Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
The Homestead, a Sullivan Catskills classic, has been reborn at The Eldred Preserve as The Homestead Restaurant + Lounge, a modern steakhouse offering a true farm-to-table experience. The restaurant features several unique experiential spaces, including a mezzanine-level bar and wine-tasting room, a private dining room, a sunroom dining area, and large outdoor terraces that are ideal for dining al fresco.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1040 State Rte 55, Eldred, NY 12732
Phone: (845) 557-8316
Website: https://theeldredpreserve.com/dine
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Related Web Results
The Homestead Restaurant + Lounge | The Eldred Preserve
Sundays: 11:30 a.m.-2:30 p.m.. DINNER (Dining Room) Fri-Sun: 4:30 p.m.-8 p.m..
Menus | The Eldred Preserve
The Homestead, a Sullivan Catskills classic, has been reborn at The Eldred Preserve as The Homestead Restaurant + Lounge, a modern steakhouse offering a …
The Eldred Preserve
Your Nest in the Catskills · The Homestead Restaurant + Lounge · The Bradstan Boutique Hotel · The Preserve Weddings + Events · The Eldred Preserve on Instagram.
Last Updates
Reviews
Crissibeth Cooper
Wonderful place. Modern ambiance, lovely scenery. We were lucky to have some live music when we went, and what a delight! The vegetarian option (just one) was delicious and I hope they will add some more in the future. They seem to be embracing a modern perspective so I have hope! The cinnamon bread was divine. Cocktails were reasonably priced. Anna was an absolutely amazing server. We will be back often.
… moreK W
Had an amazing anniversary experience at The Homestead. Our server, Sam, was outstanding. She reassured we knew all the specials in house tonight and was very attentive. We appreciated the sharing plates for our porterhouse! It was cooked exactly how we requested! The steak fries and mushrooms and onions paired perfectly with the dinner. We started with the gojuchang chicken starter that is gluten free and our dessert was a creme brulee and homestead apple made in house. Thanks for taking care of us on our special occasion!
… moreGrowing Seed Academy
Outstanding Experience – Twice in a Row! Alexi made it very special.
We had such a wonderful experience at this restaurant not just once, but two nights in a row! From the moment we arrived until the last minute we walked out, the service and reception were absolutely exceptional.
A special mention goes to Alexi, our waiter both evenings. She was young, fun, and incredibly knowledgeable about the menu and the house specialties. Her energy and professionalism made the dining experience even more enjoyable. You can tell she truly loves what she does attentive without being intrusive, friendly, and very well-trained.
The entire team made us feel welcomed and cared for from start to finish. Everything about these two visits reflected quality, hospitality, and great attention to detail.
… moreWe had such a wonderful experience at this restaurant not just once, but two nights in a row! From the moment we arrived until the last minute we walked out, the service and reception were absolutely exceptional.
A special mention goes to Alexi, our waiter both evenings. She was young, fun, and incredibly knowledgeable about the menu and the house specialties. Her energy and professionalism made the dining experience even more enjoyable. You can tell she truly loves what she does attentive without being intrusive, friendly, and very well-trained.
The entire team made us feel welcomed and cared for from start to finish. Everything about these two visits reflected quality, hospitality, and great attention to detail.
McAteer & Will Estates Keller Williams Real Estate
After a much-needed break from the real estate hustle, we had the perfect date night at The Homestead Restaurant + Lounge at The Eldred Preserve. A true hidden gem! The grounds were stunning, the atmosphere warm and inviting, and the food absolutely delicious. It’s officially a new favorite spot as this place is a must-visit! It’s rare to find a spot that checks all the boxes: atmosphere, service, scenery, and cuisine but The Homestead delivers on all fronts. ️
… moreS
We had a nice early dinner. Enjoyed the chicken tenders, Caesar salad (love the parm crisp), and the Frenched Chicken Breast. Not a big fan of the wine menu or the Stagg’s Leap Petit Syrah and the OR Pinot Noir we had. The bread offering was tasty! The service was very nice and accommodating. The ambiance is beautiful, fresh and clean.
… moreSmiling Bellies
So we came to The Homestead Restaurant and Lounge for my husband’s 35th birthday and it was an excellent choice on that Sunday Evening!
We had exceptional service from the seasoned waitress who was on staff that night. She was very attentive and quite informative.
The bread basket is phenomenal with an array of breadsticks, cornbread and their made in house cinnamon raisin bread (it’s to die for). I definitely filled up on this before I even got my meal.
The seasonal cider on tap was delicious especially with the cinnamon sugar rim! I opted for the specials that night: Fried Calamari and Tomato Soup. The calamari was soooo good, I wish there was an opportunity to order another but we scooped up the last order of the night.
Tomato Soup was okay, I’ve had more flavorful ones but it sufficed!
