Korey Jones
Chose to get (2) single slices of pepperoni, just to try this place out. This might have been the thinnest pizza we’ve ever had. We DO NOT like thin pizza, personally. This was not worth $4.75 each. Also, took about 20 minutes to recieve the slices. Pizza did taste ok but not something I would come back for if it will continue to be this thin.
… moreJonathan Joiner
Excellent pizza crust. Pepperoni blend large ftw they have crust brush ons which can add a little more to your crust but I don’t need it. The secret in the dough is where it’s at. Great customer support over phone. Always nice people and on time service. It’s a bit of a drive for us but we don’t mind for the quality! Great job Killer Crust!!
… moreD G-S
This is the second time coming and again did not disappoint. Really great pizza spot. The pizza is decently large. The 2 pizza and a drink combo is perfect to make me full and content. The cheese pizza reminds me of my favorite childhood pizza spot back in Jersey. My husband had a meatball sub last time we were here and he was extremely happy with it. Honestly, we have made this place our go to pizza spot!
… moreAustin Mills
I hate to be mean, but this was honestly one of the worst calzones I’ve ever eaten. (I should’ve listened to the other reviewer who thought the same…) Not only was it not flavorful, but the dough was chewy and the mozzarella cheese had that unappetizing rubbery texture that comes with low quality cheese. Further, there weren’t any specialty calzones, and every topping you add (in addition to the included cheese) is an extra $1. The employees were friendly though!
… moreRachael Killingsworth
The staff was top notch. The pizza was fresh and delicious! They have so many neat options of pies to choose from or build your own. $2 draft beers and kid friendly. There are a few tables inside and outside, but not ideal for large group dining. They sell very unique local artist paintings. Definitely craving their pizza again!
… moreNate Koep
Discovered this place about 3 months ago and couldn’t be any happier. The pizzas are amazing. You can tell the ingredients are super fresh. Every time I go in the staff is amazing. Just wish it was a bigger sit down area. Check this place out if you love pizza! Best in Athens.
… moreEnchantedGaming
I got the killer supreme and it was amazing but the only down side was that the crust got slightly hard and was not great to eat. Garlic Nots were a 0/10. It was undercooked and i’m not sure if it’s supposed to be half raw on the inside but it was. The cannolis were okay. It’s very sweet and a little too much chocolate for me. It was a bit pricey for these 3 but I understand why the pizza was $30 but $8 for 2 cannolis and $8 for the undercooked nots were not great.
… moreHannah Khan
Garlic knots were tasty! Got a large pizza and it barely had sauce on it which was disappointing especially coming from someone who likes light sauce on a pizza anyway… Opted for garlic Parmesan crust which was identical to the garlic knots. Portions were great. Clean dining room.
… moreCharlie Williamson
I have been here with my girlfriend here about 4 times now and we are hooked. The lunch special feels like a great deal for the fresh mozzarella. She is a vegetarian and then always are accommodating to that. Lastly they make the ranch in house and it’s so good.
Update now, we’ve been there probably 10+ times and it’s really good. The ranch is still just as good and it feels like the toppings keep increasing
… moreBill
My new favorite pizza shop! Old-style Italian pizzeria quality. Fresh salads and toppings, crispy crusts, & friendly service. Treat yourself to their lunch specials or take home a pizza. And try the calzones, they are amazing!
… more