Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Discover a taste of authentic Italian cuisine at La Bella Pizzeria. We pride ourselves on crafting delectable pizzas using only the finest, freshest ingredients. Our cozy and inviting atmosphere provides the perfect setting for a memorable meal with family and friends. Join us and experience a slice of Italy right here in the heart of Oyster Bay, where every bite is a celebration of flavor and tradition.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 342 Lexington Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
Phone: (516) 226-1440
Website: https://labellapizza.net/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
La Bella Pizza & Italian Restaurant | Oyster Bay, NY
You’ve Tried the Rest, Now Try the Best! Authentic Italian cuisine made with the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes passed down through …
La Bella Pizzeria – Oyster Bay, NY Restaurant | Menu + Delivery
Fresh Baked Paninis & Wraps · Chicken Panini · $11.44 · Fried Eggplant Panini · $11.44 · Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap · $14.89 · Chicken Greek Salad Wrap · $14.89 …
342 Lexington Avenue, Oyster Bay NY 11771 – Instagram
Photo by La Bella Pizzeria on May 21, 2025.
Reviews
Bryan B.
Outstanding.
La Bella is the newest pizza place in town, and I must add – THE BEST!!
I grew up in NJ where they had very unique slices of to-go Pizza (Veal, Tortellini, Chicken Caeser, etc.) I’d order one during my lunch breaks.
La Bella has gone above & beyond to bring “NJ creations” back to life here in Oyster Bay. You can call in an order and they will accommodate any request if it’s possible.
Mr. Frank said “if you think of it, we can make it” and that has been the case since I’ve purchased from this establishment. This is how you run a business !!!
The pizza is top notch. You can tell the chef(s) have experience making a great pie. The last place in La Bella’s location was an atrocity ! I’m so glad La Bella opened and showed how NY pizza should truly be made.
Best of luck to Mr. Frank & Chef Francesco . Thank you for making our weekly Pizza nights the best we could enjoy.
-Bryan B. (customer)
… moreLa Bella is the newest pizza place in town, and I must add – THE BEST!!
I grew up in NJ where they had very unique slices of to-go Pizza (Veal, Tortellini, Chicken Caeser, etc.) I’d order one during my lunch breaks.
La Bella has gone above & beyond to bring “NJ creations” back to life here in Oyster Bay. You can call in an order and they will accommodate any request if it’s possible.
Mr. Frank said “if you think of it, we can make it” and that has been the case since I’ve purchased from this establishment. This is how you run a business !!!
The pizza is top notch. You can tell the chef(s) have experience making a great pie. The last place in La Bella’s location was an atrocity ! I’m so glad La Bella opened and showed how NY pizza should truly be made.
Best of luck to Mr. Frank & Chef Francesco . Thank you for making our weekly Pizza nights the best we could enjoy.
-Bryan B. (customer)
Vinny Zukowski
Best pizza in Oyster Bay, hands down. I’m here at least once a week Tonight we went with a grandma pie (12 slices — which you almost never see) half sausage, & broccoli rabe. They hooked us up with garlic knots on the house too Food is always on point, people are always super nice. Can’t wait to actually sit down for dinner here soon. ❤️
… moreLife of Agony N.Y.H.C
New owners have completely remade this location and brought back the great food that the original owners had. The pasta is amazing and I’ve tried almost every type. The garlic bread is amazing also. If you tried the previous owners and gave up give the new owners a try I guarantee you won’t regret it
… moreRosanna Shooshtary
La Bella Pizza did not disappoint! Old school Italian atmosphere- Frank and Anthony greeted us with yummy garlic knots, homemade bread and meatballs that were amazing. Then, came pizza straight outta the oven! Mama Mia! We will be back!
… moreS Patrick
First time visit just by chance. I’ll be a regular customer, for sure! Can’t say enough good things about this place! I took a chance based on the solid, 100% 5-Star reviews and was not disappointed. My family ordered a good cross section of menu items – everything was exemplary! The pizza was well crafted, too. For Italian take-out, our family normally makes a weekly 1-hour+ round trip from Eastern Nassau County to Queens. The restaurant was also spotlessly clean and the hospitality was a knockout. DO YOURSELF A FAVOR, DON’T PASS THIS PLACE BY!!!! THERE’S NO CHANCE THAT YOU’LL BE DISAPPOINTED!
… moreJoseph Graziosi
Pizza was excellent. Lots of choices. Service was top notch. The dining area was comfortable and extremely clean. Give them a try you won’t regret it.
… moreNora Boromisza
The pizza is absolutely incredible—perfectly crisp crust, fresh ingredients, and creative toppings that make each bite better than the last. You can taste the care and quality in every slice.
What really makes La Bella special, though, are the owners. They’re warm, welcoming, and clearly passionate about what they do.
If you haven’t been yet—go! You’ll be glad you did.
The vodka grandma is absolutely delicious!!
… moreWhat really makes La Bella special, though, are the owners. They’re warm, welcoming, and clearly passionate about what they do.
If you haven’t been yet—go! You’ll be glad you did.
The vodka grandma is absolutely delicious!!
Jack Bloom
Really solid slice! The inside is beautiful and the owners are very kind, gave us a free garlic knot. Would definitely recommend!
… moreM S
This is the best pizza I have had since being in Italy! The flavor of the dough, the sauce, everything! Always fresh, always amazing!
… morecrystalyn stuart
After a recco from our neighbor we tried La Bella for a big end of season party! We got 10 pizzas and three dozen knots and it was outstanding!! The grandma vodka is exceptional (we love Umbertos and this gives them a run for thier money), the white broccoli is delicious and everyone complimented the cheese and pepperoni. Service was great and on time for pick up! Def recommend!
… more