Barnabys Mishawaka

Pizza and a large drink from B100 and was pleasantly surprised to receive a large 3 topping pizza that was amazing. I could have ate the entire pie but forced myself to tuck half away in a to go box before finishing so id have some for later. These pizzas can easily feed 3-4 people.. Hands down an awesome pizza!! Thanks to B100 for hooking it up and thank you Barnabys for cooking it up!! I WILL BE BACK!!

… more

Ted Broskey

This is my favorite place for pizza, always turns out delicious, very fresh toppings on the pizza, we ordered this time hamburger, black olives, and mushrooms and light on the sauce, but Barnabys has specialty pizzas and a vast amount of topping choices. the atmosphere is a cozy cabin style with low lighting. TVs to watch games on and a few fun coin games for the younger ones. So stop in and place your order at the counter, they will let you know when it is done.

… more

Lori Anderson

Ordered takeout Dec 2025. One pizza was totally wrong and all three 20 oz sodas were expired (one over a year ago from Oct 2024). Called the manager (who escalated to owner) would not issue refund — said I would have to bring the bottles and the pizza back into the store as proof for a ‘replacement’. I hate to write this, especially for a family owned business, but the quality of product and care for customers is not acceptable.

… more

Richard Handley

This pet friendly thing is going to far guys! In my picture, at the top you can see a dog sitting at the table and I caught the owner feeding the dog some food. What is this?!?!? Gross. I do not go out to eat so I can eat with dogs and from the same dishes and table.

… more

Christina Scott

When you just want to go out and have a great pizza, you will never be disappointed going to Barnaby’s! We love going there, the garlic cheese bread is amazing too- no picture because it didn’t last long-that’s how yummy it is! Love the atmosphere here, try it out! They are so friendly here!

… more

Dana Tennison

I ordered a salad and a pub burger. The burger was burnt and it really tasted like it was precooked because the amount of cold grease on it was like an oil slick. I’m tired of complaining about burnt food. They gave me a pickle that I couldn’t bite through. The salad was pretty good. I’m really sad that I had this experience at this very popular place.

… more

Steve Frizzo

As a person who choses to deliver food part time, this location has become one of the worst experiences ever. I arrived with a pick up a few minutes after 5 and was told to wait in my vehicle and the food would be brought out. Fifteenth minutes later I went to the door again where they acted oblivious to my order… so I showed the same person my order and they said I will check… a man with a SUV parked outside the delivery door loaded what looked like 20 pizzas and said because it was Friday night delays were expected but my pizza was being cut… as he left another employee stated my pizza was being cut… after waiting another 10 minutes I again rang the bell… The same guy answers asking what name was on the order… I said are you joking? I spoke to the same person and they were completely incompetent… the owner and employees had discarded every interaction. I went to the front and asked to speak to a manager and was told he was working the oven… I gave the young lady my situation and story and asked for information… she found the order and said they should have communicated better but it would be at least 15 minutes before the pizza was done… I lost 50 minutes of delivery time and had to unassigned my delivery… no compensation… I will never accept delivery from this location again…. Im sure it matters little but sometime a little respect goes a long way…

… more

Dominique B

This was an odd restaurant. German looking building and theme, but no German food or beer. I guess they did offer a giant pretzel, if that counts for something. There are no waiters/waitresses. You seat yourself, there are order sheets on the tables. You mark what you want then take it to the pizza counter to place and pay for your order. Pizza is picked up and one counter and apps are picked up at another counter. They make sandwiches and other food but I didnt see an order sheet for that, so not sure how to order those. Drinks are done at the bar. You have to order all beverages at the bar. You pay and grab them there. No refills on fountain soda, which is annoying. Food came in at all different times. Long wait for the pizza despite all the crust being pre-made. The pizza was mediocre at best. Toppings were fresh. Sauce was tasty, but the bread was just dry and crumbly. The breadsticks were undercooked. Just very doughy. Onion rings were fine. Normal frozen rings. You can tell this is the local hole in the wall. Nice music playing on the speakers, little bit of everything. Some of the tables (probably college kids) blasting their on music from the tables. The tables were cleaned pretty quickly, which was nice. No piles of plates and trays on the tables. Overall, I wouldn’t come back. Pizza wasn’t great and the lack of assistance on where to go to order and pickup food wasn’t helpful. Also, they offer kid pizzas but its not indicated on the order sheet. So you have to write “mini” on the order sheet when you want a mini pizza. Quite annoying.

… more

Erin Meisterheim

The guy behind the counter. He’s probably like in his forties maybe 50 he was just all over like I would talk and he’d be rushing or he would interrupt didn’t really explain certain things. He was just really moving too fast and not really paying attention to me as a customer. He seems nice. He just needs to focus slow down and listen to people. Other than that it was a really nice place. The pizza was great. I did try their giant pretzel which was amazing and it is huge like I didn’t think it was going to be that big but it’s huge. It definitely will take you 2 days to eat

… more

Chris C.

Never been here before. Grabbed a couple carryout pizzas and cheese garlic bread. It’s a neat place inside. Almost has a pub-like look and feel. I would’ve liked to sit down and enjoy the atmosphere. Unfortunately, I was just not too impressed with the pizzas. They did not have a whole lot of flavor, and didn’t have an adequate amount of cheese on it. The crust was just sort of blah. It may just be a personal preference, but the pizza just did not impress me. I may go back to try something else, but will steer clear of the pizza.

… more

… View more

Hours

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Mishawaka Barnaby’s (Grape Road)

Mishawaka Barnabys: Pizza

Barnaby’s | Mishawaka IN – Facebook

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

🍽️ List or Update Your Restaurant

Recent Posts