Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Nostalgic 1950s-style eatery serving heaping portions of classic American & Greek diner fare.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1887 NJ-35, Middletown Township, NJ 07748
Phone: (732) 671-1316
Website: https://newmonmouthdiner.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
New Monmouth Diner: A Menu Filled With American Favorites
New Monmouth Diner is an Excellent Online Store Efficient In Delivering Tasty Cheeseburgers, Fries, and Shakes for a low price. Contact us.
Order New Monmouth Diner – Middletown, NJ Menu … – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from New Monmouth Diner at 1887 New Jersey 35 in Middletown. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
New Monmouth Diner – Facebook
New Monmouth Diner. 2294 likes · 13 talking about this · 4654 were here. Voted Best Diner in Monmouth County 7 straight years.
Reviews
Kathy Coz
We stopped in for a quick lunch. Taylor was great, and helped us order. We ordered a cheesesteak, and burger which was very good. This is a great place to get some nice comfort food with quick service. A very pleasant experience.
… moreJohn Martinsen
Not as good as it once was. Middletown has become so crowded now and so few places to eat. I personally believe that you dont even have to try as a buissness owner anymore to be the best. People come whether or not the food and service are good there is nowhere to go. Was there 11/23/25 around 6pm ordered french onion soup waitress stated the soup will not come out before the meal it takes a while to make what? Ordered a roast beef triple decker and got a turkey club. Waitress wrote nothing down just took our order and placed it. Sure enough sandwich came out (wrong) and then the soup arrived after.Took the sandwich back to get the right one I ordered came back stated we have no provolone or swiss cheese just mozzarella so they put mozzarella on my roast beef triple decker! No pickles or coleslaw either she said. How are you out of all these items? This is why I say the owners just dont care. See the photo of my “Triple decker” lol its a sandwich with lettuce and tomato on top then another slice of bread thats not a triple decker!
… moreRichard “Army Veteran”
First time here meeting with good friends. From service to our meals we were very impressed. Matzo ball soup was very good and not salty. I had the broiled flounder which was cooked perfectly and did not have a fishy smell or taste. Definitely fresh. My wife had the chicken with Ritz cracker crumb. Cooked perfectly and tasted great. She really enjoyed it. Our friends had the pork chops which looked really good. That is their goto meal and say how good it is. Overall we will definitely be back. Welcoming environment and great food. Looking forward to trying the other menu options.
… moreAndrea Scott
We stopped in on a whim, we were quickly seated, they had a character visiting who came by and said hello to our littles. Our server was attentive all of our orders were perfect and the food tasted great! Even our children finished everything on their plate! We’ll definitely stop in here again next time we are in the area.
… moreAllison Kane
Gabriella was wonderful server, remembering our order with out a pad and pencil for a table of 6. I only saw that on tv…lol
… moreMichele M
In the heart of Middletown lies a diner that has served the most fantastic food for many many years! They are my old reliable when I am in town, as I know I’m always going to get good food and great service! Their chicken Parm is quite delicious and the chef always deep fries the pasta for me! Try it with their sauce and you won’t be sorry. Whatever it is, you’re craving, it’s going to be good here if it’s on the menu, which it probably is.
… moreMark Birch
Classic NJ diner experience. Good food, served fast, and efficient yet friendly wait staff. Got the gyro which comes with fries and a small Greek salad on the side. For $16 it is a really awesome deal for a quality and filling meal. Gyro itself was decent and packed with meat. Fries were on the perfect side of crispy. The salad was super fresh. My dining mates had the cheeseburger and the chicken fried steak, both is which were delicious and huge portions. You will not leave hungry leaving this diner. Total bill with tax less tip was under $60, so pretty decent from a value perspective. Absolutely one of my favorite restaurants in the north NJ shore region!
… moreRic Ravier
Stopped in for dinner and was pretty let down by the food. Service was amazing. The food was just really bland. Even the Chipotle Sauce, it just needed something. Lime, Brown Sugar, garlic… something was missing. Maybe we ordered the wrong itens
… moreSachin nayak
The recurring theme about this place in the reviews section is the lack of Covid precautions in place. I had mixed feelings about dining at this place after seeing the reviews. Although the staff did wear masks during our time of visit, the diner was surprisingly working at almost full capacity.
Let’s talk about the food because that’s what makes a diner special and the folks working here have nailed it. Everything that we ordered was delicious and the quantity was huge. We ordered – pancakes, a couple of different omelette, stuffed mushrooms and grilled cheese with fries. We enjoyed everything that we ordered.
The diner is huge with ample parking space outside. They do operate at full capacity so you’d be seated close to others. So, this is the thing, the food is spot on and there’s no complaints, but the place could do a little more towards taking precautions.
… moreLet’s talk about the food because that’s what makes a diner special and the folks working here have nailed it. Everything that we ordered was delicious and the quantity was huge. We ordered – pancakes, a couple of different omelette, stuffed mushrooms and grilled cheese with fries. We enjoyed everything that we ordered.
The diner is huge with ample parking space outside. They do operate at full capacity so you’d be seated close to others. So, this is the thing, the food is spot on and there’s no complaints, but the place could do a little more towards taking precautions.
Steve Nagy
It was our 1st time at this diner. It was a Saturday mid afternoon. There is a wide selection to pick and choose from on the menu. I had a light lunch consisting of a hamburger with lettuce and tomato on a brioche roll, fries, Cole slaw, and a pickle spear. It was very tasty and juicy. It may have been a 6 or 8oz burger. Not sure of that. My son had an omelet that he enjoyed. My better half had the plain burger. It was like mine without the fries, lettuce and tomato. We enjoyed everything. We’re looking forward to returning there to try some other meals!
… more