Address and Contact Information
Address: 1415 E Michigan Rd, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Phone: (317) 392-4371
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Fiddler’s Three – CLOSED, 1415 E Michigan Rd, Shelbyville, IN …
Fiddler’s Three is a cozy establishment in Shelbyville, IN that offers a unique dining experience. With a focus on traditional cuisine and a welcoming …
The Fiddlers Three – Tales from the Trail Blog | Indiana Foodways …
Fiddlers Three is one of those stories true local business that has been a stand out in Shelbyville. Kathy De Moss shared her Dad’s story …
Fiddlers Three restaurant in Shelbyville, IN review – Facebook
The Good: Service was quick, the waitress was friendly, and my root beer was tasty. If first impressions were just about friendliness, they’d be …
Reviews
Nathan Harris
My wife and I came on a Saturday night for our anniversary dinner and had a wonderful time. The service was very professional. The bread brought to the table was the best ever! The shrimp cocktail appetizer was ok, and the lobster bisque was perfect! I had the fried chicken which I enjoyed, and my wife had the grouper which was also good!
… moreLonnie Phillips
The food was not very good. The lobster tails were fatty and the worst I have ever had. The crab cakes tasted bad. The service was not very good.
For the price I expected a lot better food and service.
Not a place I will visit again.
… moreFor the price I expected a lot better food and service.
Not a place I will visit again.
Rhonda Herman
Took some friends as they had never been before. We were excited to introduce them to the experience. We have gone 4 times prior 2 good experiences and 2 not so good…It’s the business and you expect sometimes it happens.
We get in right away, get seated, Server was Amazing and got our cocktails, 2 of which they couldn’t drink, again no biggie server corrected. We ordered appetizers, the crab cakes were charred, the mushrooms, and shrimp cocktail great! We got our food in a timely manner however my prime was cold ,my sister in law got the Cajun shrimp pasta, the two men got the breaded shrimp dinners.
Her dish was soooo spicy hot it wasn’t even editable. The pasta was mush. The guys sides were also cold…
Keep in mind the server was extremely accommodating (not her fault).
As a customer and previous restaurant owner, you know stuff happens and again you try to give benefit of doubt.
Needless to say Our guest will not return in the future, and after 5 visits, 3 being poor, We too will not be returning.
It is such a neat place, and I hear at one time was consistently very good… The place to go for finer dining.
Was truly hoping for a better outcome…
Best of luck.
Thank you.
… moreWe get in right away, get seated, Server was Amazing and got our cocktails, 2 of which they couldn’t drink, again no biggie server corrected. We ordered appetizers, the crab cakes were charred, the mushrooms, and shrimp cocktail great! We got our food in a timely manner however my prime was cold ,my sister in law got the Cajun shrimp pasta, the two men got the breaded shrimp dinners.
Her dish was soooo spicy hot it wasn’t even editable. The pasta was mush. The guys sides were also cold…
Keep in mind the server was extremely accommodating (not her fault).
As a customer and previous restaurant owner, you know stuff happens and again you try to give benefit of doubt.
Needless to say Our guest will not return in the future, and after 5 visits, 3 being poor, We too will not be returning.
It is such a neat place, and I hear at one time was consistently very good… The place to go for finer dining.
Was truly hoping for a better outcome…
Best of luck.
Thank you.
Jennifer Turner
We had a fantastic meal; everything was great. The prime rib is phenomenal, as are the fish and the grilled pork chops. Friendly service, a really fun setting, and amazing desserts made by a talented pastry chef. A real treasure.
… moreBen St. Vincent
Waiting staff was very friendly and accommodating, about the only great thing about our experience unfortunately.
The food here was simply below average. Mac n cheese tasted like it was microwaved. Fried food was disgusting, no one at our table would it. I would just expect a little more for the price we paid.
… moreThe food here was simply below average. Mac n cheese tasted like it was microwaved. Fried food was disgusting, no one at our table would it. I would just expect a little more for the price we paid.
Steve Bredemann
Girlfriend took me here for date night, so wasn’t sure what to expect.
Food was outstanding!! I had the crab/shrimp stuffed ravioli, with a side of spinach and a baked potato. Everything was top notch. Potato had the perfectly cooked skin, one could eat the whole thing, which I did. Bread was fresh and delicious. Service was splendid with several personal touches. Very impressed by my first visit.
… moreFood was outstanding!! I had the crab/shrimp stuffed ravioli, with a side of spinach and a baked potato. Everything was top notch. Potato had the perfectly cooked skin, one could eat the whole thing, which I did. Bread was fresh and delicious. Service was splendid with several personal touches. Very impressed by my first visit.
Peggy Bailey
I think at one time this was a wonderful place but it has seen better days. We waited for quite some time for anyone to realize we were there to begin with. The carpets are stained, it’s dark, and is starting to fall into disrepair. The food is expensive too, we just had appetizers, no alcohol and the bill was still $70.00. It could be a charmer, but it needs an overhaul and an owner that cares about it.
… moreChad McClellan
Great place for fried chicken and prime rib. Neat old style decor, like an old house inside as there’s a few tables in each large room. Upscale type place, bit pricey, but very tasty food. Service was OK, not best, but not the slowest either.
The lobster bisque was great, food presentation was very pleasant, and taste was excellent, shrimp cocktail and sauce was very good. Nice place for a nice upscale dinner.
… moreThe lobster bisque was great, food presentation was very pleasant, and taste was excellent, shrimp cocktail and sauce was very good. Nice place for a nice upscale dinner.
Morgan Combs
The food here is terrible! Certainly not worth the time or money to go there. I was shocked that they had such terrible food for such high prices! It almost feels like we got robbed. No joke. They took my meal off the bill, but even then it was $52 for one person and an appetizer! My fiancé didn’t like his meal either. If you are looking for a new place to try I recommend anywhere but here in town. I’ve never been so disappointed in my life.
… moremary zywar
We met at Fiddlers 3 for supper last night.
We knew they had outside seating so that greatly appealed to us because of Covid. It was kind of an impromptu family reunion with us from Massachusetts and family from Kentucky and Indiana as well. Because of the intense heat we realized we couldn’t sit outside comfortably. The manager and staff couldn’t have been more accommodating and sweet!!! We had an indoors room pretty much to ourselves! Needless to say we were sincerely grateful and a wonderful evening was had by all!! I highly recommend the fried chicken and the lobster bisque and the clam chowder!!
… moreWe knew they had outside seating so that greatly appealed to us because of Covid. It was kind of an impromptu family reunion with us from Massachusetts and family from Kentucky and Indiana as well. Because of the intense heat we realized we couldn’t sit outside comfortably. The manager and staff couldn’t have been more accommodating and sweet!!! We had an indoors room pretty much to ourselves! Needless to say we were sincerely grateful and a wonderful evening was had by all!! I highly recommend the fried chicken and the lobster bisque and the clam chowder!!