Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Hours
| Monday | 9 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 9 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 9 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 9 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 9 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 9 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 9 AM–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 103 S Randolph St, Garrett, IN 46738
Phone: (260) 494-4351
Website: http://www.sugarandicegarrett.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
sugar and ice: Home
Sugar + Ice is a locally owned dessert destination dedicated to bringing joy, creativity, and viral flavors to Garrett and the surrounding communities. We’re …
Sugar + Ice | Garrett IN – Facebook
Sugar + Ice, Garrett. 4629 likes · 194 talking about this · 65 were here. Your go-to sugar stop since 2025 Ice Cream • Italian Ice • Milkshakes •…
Sugar + Ice (@sugarandicegarrett) • Instagram photos and videos
Shaved Ice • Italian Ice • Gourmet Milkshakes Garrett, IN Your go-to sugar stop since 2025. Photo by Sugar + Ice in Sugar + Ice. May be an image of gelato …
Reviews
Delanie Lorenz
My fiancé and I just absolutely adore this place! The first time we came, we were greeted by Grandpa, who was truly the friendliest and made us feel at home! We tried the 3D Strawberry and the Chocolate Bear (photo posted!) and they were both phenomenal! We just went back last night and got the Strawberry and Mango 3D fruit, as well as ice cream, and one of the owners, Colton, was there and was extremely kind. I just love this little gem in the town of Garrett, what a fun place to go on a date or take the whole family! Great vibes, great treats, we will definitely be back!
… moreTom Boyer
I tried this cute newish place after dinner. The interior is bright and cozy, with lots of cute sweet and savory snacks in addition to the ice cream and Italian ice. After chatting with the owner, I found out they roast their own nuts and will be making fresh donuts starting next weekend. I can’t wait to come back.
… moreAmanda Miller
I’ve been dying to try the viral pastries and finally somewhere near me has them! Sugar + ice is amazing. The service we received was incredible. The pastries 1000/10 highly recommend checking this place out if you haven’t yet.
… morePam Lake
I recently visited Sugar + Ice and tried the viral pastries. They absolutely lived up to the hype. The service was just as amazing! Friendly, welcoming, and quick. It was such a great experience from start to finish. I will definitely be back and highly recommend stopping in if you haven’t yet.
… moreCathy Yoder Roark
I had a 3-D lemon treat while here. The owner of the shop was friendly, personable, and knowledgeable about the products in his shop. I absolutely loved the lemon pastry while my friend had the coffee chocolate chip ice cream in a sugar cone. We will definitely be back to try other flavors and items! You will not be disappointed.
… moreChloe Wacasey
Genuinely the best bakery/candy place I’ve ever been to; I’m pretty sure the owners dad served us, he was very nice, explained in great detail everything about where the pastries came from and what they contained. So many selections for not too bad of a price. I got the coconut, blueberry, and the bear. All 10/10. The blueberry had actual blueberries inside which made the texture irresistible, I tried saving more for later but I just couldn’t!! Exactly what I expected and worth the hype..I will be revisiting.
… moreAshley Rickman
Cutest little dessert and candy shop. I went for the viral pastries and they were pricey, but delicious. My kids and I agreed that the strawberry was our favorite. We will definitely stop by again the next time we are in town
… moreJust So Kay
From the moment you walk in you are greeted with a warm smile from any of the staff! There are tons of choices from Italian ice, shaved ice, and ice cream both dairy and dairy free! There are lots of popcorn options, kernel in or popped, candy galore and even cute candles which smell heavenly. Creamy perfection is the best way to describe the ice cream. The staff? Super friendly and happy to offer samples until you find your favorite. If you have even thought about going here— GO! Here pictured are my all time favorite cheesecake bowls!
… morepaige fugate
Sugar + Ice is the perfect place to satisfy your sweet tooth! Whether it be a dessert after family dinner or a mid day pick me up, you’ll just what you are looking for! They carry a variety of products ranging from cheesecake, specialty nuts, gourmet rice crispies, ice cream, italian ice and shaved ice! It is worth the stop if you are from near or far! The owners just add the cherry on top of the experience ❤️
… moreHolly
We stopped on a spur of the moment and got ice cream. We were gonna keep driving decided we love the coffee so much why not. The guy working was so nice! The ice cream was so good! They even had candy from other countries!
… more