Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Carmelina’s Pizzeria & Gelateria – Amityville, NY – 183 Merrick Rd …
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-10:00 PM; Shop address is 183 Merrick Rd, Amityville, NY 11701183 Merrick Rd, Amityville, NY 11701; (631) 837-2428.
Carmelina’s Pizzeria & Gelateria – View Menu & Order Online – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Amityville, NY! Carmelina’s Pizzeria & Gelateria is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive …
Carmelina’s Pizzeria & Gelateria – Amityville, NY – Seamless
Order with Seamless to support your local restaurants! View menu and reviews for Carmelina’s Pizzeria & Gelateria in Amityville, plus popular items …
Last Updates
Reviews
Anna H
I absolutely love everything we tried. The Thai ch I’lli shrimp outstanding. The crunch of the slice perfection. Ty evening boy sandwiche on semolina fantastic. You know, sometimes you have these sandwiches that are have all of these different things in it and it comes overwhelming. The sandwich was not it. It was perfect and delicious. The espresso ship ice cream was a 10 out of 10
… moreKristine Waller
My husband and I ordered a pizza for pickup – half plain, half meatball. We arrived within the timeframe that was given to us over the phone. When we arrived home minutes later, the pie was ice cold and hard, like it had been sitting out for a long time. It definitely felt like we were given an old pizza instead of a fresh one, despite paying a significant amount of money. Really unacceptable quality — we won’t be ordering from here again unless things improve.
… moremike s
Ordered 2 dinners for delivery, the preparation was very well thought out and hats off to the chef. Ordered the chicken sorrentino with penne and had them add zucchini, peppers, and onions, and everything was unbelievable. It’s not easy to get the ratios and the cuts and all those ingredients to work together and it was out of this world. Delivery was fast.. the guythat took our order was nice ..and really good for fr under 50 bucks . Other dinner was a chicken ceasar wrap . Nice size .. made my night
… moreMichelle Buschor
Nothing but great things to say about this pizzeria. From the food, quality, value and staff, all are AMAZING! We order from them just about every week and our food has always been delicious, never a soggy slice. We also ordered this past holiday season a catering package and everyone loved the food. Their drunken chicken parm was a HUGE hit!
… moreAva Hartung
The new owner has done a fantastic job with this spot “Carmelina’s”! Pizza, food, menu still the same great stuff we love, with a new bright atmosphere. The place looks modern and clean. Staff and owner were attentive to my questions and very friendly. For those curious like me, no fear, I asked and the pizza is still the same recipe!!! Refreshing revamp
is worth being checked out
… moreis worth being checked out
Scott Robalino
Terrible business. I go there twice a week for years since they’ve moved here. Ask to use the bathroom today and get an attitude from the guy behind the counter. Will never go here again. And they just stuff slices in a box that clearly does not fit.
… moreloretta nauth
This new place sucks big time. If they dont live up to their customers expectations they WILL go out of business. We were always somewhat satisfied with Parisi’s, but now its much much worse tjan Parisi’s. We, just a few minutes ago ordered to takout, eggplant parm, a gyro, and rice balls, and asked for lite red sauce and they still put too much red sauce, and the gyro is so hard its unchewable and the rice balls are over fried. I am so very disappointed!!! Ive never heard of Carmelita’s before but I am NEVER going back there. Their food is worse than a food cart.
… morekathryn ludwig
I have had Parisi’s cater a couple of parties for me and we order from them often and the food is usually delicious and delivery is quick. That being said, we have also gotten food that has been disappointing. Consistency seems to be an issue, you can order a dish that you really enjoyed the first time so you order it again and it doesn’t compare. I am hoping they can fix this.
… moreNemo G
Pizza is subpar at best. prices are INSANE. There’s a whole case of different pizzas to choose from which is a little overwhelming if you’ve never been there, and they rush you to order.
… moreEddie Momma
The best pizza!! So glad I randomly ordered your pizza one night bc you were open late. I now have my whole family ordering from you! They all love it! Grew up on massapequa pizzas, but yours out does everyone’s locally! Always fresh, any day of the week! Pasta dishes are really great too! Fast delivery. Never had a bad order from you! Thanks for staying consistently great!
… more