Stellas Pizzeria 2

Experience the culinary delights of Stellas Pizzeria 2 in Athens, NY. From expertly crafted pasta dishes like Penne alla Vodka to the finest cheese pizza, …

Home | Stella’s Pizzeria, NY

Featuring the best pizza in the area, as well as wings, knots, and a wide selection of your favorite Italian dishes, Stella’s Pizzeria is the areas most …

Stella’s Pizzeria II | Great Northern Catskills of Greene County

Located in the charming village of Athens. Pizzeria and pancake house. Fresh made pancakes and eggs for breakfast. Pizza, salads, subs, sandwiches, …

Reviews

dark menace

This is about the reopening. I dont know what happened during their vacation. But the pizza is amazingly better. Just delicious, thin crust, perfectly balanced. Cheese no longer tastes like cheese curds, the sauce just had the perfect seasonings. I was told the owner was back there helping out. The homemade soup, Im always looking for that. Happy trails

… more

Bill Maas

Small dining area with a few tables to enjoy your meal at. Great service and clean dining area. Chicken Wings were very good. Had two slices of pizza which were OK not the best I have had but they were good. The atmosphere at the place was comfortable. The server was very polite and professional.

… more

Jamie Scognamillo

Awesome.. food was fantastic. Service was great. But the food was fantastic…. PERFECT Mozz sticks, wings were great plump and juicy, boneless were big and crispy not dry or crunchy like some places. The calzone and wraps are huge and stuffed. The spaghetti was perfect cooked? The sauce wasn’t acidic at all (no heartburn) and meatball were delish just like Nona used to make!!

… more

Marietta C

The best thing about this place is that you can take it to go and walk across for some killer water views.

Now..what do pizza and pancakes have in common?

ABSOLUTELY N-O-T-H-I-N-G!

Seriously. This is the worst mix ever. Super confusing. Confusing menu. So many options but you’re not really sure what they’re good for. Naturally pizza is one of them and you can never go wrong with pizza, right? Pizza was fine. Just grabbed a couple slices to go.

I would NEVER dine here. Covid or not. The ambiance is not appealing at all. You have a killer view outside with a vibe killer inside. A menu so large you get lost. It’s basically a diner? But a pizzeria? But a pub? But you eat here? So you can get spaghetti and meatballs? I think? But also chicken and waffles type of thing.

Super confusing. Not my fave. At all. What’s also not my fave is the fact that they have a plexi glass to protect themselves from us (while we’re wearing masks) and masks ARE required but apparently not for employees. Hmm..also super confusing.

The person that helped me had no mask on, no gloves, yet she was handling our food. As i peeked to the kitchen, several people were not wearing masks. SUCH A TURN OFF.

When I went to leave I decided to grab myself a little to go container of hot pepper flakes (that was never offered to me nor did I want her to handle it after touching her face and my card and the register while wearing no mask). I was abruptly stopped while she said well you know “covid” as she’s there without a mask and I am. Funny. Lol.

Anyways. This place is probably the only place open. And yes you can have many options of food. Not exactly sure I’d come back here but give it a try YOU might actually like it.

… more

lindsay reis

I ordered take out from this location on August 14 while my family and I were on vacation. Three of our items were raw when we ate them; chicken fingers, buffalo bites, and fried shrimp. My three year old nephew and I bite into this raw chicken finger. I called multiple times about a refund. Was told a refund was submitted to someone who does the refunds. Haven’t received any type of refund. Now when you call the location is closed until further notice. Also waited an extra 20 minutes in the restaurant after my food was supposed to be ready from the order pickup time.

… more

Phyllis Taddeo

This is a pretty small pizzeria and it was so hot outside so they had 3 air-conditioners running!! The place was crowded and very noisy. The service was great. The food was good.

… more

Giovanni Correra

Penne alla Vodka was wonderful and very well cooked. I strongly recommend this place for the food and also for the view near the lake.

… more

Jeff Wood

Tried it once again. I ordered Linguine and red clam sauce. There were raw plum tomatoes and the hard tops of the raw tasting sauce. No claim flavor at all. All I could taste was raw tomatoes. No seasoning at all. No oregano, basil… nothing. Not going back. Promise.

… more

Crystal P

Many times you order online & they never see your order. Today I waited an hour and a half for what I thought would be delivered because online you can select delivery. I called and the rude older woman answered saying they never received our order “let me grab this stupid tablet” then she sees it there immediately and says oh we no longer deliver during the day time. Why advertise delivery and have it as an online option if you don’t deliver?? Lately their food has been disgusting last week I got inedible garlic knots that tasted like uncooked flour was put on them instead of cheese. My calazone is always and I mean ALWAYS raw in the middle and most times I have random toppings thrown inside when I only ordered mushrooms. When we do get delivery the driver won’t come inside and calls to have us exit ththe apartment building and meet him outside… terrible service for being the only local place other than all the bars…

… more

Bob Ricketson

Great service. The food is good. Try the soup, I sometimes get one to go for later. If it is really busy, it will be noisy.
I live close by, so it is easy to pick times it isn’t so busy.

… more

… View more

Hours

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results