Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5526 Main St, Williamsville, NY 14221
Phone: (716) 204-9020
Website: https://www.muscarellaspizzeria.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Muscarella’s Pizza Williamsville NY
Indulge in Williamsville’s beloved Muscarella’s Pizza, a local favorite renowned for its classic, delicious pizza. Experience the ease of curbside pickup …
Muscarella’s Pizza: Pizza Buffalo NY With Locations in Lancaster …
Delight in authentic Italian cuisine at Muscarella’s Pizzeria, serving Buffalo, Williamsville, and Lancaster. Enjoy our homemade pizzas and classic dishes!
Muscarella’s Pizza – 5526 Main St, Williamsville, NY 14221 – Slice
Picked for You · Best seller. Cheese Pizza. Classic cheese and pepperoni or create your own pizza. $14.94 · Best seller. Chicken Wings. Comes with bleu cheese …
Reviews
Sree Anumolu
Got a chicken finger pizza without blue cheese. Very attentive staff asking what we would like for substitution. Great tasting pizza and super cheesy (just the way I like it). Would have given 5 star if the crust was baked a little more and was crunchy
… moreKimberly O’Meara
Best Buffalo style Pizza in WNY! Hands down! I have had tons of Buffalo pizza and this place is my favorite. It has the most flavor in a pizza. I also love the crispy pepperonis. It’s a hidden gem of a place and a must try! This place is my favorite and Picasso’s is my second. All other Buffalo pizza is tied for third.
… moreSiddhant Aggarwal
Tried a small pizza (good for 2), and it was incredible. Soft crust and finely chopped toppings take the taste to another level. Love it.
… moreKyle Matesic
First time trying this place. Ordered online. Picked up no issue. Open the box and I laugh and shake my head everytime I see this. Square box. Circle shaped pizza cut in squares. IMO only pizza to be cut in squares should be sheets. Despite the un preferable cutting style this pizza was delicious. Great cook. Amazing cup n char. Perfect ratio of cheese to sauce. Crust was great. This was a fantastic pizza. Thank you
… moreMarshaun Quinniey
Great service! Great food! Great location! Great special 2 slices for $10 with a soda!
… moreLo Rivera
This is legit the best pizza I’ve ever had. The cup pepperoni was cooked perfectly. The garlic crust on the pizza is AMAZING. Honey mustard & Italian wings are also excellent. All the food got delivered still hot. I’ll definitely be back.
… moreRocco DelGrosso
The honey sesame crust pizza is my favorite in all of buffalo. Always delicious and consistent. Highly recommend
… moreLindsay D’Arcy
Found this in our pizza today, and the manager insisted we put it in there because they only have blue bandaid in their store. Refunded our money but stated it was just because we wanted free pizza. Terrible customer service and this is beyond disgusting. The owner just called me back to argue because he’s mad I put a bad review on Facebook. Sorry, getting my money back for this pizza is just not enough, who knows what’s on that bandaid. I understand mistakes happen, but if there was better customer service I never would have badly rated this company.This was the lancaster location. For the record, you can look back on my Google reviews, never have I ever given a bad review….I didn’t lie just to get your 20 dollar pizza for free.
… moreLouise Miller
First time trying this place…. and so happy I did!! The pizza was full of toppings and the wings were still crispy after the drive home(40+ minutes). Definitely a place I will order from again. Thank you for a wonderful experience.
… morediana gangarossa
My husb and I finally found our go to pizzeria. Sometimes you just want to order a pie and have it hit the spot and this place delivers that! Absolutely delicious pizza
… more