Michael Shoblock
Very good pizza, $3 slice, $3.50 for pepperoni. Thin crust, crispy, nice sauce, good amount of cheese
… moreMichael Lizza
Wow wow wow. The BEST Chicken Parm Pie! I ordered it via Uber Eats. It came so hot and fresh. Amazing chicken quality and I love that they add Ricotta. Order it! You will love it.
… moreBig Wally
Great family pizzeria located in the scenic area of Redbank. Lots of great local businesses on the street.
Large variety of pizza slices ready and menu of other items. Buffalo Chicken was very good, added a side of ranch dressing. Margherita was thin and crispy. Sicilian was thick and cheesy.
Fast, friendly service.
… moreDaniel Matthies
Total rip off taking advantage of kids who want cheeseburgers. Have you ever been to a place that charges $5 for a slice of cheese?! Or $15 + tax + tip for a cheeseburger with no fries, pickle, nothing but a cheeseburger?! Twice the price for half the food!! This is the first time I’ve seen that in my life. Never going here again!!
… moreMandie Sepulveda
I rarely ever post reviews but what the actual heck happened and why does your chicken wings taste fishy and why is the pizza INSANELY salty and dry. The fries?!? My 9 year old is obsessed with fries and she even goes “mom i actually really hate this its insanely salty” she also hated the pizza, what child hates pizza?!? I used to LOVE Mr pizza slice growing up. Also you guys messed up my order. Ya’ll nasty now.
… moreRachel Catena
Straight to the point. Delicious perfect greasy cheesy pizza. A classic. Always slaps. Salads are decent size and include a lot of toppings/dressing. Worth it.
… moreAmanda Richmond
The pizza was good but I recommend them for take out only. There was no ac. It was so hot in there just waiting a few minutes for my pizza felt like forever.
… moreamazing tree
Grew up going here with original owner. Deff is not the samep the pizza. but hey things change ppl come and go but Can’t go wrong with those circle fries! THE BEST! If It wasn’t for those fries I wouldn’t even be going there anymore. That’s only thing that hasn’t changed. The original owner was the nicest guy you would have ever met!
… moreDenise Manco
I spent the weekend in Red Bank for my birthday and we ate here. I ordered a white slice with broccoli and a plain slice. We sat in the back at a table. BOTH slices were absolutely horrible. It was about 8pm on a Friday night. The pizza was SO thin and dried out that it literally turned to crumbs when I bit into it. My friend ordered a cheeseburger and said it was great but that’s because it was cooked when he ordered instead of sitting out for a length of time like the pizza. Staff is oblivious to customers. A staff member came to the back a few times. The fact that each slice had one bite taken out of it and pushed to the end of the table should’ve been a red flag but I noticed it was more important for staff to conversate and play on their phones ♀️ I won’t come back and I would not recommend anyone to eat here unless you want bad food and bad service.
… moreMichael Wright
I love this pizza! Whenever I come back to Red Bank, I make sure to stop by and grab a slice it two.
… more