excellent and the over all atmosphere was great. I highly recommend! Will be coming back again and again! With the extra 30 minute drive even though I have like 3 Pizza right by my home.
… moreTerre Alexander
Good cheese ordered well done and got what I wanted! One bite everybody knows the rules. I give it a 8.1 but the second and third bite? 9.9 check out the cheese pull! Most pizza places are missing this!
… moreJames Jones
We love this place! Normally get right in. Lots of variety on the menu. We go to burgers and pizza alot. We also love the Italian offerings.
… moretatum kral
My family and I went to Brooklyn Joe’s last night and we were served by Bry. She was such an amazing, fun, and kind server. The food was so good as always and the atmosphere is very nostalgic. I always enjoy coming here. It’s great for family outings, hanging out with friends, or just grabbing a bite to eat. I would 100% recommend coming and especially trying the patty melt. The food is awesome and the service rocks. Everyone is so nice and welcoming, I truly could not recommend this place more.
… mores Coup
You cannot go wrong at any brooklyn joe’s…There’s a wide variety.
Of Italian dishes and pizza… The portions are healthy… I’m a midsize guy and I have to take half home every time… It was super bowl sunday, and service was very good, Considering the flow of traffic in the restaurant…the restaurant was clean and the food came out in a reasonable amount of time.. Hot and delicious …
Enjoy,
… moreSunny Patel
Good things: Very friendly staff and atmosphere was great. Requested for the Braves game to be on the tv and they got it done.
Mozzarella sticks were excellent!
The garlic knots were not bad. They were made and then the garlic butter was put at the bottom. So we were dipping the bread into the garlic at the bottom of the tray.
The marinara sauce was really good as well.
The pizza was not good. The sauce was sweet and the cheese was loaded so it wouldn’t let the base of the pizza really cook. You can tell from the picture that it was still doughy. The crust was great. But the actual pizza was a miss. We did ask if the jalapeños were fresh or not and the staff assumed as they came from the salad bar they must be fresh. They weren’t. Not a big deal. But just trying to help the staffer here on that portion.
Overall not bad. Good people. Just need to improve on the food.
… moreJoshua C
Was in the area and wanted to try someplace new with my wife. We both are pizza fans and after reading the reviews here we decided to give it a try. We were greeted as soon as we walked in and informed to sit where ever we like. Our waiter “Chris” came to our table, greeted us and asked what we would like to drink. Chris did a great job through our meal checking on us and making sure we were okay. The pizza was was on point. The crust was chewy but had the initial crunch when you bite into it. My wife said the chicken wings could have used some more sauce on them but I’m sure if we asked Chris would have brought it over to us.
I would recommend this Pizza Place to anyone in the area looking for a good pizza. I’ll be returning without a doubt.
… moreNadzyelee Hincapie
Great server! She was super friendly and took great care of us. Food was delicious. Huge portion. Zucchini fries are a must!! Can’t wait to come back with more friend and family
… more