Address and Contact Information
Address: 400 E Valley Rd, El Jebel, CO 81623
Phone: (970) 963-6088
Website: http://www.nyp.pizza/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
BASALT | My Site – nyp.pizza
top of page. Log In. HOME · ASPEN · BASALT · Delivery Zone · CARBONDALE · Shop. NYP Basalt Logo Letters.jpg. MENU · 970-963-6088. 400 E Valley Rd Next to El …
New York Pizza | eatBasalt
400 E. Valley Rd. El Jebel, Colorado 81623 (City Market Plaza). Hours, Details + More. New …
Beer & Pizza | New York Pizza
New York Pizza Aspen 409 E Hyman Ave Aspen, CO 81611. New York Pizza Basalt 400 E Valley Rd, Unit D Carbondale, CO 81623. New York Pizza Carbondale 901 Hwy …
Reviews
Christ Endeavors Ministry
Really good Pizza! The crust is really good the sauce is really good just makes for a really reliable Pie if your into New York style pizza! The young lady who was making the salads and wings OMG the wings were sauced and crispy not soggy and the salads were a dream! Highly recommend this spot, and the vibe and customer service was top notch, definitely can’t go wrong with this one!!!
… moreThomas West
This place has amazing food and even better customer service. Our hockey team was in town for a tournament and we had plans to go eat at the Glenwood brew pub. When we got there after making arrangements with them over the phone for 42 people to eat and drink there they chose not to honor their word and told us we couldn’t eat all together as a group. So we called New York Pizza and they were happy to help feed us all. They even put other orders on hold to expedite our order. Highly recommend the delicious pizza this place has to offer! I will definitely tell everyone I know to eat here!
… moreSallie B
Went in for a slice and wasn’t disappointed! The slices came hot out of the oven. The crust was authentic, thin and crispy. The sauce and toppings were delicious.
… moreCarol Ross
Great option for a family with varied dietary restrictions – something delicious for everyone! Vegetarian, gluten free vegetarian, hot wings, plain cheese, pepperoni or Margherita; everything was fabulous. The meatball sub looked amazing too – maybe next time.
So happy to find this gem in Basalt while visiting there. Ordered twice in less than a week & they’ll definitely get our business the next time we’re lucky enough to visit this beautiful area!!
… moreSo happy to find this gem in Basalt while visiting there. Ordered twice in less than a week & they’ll definitely get our business the next time we’re lucky enough to visit this beautiful area!!
Shane Hirsekorn
The guys here really care about customer service! I was caught in a bind when a different restaurant was able take a reservation but not hold a reservation. They were on the spot to feed a whole youth hockey team on a busy Friday night. The best part about this was the food was incredible as well! We had pizza, wings, and salad and everyone from the group was ecstatic about the food.
… moreHIbachi
For what it’s worth I usually do not leave reviews. I ordered this for lunch just thinking it would be average pizza. I travel for work and this was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. The owners *i assume* were working the front and offered me paper plates and your usual cheese and peppers. 10/10
… moreJustin Kovaleski
Wish I didn’t eat here.
Pizza is pretty easy to make decent. This is less than decent. The flavor is surprisingly bland. It makes you wonder why you can’t taste as much as it looks like you should.
They made the crust so thin that some of the slices couldn’t even be picked up.
They also took forever to make the pizza. It wasn’t that busy and still took 20 minutes to make a pizza. I make my own pizza in an Ooni pizza oven and I can heat it up and make a pizza in less than 15 minutes. And it tastes better.
… morePizza is pretty easy to make decent. This is less than decent. The flavor is surprisingly bland. It makes you wonder why you can’t taste as much as it looks like you should.
They made the crust so thin that some of the slices couldn’t even be picked up.
They also took forever to make the pizza. It wasn’t that busy and still took 20 minutes to make a pizza. I make my own pizza in an Ooni pizza oven and I can heat it up and make a pizza in less than 15 minutes. And it tastes better.
beth ellyn rosenthal
I lived in Manhattan for four years, so I know New York pizza intimately. But this pizzeria in this tiny mountain town in Colorado makes as good or better pizza than New York…or anywhere (except maybe Rome.)
