Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4960 Nesconset Hwy, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776
Phone: (631) 473-5858
Website: https://betteronabagelpjs.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Better on a Bagel
Welcome to Better on a Bagel, Port Jefferson Station’s go-to spot for fresh bagels, hearty sandwiches, and classic American breakfast favorites.
Better On A Bagel | Port Jefferson Station NY – Facebook
Better On A Bagel, Port Jefferson Station. 1094 likes · 333 were here. Family owned & operated Located in Port Jeff Sta Not affiliated with any other…
Better on a Bagel Delivery Menu – Port Jefferson Station – Grubhub
Breakfast Bagels and More · Bagels Breakfast · $1.75+ · Bagel with Cream Cheese Breakfast · $4.00 · Muffin Breakfast · $3.50 · Sliced Lox Breakfast · $28.99 …
Reviews
Ellie
A hidden gem after a much needed Homegoods run! Bagels were soft, much bigger than other local spots, and extremely fluffy. Cream Cheese was creamy and delicious. The coffee was brewed perfectly and absolutely hit the spot on a cold day. My son ordered a BEC and raved about it. The bacon was cooked crispy and they gave him a nice amount. I was pleasantly surprised by their prices which are very reasonable compared to other shops we’ve visited. Especially when comparing the portion sizes. We will most definitely be visiting here again soon!
… moreCristina Badami
Such a great spot any time of day! I love that they have longer business hours, which makes it easy to stop in for breakfast or lunch. The egg sandwiches and skillets are always fresh and filling, the coffee really hits the spot, and the lunch specials are a great deal, especially with extras like chips, pickle, or side salads! Prices are very reasonable, portions are generous, and the staff is always friendly and welcoming. Highly recommend!
… moreCheryl Waters
I have been a customer for years and am always so pleased by the professional and cheerful employees. Always so kind. The food is excellent whether im getting a bagel or sandwiches. I highly recommend!
… moreROYAL GAMING SQUAD
Rude customer service everybody’s just mad and upset there. I don’t know why. I would say it was like Guy was very rude I want a sandwich that’s really easy. You can’t mess it up. I paid $15 for it and I’m pretty pissed it taste disgusting it tastes old. I’m never coming back here again
… moreabby kerrigan
The Bronx Bomber lunch sandwich is a game changer! More than generous amounts of Roast Beef smothered in between delicious, freshly toasted garlicky bread.
… moreThomas DeMaio
In the middle of a snowstorm 20 inches of snow on the ground. This place is open. As always great bagels & BEC
… moreElizabeth Hellmann
Literally the smallest chicken wrap ever. Literally no salad on a chicken Caesar salad wrap. Never order again.
… moreJon Berlin
An amazing bagel and deli store with great food, great service. I’ll definitely be back
… moreDonald Hunt
There bagels are good service terrible!!! Waited over 10 minutes to get a bagel when on my break that’s a long time. Probably wont go back
… moreJohn Macias
An absolute A+ staff with amazing sandwiches to come along with it. Wouldn’t rather get my bagels anywhere else.
… more