Kate Ceraso
Always love trying different mellow mushrooms when I am in a city that has one. This one is pretty big compared to others. Good food and good service. They have a pretty large menu it’s hard to choose. We got a full Italian hoagie, it was mostly lettuce and tomato hardly any meat. We also got the holy shiitake pie. The pizza was delicious I just wish we would’ve gotten the aioli on the side. It was kind of overpowering
… morePam Ella
Loved the pizza and couldn’t wait to pull a slice away to eat. The crust was really good. It had a chewy texture and complemented the sauce, cheese and toppings perfectly. I used the drive up service to pick up our order and the employee was very polite. I forgot photos this time – just to excited to eat!!
… moreJust Inked & Cruisin’
I’ve had a lot of Pizza in my day traveling all over the world. This place by far is second to none. My girlfriend got the taco pizza which that was slamming as well but If you like a little bit of spice get the house special take off the green pepper and add jalapeno. Definitely Scrumpdelilyumptious.
… moreDante Oops
The tables were sticky and dirty, which killed my appetite. Despite it being a quiet Sunday afternoon at 3:00 PM, our food took over 25 minutes to arrive. Poor cleanliness and slow service—won’t be returning.
… moreSarah Smith
Just wanted to say that it’s been years since I have been here and we had a great experience tonight. From the beginning the host was very friendly and inviting. Our waitress Micaela was very sweet and has top tier customer service. She’s very attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. The atmosphere was very chill but the staff seemed like they enjoy being there and the food was excellent.
… moreSheca
Went there after driving 45min to eat and the hostess tried to sit us at a small table. We politely asked for a larger table and it was a problem. We spoke with a manager and she was very nice and told us we can sit at the larger table. After being seated, we heard the black girl saying she didn’t want our table. We waited 10-15 min and still noone came to at least greet us and ask for our drinks. The hostess kept complaining as if she was going to be our waiter. We finally left after feeling unwanted. We drive too far to get treated like this at a place where we are spending money. We were just here last week. Tonight’s experience was a waste of gas and very horrible. We are officially done giving this place business. FIND NEW WAITERS WHO WANTS TO DO THEIR JOBS.
… moreDarius Turner
Always always ALWAYS, great food and service at Mellow Mushroom here in Fayetteville. The staff are patient, attentive and the pizzas are piping hot when served. The holy shiitake pie is my favorite, always look forward to going there!
… moreBrian “CoFii” Adams
Listen, I understand that with a large group food is going to take longer to come out. BUT 2 HOURS is a bit of a stretch. This is a great spot if you got time to kill and nowhere to be.
Pro:
– menu is great
– gluten free
– variety
– drink selection
– environment
– Price is ok
Con:
– service. not just from the servers but kitchen staff. This poor girl was left alone to take a party of 20±. When another server could have helped, and have our orders in the system in half the time. Drinks also took forever to come because this girl was putting in orders into the system for 30 minutes.
Overall it is a great spot if you have a part of 2, and or have no where to be for the day.
… moreisha leonard
We had the GREATEST service with Kale. Her drinks were fantastic and Benjamin help out so much! Also thanks to the Togo Mia for getting me a Togo bag and helping me as well.
… moreG8TRLIZ
First visit to Mellow Mushroom! Eli was a fantastic attentive server, probably the best server we’ve had in a long time! The food was great! Even the pizza crust was yummy! We ordered pretzel bites with mild beer cheese, pepperoni mellow rollz & added hot honey to them, hot wings, holy shitake pizza, mighty meaty pizza, calzone with chicken (up-charge but worth it) with artichokes & spinach, & 4 different alcoholic drinks (all were good). Only issue I (we) had was that the benches do not have cushions & I really couldn’t sit for another drink (FYI Strawberry Shakedown – Amazing!) cause my butt was getting sore : / I’ll bring a pillow next time!! Restrooms were clean! Will definitely return 🙂
… more