Deb Rithman
I ordered the strawberry shortcake cake for my boyfriend’s mom’s birthday and the banana cream pie barrel for myself. The cake was fantastic!! It had a really strong strawberry smell and taste to it.
The banana cream pie barrel was also fantastic. We will definitely be ordering again. For our first time it was a great first impression.
… moreD.J.W. Words and Sounds
Cowboy Creamery, much like the town of Middlefield itself, had a quaint, small community vibe to it. The store decor and products were quite vibrant in a clean, sanitary environment. The staff was quite lovely too. I ordered the Zanzibar Chocolate milkshake, and while it admittedly was not the best milkshake I’ve ever had, it still tasted good. I would come back to try other flavors.
… moreRyan Preisendorfer
Great ice cream joint. Whether walking around town or hitting the bike trail as a in between stop. Quality ingredients and flavors! Always a prime choice to stop by and get a scoop or two
… moreWendy Shine
Skip breakfast and lunch….. soooooo worth it! Clean, excellent staff and great prices.
… moreBrayden Axel
Don’t get me wrong their ice cream is absolutely delicious. But anymore their waffle bowls are small than they used to be. And you pay .75 for EACH topping and you cannot even taste them. I get the same exact thing each time. I have even paid for extra toppings and still the same amount. It is absolutely ridiculous. I do not mind paying but I expect what I pay for. Do better yall.
… morekent taylor
First the ice cream is outstanding! Second, the staff is always friendly and are always willing to help with your order! Fast service and just a great customer service. We really enjoy stopping in!
… moreCarole Klaue
Restrooms. Street level at front of the store. Rear door parking drops down a few steps. No auto handicap doors. Instant service helpers and fast, correct orders. There are many ice cream choices at the counter. Plus gorgeous ice cream cakes and sm. Ice cream tubs. Lots of table seating. Nice birthday party size place. The neighborhood is Amish and English. Lots to enjoy in the neighbirhood.
… moreBig-J
First but not the last time here! Very unassuming front entrance. Amazing place with great ice cream quality and selection. Great service and spotless clean! Loved it! Back from Cleveland 2 weeks later.
… moreDeb Thompson
By far, the absolute best soft serve ice cream I have ever had! This place offers many things other than the ice cream nachos that we ordered. I loved them so much, I don’t know how I will be able to get anything else. I have waited too long to go here!
… moreHoward Pierce
Ice cream creamy, told they have a custard machine they use for strawberry Cassata cake. Custard should be for cones also. Nice family place. You can order on kiosk or in person. Several tables all wooden seats, except kiddie tables. Some machines to play for prize. Huge gumball machine. See video for more.
… more