Address and Contact Information
Address: 144 Genesee St, New Hartford, NY 13413
Phone: (315) 797-9806
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Prop’s Inn | New Hartford NY – Facebook
Prop’s Inn, New Hartford. 1662 likes · 9 talking about this · 7 were here. Prop’s Inn and Bar, 144 Genesee Street New Hartford Kitchen open Mon…
Prop’s Inn Menu (Updated 2026) – Wheree
Prop’s Inn, located in New Hartford, NY, has earned a reputation for its incredible menu and vibrant atmosphere. This local tavern offers a …
Prop’s Inn – Bar & grill in New Hartford – Website
Prop’s Inn stands as a beloved local tavern that marries nostalgic charm with delightful culinary offerings, earning its reputation as one …
Reviews
Mike Fase
A very quaint small tavern / restaurant that I was extremely pleased to have tried. The waiter recommended the stacked ham sandwich which was excellent. Ordered onion rings that was like a double order anywhere else.
… moreRoy Lawrence
Stopped in late afternoon during the week. Bar was full of people just getting done with work. Others were coming and going either sliding in the mint green vinyl booths, love it, or picking up orders to go. Everyone commented on how good the food was when they left.
This place looks like it hasn’t changed from the 60’s. Which is a testament on how they care and take care if the place.
These types of bars are harder and harder to find. A real neighborhood bar. Everyone knew everyone else except me. I chatted up a couple gentlemen next to me and someone else bought the bar a round and included me.
I will stop by next time I’m in town and definitely eat. They even had Molson Canadian!! Double bonus.
Bartender and customers all friendly and engaging.
… moreThis place looks like it hasn’t changed from the 60’s. Which is a testament on how they care and take care if the place.
These types of bars are harder and harder to find. A real neighborhood bar. Everyone knew everyone else except me. I chatted up a couple gentlemen next to me and someone else bought the bar a round and included me.
I will stop by next time I’m in town and definitely eat. They even had Molson Canadian!! Double bonus.
Bartender and customers all friendly and engaging.
Ed Netzband
A warm and inviting atmosphere is what we always have experienced there. The wait staff are attentive. The Ruben is to die for good!! The beer is ice cold. The owner is engaging and friendly to everyone. I will continue to stop here every time I visit my family in the area!
… moreStewart Farwell
Haven’t been there in over 15 years. Came with my family and had such a wonderful experience. The food was amazing, service top notch and friendly and the price was just right. We will be making this a regular stop for a family bite out.
… moreLori Rivecca
Props never disappoints! Great bartenders…atmosphere..and food…just love it there!
… moreCathy Sommers
Prop Burger was HUGE! Hubby loves the tater tots! Pulled Pork outstanding. My favorite, along with the coleslaw!
… moreYetuh
Service was super personable, they always are down to just have a conversation. Environment was lively. Food was delicious: they don’t have a big menu, but what they do have is made to perfection with the love & care you only get at a local spot
… moreMarion
The food was amazing. Our waitress was the sweetest little blonde who was so nice. I am non verbal, she took her time to make sure I had what I needed and wanted. The atmosphere will take you back in time . So cool. Very clean. We will be back for sure .
… moreMatt Smith
Been going here a few years. The food here is incredible. The wings are the best around and I’ve been everywhere. All the food is world class packed into this small bar room setting its perfect. Perfect hiding spot for the best food around. Great people and atmosphere.
… moreMark Dunn
Very nice local tavern. Food is very good and service is excellent as well. More of a bar menu, but the daily specials make up for that. Worth a try to see if your pallet agrees. Very fair prices that add value.
… more