Elijah Drug
Yall this place is incredible. Some of the best combo pizza ever and also got a Margherita. Picked up two pizzas here and everything was perfect. The staff was quick and professional, my order was ready the second I walked in, and the pies looked like works of art. The ingredients tasted fresh and homemade, and both pizzas were packed with flavor. Definitely my new go-to spot over here, amazing place.
… moreArlind rama
Been going to this place ever since I was a kid. Never been a let down! They always are kind and get my food out quick. Employees are nice and make sure to write down what you order.
… morePrinceof Peace773
Best two slices I ever had!
I often come and have two slices and just the way I like, I recommend this place % Warm atmosphere and calm environment clean and relaxed, come and enjoy their famous slices you won’t regret it! May this place be blessed and abundant you deserve it. Peace be with you!
… moreRobert M Ferrieri III
Great spot. Right by the train station, easy walk from there. Huge slices, great crust. I did the chicken, , ranch. Highly recommended, great slices.
… moreTori Fonseca
Ordered a Sicilian pie and cheese fries. Pie came like someone sat on it- cheese and sauce on the top of the box with the side of the box partially baked into the pizza. To make matters worse, the cheese fries had scraps of bacon (looks like they were added and poorly removed and unnoticeable) which were for my religious vegetarian husband making him violently ill. When I called the restaurant, I was offered a 10% discount on a future order. Since that was not sufficient, I called door dash for a refund only to discover the restaurant took it upon themselves to issue a $6 refund on a $36 order. They did this to ensure door dash would be unable to refund me any further. This is the wrong way to run a restaurant; they must do this often as they processed this refund before I was even able to get through to door dash customer service. Avoid this place at all costs, much better pizzerias in the area.
… moreNon17
Kathy from 1MR Brewster!! I can’t say enough!! The food is 5 star! DELISH! The service is professional…always willing to help!! Deliveries always on time!! Thank you for always doing your best!! We love you
… moreGeovanny
I’m so blessed to have Pizza Place & Trattoria ll in my neighborhood. I’ve visited so many pizza spots around the country and nothing comes even close to this place. The food, service and atmosphere make this place an absolute gem. Shoutout to everyone working here including the owner, he’s often seen working along his crew and making deliveries!
Besides pizza, Spinach Rolls are a must have!
Clean customer bathroom and tables.
… moreElaine Maggie
The name does have “pizza” in the title so I’m sure they’re probably best at pizzas. We ordered a lasagna and chicken parm which were awesome but the sides were a let down. Stay away from the garlic bread with cheese and the cheese fries.
… moreEnmanuel Arias
One of the best NY style pizza I’ve had at a reasonable price too. The slices were large with a good cheese to sauce ratio. Sauce was a bit acidic, but not overwhelming. The dough was soft and held its form well, crust was crunchy on the outside and soft within. It wasn’t oily either. Their garlic knots were a bit small, but you get 6. They were really soft and not too garlicky. I’d get marinara sauce on the side.
… moreKelley White Wilkinson
THESE PEOPLE ARE AMAZING! I called to get a delivery to my best friend who just got engaged. I asked if they could do a heart shape in pepperoni. Without hesitation they agreed- even though he said they have never done it before. It turned out GREAT! And she was so happy! THANK YOU!
… more