My son enjoyed the kids pasta with red sauce which was basically spaghetti!
The potato wedges were massive and extra crunchy so we enjoyed that.
The spinach and artichoke dip was pretty disappointing and quite watery to be a cream based dish. We were rewarded with a new dish bc it looked extremely watery but the replacement wasn’t really any better!
We enjoyed ourselves and are definitely coming back for another Sunday night in the future. This place is beautiful and I’d love to explore the grounds when it’s light outside and not raining.
… moreWe had exceptional service from the seasoned waitress who was on staff that night. She was very attentive and quite informative.
The bread basket is phenomenal with an array of breadsticks, cornbread and their made in house cinnamon raisin bread (it’s to die for). I definitely filled up on this before I even got my meal.
The seasonal cider on tap was delicious especially with the cinnamon sugar rim! I opted for the specials that night: Fried Calamari and Tomato Soup. The calamari was soooo good, I wish there was an opportunity to order another but we scooped up the last order of the night.
Tomato Soup was okay, I’ve had more flavorful ones but it sufficed!
My son enjoyed the kids pasta with red sauce which was basically spaghetti!
The potato wedges were massive and extra crunchy so we enjoyed that.
The spinach and artichoke dip was pretty disappointing and quite watery to be a cream based dish. We were rewarded with a new dish bc it looked extremely watery but the replacement wasn’t really any better!
We enjoyed ourselves and are definitely coming back for another Sunday night in the future. This place is beautiful and I’d love to explore the grounds when it’s light outside and not raining.
Raymond Sosler III
Fantastic Dining Experience from Start to Finish. Delicious Food, Great Drinks and Amazing Atmosphere. Highly Recommend The Homestead Restaurant at Eldred Preserve
… moreMatthew Rodwick
This was my second time coming here and was truly blown away by the surrounding preserve that envelops you thru the floor to second story windows. In March the dining room was not open for the season, so ate at the upstairs bar area. Both spaces are absolutely beautiful and the food was superb as it was in March, just elevated all the more spending time in the dining room. Are waiter Matt was on point and the whole operation of kitchen to table and every thing in between was perfect!!! Worth the trip each and every time!!!!
… moreKrista Rumbaugh
We were guests for at The Bradstan Boutique Hotel for a couple of nights and made reservations for one of the nights at The Eldred Preserve.
Our reservation was for a Thursday at 6:45pm in early November.
Service was extremely slow. We were served our drinks after waiting for almost one hour at our table.
Cocktails were fair. (Presentation/service was poor, clumsy & unprofessional)
Food was mediocre at best. (Cold, overcooked and bland)
Presentation was poor.
Atmosphere excellent.
Manager was professional.
Main bar was excellent and friendly.
Reservations were for a special event they failed to recognize. I had to talk to the waiter privately after desserts were served. I thought he was new, but he had been there for 2 years!
We will revisit the Bradstan Hotel, but dine elsewhere. Maybe check out the main bar for a happy hour cocktail.
… moreOur reservation was for a Thursday at 6:45pm in early November.
Service was extremely slow. We were served our drinks after waiting for almost one hour at our table.
Cocktails were fair. (Presentation/service was poor, clumsy & unprofessional)
Food was mediocre at best. (Cold, overcooked and bland)
Presentation was poor.
Atmosphere excellent.
Manager was professional.
Main bar was excellent and friendly.
Reservations were for a special event they failed to recognize. I had to talk to the waiter privately after desserts were served. I thought he was new, but he had been there for 2 years!
We will revisit the Bradstan Hotel, but dine elsewhere. Maybe check out the main bar for a happy hour cocktail.
Christa L (American Girl Doll)
The food is expensive and did not taste good, Nor was it presented well. Super tiny portion, also disappointing that the online menu isnt the same as the actual menu. Some of the specialty cocktails & zucchini noodles offered, are not actually available. Honestly
I ordered 3 different dishes, it was either sold out, or completely revolting (the turkey soup I couldn’t believe they served something so gross looking/tasting). The absolute best dish among our group was the burger and giant crispy wedge fries. I will never eat there again, however I would return for a drink & enjoy the gardens, grounds, walkways, uplights, firepits. It’s beautiful, the ambience is so relaxed, soothing, upscale. I wanted to give it 5 stars but the food is awful..so disappointed.
… moreI ordered 3 different dishes, it was either sold out, or completely revolting (the turkey soup I couldn’t believe they served something so gross looking/tasting). The absolute best dish among our group was the burger and giant crispy wedge fries. I will never eat there again, however I would return for a drink & enjoy the gardens, grounds, walkways, uplights, firepits. It’s beautiful, the ambience is so relaxed, soothing, upscale. I wanted to give it 5 stars but the food is awful..so disappointed.