Kuffer
I was there on 1/13/2026 at 8:30 pm to get a hot sub and I had a ridiculously great experience. Everyone was very friendly and personable. Previously I had a negative experience at this location with one of the employees which discouraged me from returning, especially before closing and buying a hot sub on the stove, but on this night everyone was extremely kind and just seemed happy. Really made an impact on my impression of the place and the taste of my sandwich
… moreKaren brown
There is a very handsome young man with beautiful blue eyes who works here, and every time I come in he has such a great attitude and is always so friendly. He makes the most delicious sandwiches, and the atmosphere of this place is truly wonderful. It’s always a pleasure coming here.
… moreBecca McCrindle
Great experience at this location. Nick and Dan were so pleasant and greeted all costumers with a smile and warm welcome. Store was clean. Staff was incredibly friendly and knowledgeable.
… moreBob Gleason
I ordered 3 subs online – my order was ready when expected. Everything was perfect, better than other Jersey Mike’s locations I have tried. A great experience.
… moreRobin S
Got the #13, The Orginal Italian on Rosemary Parm bread. Fantastic. Loads of meat and tasty provolone cheese. We got it Mike’s Way and it was perfect. Nice selection of chips and I appreciate the Diet Dr. Pepper choice on the fountain pop machine. Also added a deli pickle, and I liked how they cut it and let me pick which one I wanted out of the jar. The staff was really friendly. Will be back, often.
… moreDenise Ibarra
A new manager with blonde hair and blue eyes was super rude/ mean. They messed up my order and they didn’t remake it. I asked him nicely and calmly if they can remake it, but he said “No I should go get my sandwich somewhere else” since “I was being the rude one”. I’ve been coming to this Jersey Mike’s in Buffalo Grove for so many years. All the employees have been nice, but this one really acting immature.
… moreJoseph Arenson
Quenton and Dan were awesome, amazing service, high quality food. Best jersey mikes around.
… moreMelanie Nigliazzo
Managers/employees close up an hour early almost every night. Jersey mikes is a chain, not a mom and pop shop. It’s weird that you close whenever you feel like it.
… moreHarmony G
My husband went in to get me a sandwich it was cold, and it had a hair in it so we asked for a refund. They said they could not see the hair so he showed them a picture.
… moremayra ortiz
I love Jersey Mikes! The reason I’m giving 3 stars is because what’s the whole point of doing an online order if the employees don’t read the instructions? I placed my online order during my lunch break spend over $30! I always get my subs mikes way with jalapeños and got a dry sub with NO flavor! Next time I’ll just drive to the Mount Prospect location!
… more