I discovered New York Pizza grocery shopping at El Jebel City Market next to Willits Town Center where I live in the summer. I noticed on Friday nights a line to pay almost reached the front door.
I had to explore.
Well, I discovered it’s one of the most fun places in Basalt. Forget Zane’s Tavern. This is THE place. Sports on multiple TV screens. Plenty of tables inside AND outside to enjoy the food. Plenty of beer. This place is hoppin’ on weekends.
The pizza is…phenomenal, especially if you eat in and get the pie steaming hot straight from the oven to your table. A thin but yeasty, crunchy crust serves as the foundation. We are carnivores so we had the all-meat pizza called the works. Pepperoni, sausage and Canadian bacon mix it up with mushrooms, onions, green peppers and black olives, all buried under a blanket of melted mozzarella.
But you can build you own pizza; there are 23 choices including artichoke hearts and red or yellow onions. (Picky, picky!)
To me the best thing to order is their chicken wings. City Market next door sells great chicken wings at half the price. But I would still pay full price ($12 wings for $19) for these. Juicy, sweet, just greasy enough. There are eight sauces ranging from sweet (Carolina Gold) to burn your mouth hot (honey sriracha, habanero or ring of fire.)
Surprisingly, everyone seemed to be leaving with one Philly cheesesteak sandwich. They must be good. The NYP burger uses local Colorado beef. This is a ranching county so I trust the beef. That’s on my list for next time.
You can even order fried dough, cheesy or sweet.
There is plenty of parking since it’s the main parking lot for the big supermarket in town.
There’s also a New York Pizza in Aspen and Carbondale. They are on my list for next summer.
What a joy when a local restaurant in a strip shopping center serves glorious food!
… moreI discovered New York Pizza grocery shopping at El Jebel City Market next to Willits Town Center where I live in the summer. I noticed on Friday nights a line to pay almost reached the front door.
I had to explore.
Well, I discovered it’s one of the most fun places in Basalt. Forget Zane’s Tavern. This is THE place. Sports on multiple TV screens. Plenty of tables inside AND outside to enjoy the food. Plenty of beer. This place is hoppin’ on weekends.
The pizza is…phenomenal, especially if you eat in and get the pie steaming hot straight from the oven to your table. A thin but yeasty, crunchy crust serves as the foundation. We are carnivores so we had the all-meat pizza called the works. Pepperoni, sausage and Canadian bacon mix it up with mushrooms, onions, green peppers and black olives, all buried under a blanket of melted mozzarella.
But you can build you own pizza; there are 23 choices including artichoke hearts and red or yellow onions. (Picky, picky!)
To me the best thing to order is their chicken wings. City Market next door sells great chicken wings at half the price. But I would still pay full price ($12 wings for $19) for these. Juicy, sweet, just greasy enough. There are eight sauces ranging from sweet (Carolina Gold) to burn your mouth hot (honey sriracha, habanero or ring of fire.)
Surprisingly, everyone seemed to be leaving with one Philly cheesesteak sandwich. They must be good. The NYP burger uses local Colorado beef. This is a ranching county so I trust the beef. That’s on my list for next time.
You can even order fried dough, cheesy or sweet.
There is plenty of parking since it’s the main parking lot for the big supermarket in town.
There’s also a New York Pizza in Aspen and Carbondale. They are on my list for next summer.
What a joy when a local restaurant in a strip shopping center serves glorious food!
Justin Smith
We had pizza, chicken parmesan and sweet bread. The pizza was tasty, but nothing special. We ordered extra cheese and it was a bit dry, but the toppings tasted fresh. The chicken parm was very good. They didn’t have egg plant parmesan, even though it was on the printed menu. The sweet bread was amazing! Soft, fluffy, with a honey/syrup sauce and powered sugar.
The staff was friendly, but nobody wore a mask. The bar doesn’t have any separation between patrons, but it wasn’t crowded.
Prices are reasonable for the area, but remember that even with takeout orders they charge tax.
… moreThe staff was friendly, but nobody wore a mask. The bar doesn’t have any separation between patrons, but it wasn’t crowded.
Prices are reasonable for the area, but remember that even with takeout orders they charge tax.
Mushroom
Great food, enthusiastic and entertaining staff. Great price point for lunch, 2 huge slices for 5-6 bucks each.
… more