Victor Cesari
Stopped by Tony’s Pizza in the Flagler area and it hit the spot. I had a jumbo slice—big, satisfying, and exactly what you want from a classic pizza joint. The vibe was cool too, especially the NYC mural on the wall that gives it that authentic New York feel. Simple, tasty, and laid-back. Would definitely go back.
… moreTravis Luther
Whether you’re local or just passing through town, Tony’s is the place to stop, From pizzas to pastas and my personal favorite, the calzone. I ordered the meat calzone add mushrooms and it’s by far the best I’ve had locally. If you haven’t been here before it’s time you start if you’ve been here before it’s time to leave A review. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
… moreJonah Fink
Tony’s is the best around. Not only the food but the service too. Our server Ella was amazing and so attentive. Luis was the chef and our food was 100/10. Pictures say it all!
… morePaul Herringshaw
Got there 20 minutes before they closed and they still were very friendly, the girl behind the counter and the worker in the kitchen. I ordered the cheese still and medium pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms. They had me out the door in 15 minutes and again I apologized for ordering so late since I got there 20 minutes before they closed and they were both friendly and said don’t worry about it. I tell you what that this was the best pizza I ever had since living here in Florida hands down and the cheese stix were pretty good to. Would definitely recommend and will be back on a regular basis
… moreLittle Elliott Lloyd & Justine LaClair
I’m a New Yorker and trying to find good pizza is very difficult when not in NYC. These folks did not let us down. Bonus: Gorgeous Mural on the wall includes Times square, verrazano narrows, Statue of Liberty, empire State building and other nostalgic iconic places in NYC.
… moreElise Smith
My kids love Tony’s so much that they wanted to say their review! Kid 1 – “It is the best pizza place in the world!” Kid 2 – “I love the mural on the wall, the pizza, and the garlic knots!” Kid 3 – “The garlic knots are the best! I love eating at Tony’s!” Tony’s is consistent, delicious, high quality pizza and other food, and we love this local, family owned pizzaria!!
… moreL Cardinal
We were excited to dine here for lunch. We all enjoyed our meals. They sell pizza by the slice and have many options to choose from. We also ordered subs and they were delicious. My only complaint was the server. She made it clear that she was unhappy with us and had a bad attitude for most of our dining experience. When she brought me my meal, she didn’t place it in front of me, but put it one seat over. My party consisted of three older ladies. I don’t understand why she acted the way she did. It was shameful. I really enjoyed my meal, but because of the way we were treated by the waitress, I would not recommend this restaurant.
… moreTim (XXX)
WOW, I won’t even recommend something, it all looked amazing, the pizza I got the one that has the word I cannot spell, neoplatain, I think, is delicious, then oops, I forgot to order garlic knots, they were in the bag anyway, Super friendly staff, the stuff I got was for two, and none of it made it home. It really is amazing pizza, as someone from the north, I think I’m a professional on pizza, it really is worth going, I just wish I asked their names. The young lady at the counter was very friendly. So was he, but she is cuter.
… moreElli –
The pizza and the garlic rolls were very delicious! I will undoubtedly come back again to try out some more pizzas. I absolutely LOVED the buffalo and margarita pizza!! I also enjoyed the peaceful atmosphere and the very nice chef and servers.
… moreJoe Joe
Best pizza hands down in Northeast Florida. The crust is beyond words. Once you take a bite you instantly taste freshness in the products in the pizza.
The chicken wings are crunchy and right out of the fryer. No after taste as found in chicken wings sold at other establishments. And, NOT frozen!!
Prices are quite reasonable in comparison with other similar establishments in Northeast Florida.
You get what you pay for and at this pizzeria you get more for your buck.
Overall, Tony’s is awesome!!
… more