Rachel Stepanik
One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. The owner hooked me up with a free pizza after commenting on a Facebook post they had regarding a giveaway.
I had never tried Pudgie’s before but after tasting this delicious pizza, my husband and I both agreed it was one of the best pies we’ve ever had. Sweet yet savory sauce, super cheesy, and great dough.
Even my picky toddler loved it. Thanks for making a pregnant momma happy! We will definitely be returning customers.
… moreDavid Snyder
I had a employee bring the pizza and wings for the staff and the pizza looked amazing. So I brought my family of 5 to try the pizza and wings. Not a let down. Well worth trying. Very awesome , great food. Will be back I swear on that.
… moreChristine Clark
Food was good. Pricing really good. Service a bit slow. Had to remind staff about missed item on our order.
… moreDavid Anderson
I really really love pudgies and their delicious food haven’t been here in a while but I plan to come again soon, great job Pudgies you’re awesome!!!
… moreTopher Ellis
I can appreciate that this may be a long standing and traditional pizza place in the small town of Williamsport, PA. Its an older location with faded photos and decor which may have not been updated in decades. It’s clean though and the staff is very friendly.
Pizza is average. Very greasy and everything slides off when you take a bite. I do like the charm of it and i think they should not update the decor at this point as it does have a small town / old time pizza restaurant charm to it.
… moreRyan
It was my first time going here. I asked for a pepperoni and bacon but got a pepperoni and sausage instead. To be fair, it was still pretty tasty.
… moreKevin Lansberry
Stopped here after the grandkids football game. It was suggested that we go here. We got pizza and wings and I have to say that the wings were crispy, large, and very temperature hot and sauce was flavorful. The pizza was very tasty as well. There was plenty of cheese, the sauce is very tasty, and the crust reminds me of a pan pizza even though it’s not. The staff is very friendly and helpful. There is public restrooms and a decent amount of parking. There is also a drive thru for pick ups. I recommend stopping here if your in the Williamsport area.
… moreRose C
This place has the best pizza I’ve ever had it’s a known thing with my family that this place is the best we’ve literately been in town 3 hours away and carried the whole huge box 3 hours just because it’s so good I 100 percent recommend on my gosh it’s so nostalgic!
… moreRyan DeWire
Pudgies Pizza is the best! I have been going here for over 25+ years. Absolutely love the sheet pizza, wings and soda combo. Every time I am in Williamsport a Pudgies stop is on the itinerary!
… moreJustin
I drive 20 miles to get this pizza. It’s amazing when it’s done right. The past two times the cheese has been bare in some spots, before this we stopped ordering pepperoni because we were only getting about a dozen pieces in a large for $3.50! Now it’s looking like the cheese is disappearing too.
Incredibly disappointed. Think we are done driving down for this.
… more