cristina r
Great pizza! Handpainted Alaskan murals and large windows make it the best place to meet up! It’s gorgeous and has been a local year round treasure for so long! They have a drive thru which is so convenient for grabbing your pick up order! My favorite Pizza is “The Sterling.” I recommend stopping in for large frosty mugs of beer and a huge pizza after fishing at Bings! It’s also my favorite date night with my son (now 7).
… moreEmily Rambo
This place was the perfect stop from Seward to Homer. It has a beautiful wildlife mural inside. The staff was friendly. But the highlight was the incredible food. The Naptowner pizza was among the best pizza we have ever had. Perfect amount of cheese and sauce, amazing crust with a garlic buttery flavor, and high quality toppings. The garlic bread was equally as delicious. Both paired well with what we have decided is the world’s best ranch dressing. Give this place a try, you won’t regret it.
… moreJess Beck
Whether you’re passing through or a local to the Peninsula…this is LITERALLY the best pizza on the Kenai. It’s worth a stop at the very least, but if you try it once you’re going to want to come back. Their “pizza by the slice” is truly the best deal around when it comes to value and quality of pizza…especially if you can’t decide on one of the MANY amazing offerings they have. Please don’t underestimate how awesome their pizza is. And on top of that, they serve their community in ways they don’t ever expect recognition for. We love you Magpye’s!
… moreChris Capo
Tasty pizza, Dave Portnoy would approve. In town for work, stopped in and was helped quickly & efficiently. Good pizza, exactly what I was looking for on my lunch break. Nice people too
… moredetha depari
I like Magpye’s as a local restaurant and I’m glad they’re here supporting the local Sterling community. They have pretty good food all around and a good selection of Beer. Plenty of room inside to accommodate good sized groups and smaller. It does get a bit busy but you can sit at the bar and enjoy a drink while you wait. Pizza’s are consistently good, cheeses are nice, sauce is nice, plenty of toppings.
Personally, my only criticism is that I’m not a fan of lots of edge crust unless it’s stuffed with something and would prefer less crust.
All in all, they’re a great asset to Sterling and they make life a little better because they’re here.
… moreCheryl Till
Cute decorated restaurant, delicious thin crust pizza. We hadn’t had anything green in several days so the salad was great! We were the only ones in the restaurant and they brought us a large salad, we ordered a small and asked twice to clarify our order.
… moreTina Babnik
We came late to Sterling, stopped by Magpye’s Pizzeria and enjoyed the variety of pizza’s. They had also a gluten free version, which was a great surprise. Service was good and the place was not too crowded.
… morePeter Jaime
I love the setup and home like appearance of the restaurant. Unfortunately, the pizza was nothing special. The bread crust on my pizza was done well and very good but the mozzarella sauce had little flavor and toppings we ordered we’re missing.
… moreJames Barnhill
Shame all the negative comments about the stars and bars. Part of our national history. Great food!
… moreTony sauce
We were passing by and it was lunch time and I was in the mood for pizza. We saw restaurant and decided to stop. I’m sure glad we did the pizza was delicious and the crew there were so down to earth and pleasant. If you are driving down south you must stop. The restaurant had large windows with views. I loved it.
… more