Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 259 Fish Pond Rd # 506, Sewell, NJ 08080
Phone: (856) 589-4422
Website: http://myanthonys.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Anthony’s Pizza | Sewell NJ
Let Us Do The Cooking For Your Next Party or Event! VIEW OUR PARTY TRAY MENU · CONTACT US. HOURS. Monday CLOSED Tuesday – Thursday 11AM-9PM Friday & …
Anthony’s Pizza – Sewell, NJ – 259 Fish Pond Rd – Hours, Menu, Order
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Anthony’s Pizza in Sewell, NJ. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Anthony’s Pizza – 259 Fish Pond Rd, Sewell, NJ 08080 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Sewell, NJ! Anthony’s Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy your …
Reviews
Tee N
This place has really bad customer service. $30+ for a burnt and bitter pizza. When I called, they said they checked the pizza before sending it off with DoorDash. Did the pizza get burnt in the car or something? Every piece looked like this, and it was practially inedible. It was a waste of my money.
… moreJr Jimenez
First time and certainly not the last eating there I ordered the cheesteak club and the buffalo chicken tenders. The sandwich was fantastic and the tenders were delicious. Everything was well prepared and when I finished eating, I had to call and thank them. Thank you and I will be ordering again soon.
… moreGreg Olson
My new pizza place! Close to home is a bonus. So sorry I didn’t find Anthony’s sooner. Others are right- great tasting pie with perfectly crispy crust. I love Buffalo chicken pizza & try it everywhere I go. Anthony’s has nailed it. Best Buffalo chicken pizza hands down. Prices are very very reasonable and they also have great specials. See you again soon Anthony’s!
… moreAsh G
Pizza tastes like little Caesars, cheese fries are gross, the wings were okay they would have been better if they were fresh you could tell they weren’t they were probably warmed in the microwave. There was a rude staff member who had a tone with us because we hear her at first. This was definitely not worth the price I’d advise going somewhere else.
… moreBrandon Losover
Anthony’s is usually our go to but the past few times have been very disappointing — feels like the staff is barely trying. We ordered a chicken and regular cheesesteak, both barely had any cheese, was basically just meat and onions. Then we ordered a few slices of cheese, took it home (5 min away) and it was cold, barely any cheese on it and tiny slices. The pricing they charge they need to do better service for their customers, especially loyal ones.
… moreRobert Clark
I’ve been coming to this place for years and it’s always good and the guys working there Are always the same guys and friendly. Best pizza in Township.
… morejoe tucci
Pizza back in the day when Anthony and his brother Andrew owned it. Pizza was much better. Pizza is horrible now.
… moreM M
I am 41 years old. In my life never have i walked into a pizza place at dinner time and asked for two plain slices and been told flat out no they didn’t have any plain slices. It is 5:45 on a Tuesday and i was told they would not be making anymore plain
Pizzas for the rest of the night by the girl at the counter. She said its 6pm and they get slower so they don’t make anymore pizzas. I literally was dumbfounded by what i was hearing. I asked what time they closed and she said 9. So from 6-9 you cannot get a single slice of pizza from Anthonys apparently. I asked for the manager and he said they were backed up and could make a pizza and have it ready in 10 mins. Out of principle i walked out and did not give them my business based on what the counter girl told me. That was the dumbest thing i have ever heard at a pizza place in my life. If its dinner time and u want pizza go somewhere else bc they wont have it lol crazy. Went to another pizza place and they had plenty of slices to offer. I will tell anyone who will listen about this experience
… morePizzas for the rest of the night by the girl at the counter. She said its 6pm and they get slower so they don’t make anymore pizzas. I literally was dumbfounded by what i was hearing. I asked what time they closed and she said 9. So from 6-9 you cannot get a single slice of pizza from Anthonys apparently. I asked for the manager and he said they were backed up and could make a pizza and have it ready in 10 mins. Out of principle i walked out and did not give them my business based on what the counter girl told me. That was the dumbest thing i have ever heard at a pizza place in my life. If its dinner time and u want pizza go somewhere else bc they wont have it lol crazy. Went to another pizza place and they had plenty of slices to offer. I will tell anyone who will listen about this experience
Joe Scafidi
I can’t say enough about Anthony’s Pizza. It’s 100 % my go to place . Excellent quality, consistency and always customer focused . Grandma’s is second to none but even a basic Cheese is off the charts. Kudos to our local owners
… moreKevin (Mekstar)
Been ordering from this place for the past 4 years. Never had a problem until tonight the “owners” son took my order. Placed a DELIVERY order for a Chessesteak Stomboili. My guy took my full address and proceeded told me it would be “there in 25 minutes” had to catch his attention to tell him I wanted to pay credit card because he didn’t even bother to ask me if I was paying cash/card. An hour later our food still wasn’t here (usually prompt) Called the restaurant and spoke the the “owners” son and he proceeded to tell me that my order was for “pick up”! Then he continued to tell me I was wrong.. So if my order was for pick up why the hell did you ask me for my delivery address?! And why did I have to ask pay with CC?!
What a shame because this place always has the best Stromboli in SJ..
There jerks didn’t even ask to make it right all I got was blame and deflection.. NEVER again!
… moreWhat a shame because this place always has the best Stromboli in SJ..
There jerks didn’t even ask to make it right all I got was blame and deflection.. NEVER again!