Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Grove City Menu – Coffaro’s Pizza
Smoked ham and diced pineapple with our house red sauce. … Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, white onions, and green peppers. … Ham, Italian sausage, pepperoni, …
Coffaro’s Pizza
216 Grove City Road Slippery Rock, PA 16057 (724) 794-2424. Picture. Grove City 116 South Broad Street Grove City, PA 16127 (724) 458-7900. Picture. Slippery …
Order Coffaro’s Pizza Delivery Online – Postmates
From any restaurant in Grove City • From tacos to Titos, textbooks to MacBooks, Postmates is the app that delivers – anything from anywhere, in minutes.
Reviews
Amy L
This pizza is a piece of art! I opened the box and the steam hit me- the smell made my mouth water! The crust is crispy and chewy and this is the type of pizza that when you pull a slice out you can lift it above your head and the cheese is still strung to the pizza in the box! The sub was perfect!
If you’re in the area please do your taste buds a favor and stop! Its also cheap having a good BOGO pizza deal!
… moreIf you’re in the area please do your taste buds a favor and stop! Its also cheap having a good BOGO pizza deal!
Eric Guelcher
Ordered carryout pizza that was ready in 20 minutes. Arrived at the designated time and the pizza was just out of the oven. The crust was fresh made and cooked nicely, brown and crusty on the ends, but firm and chewy throughout, very evenly cooked.
The toppings were very good, though fresh sliced mushrooms would have been preferred over the canned mushrooms.
That was the only criticism as the pizza was really good. I did prefer it to other pizzas available in the area as the crust elevated it to the top position. Definitely more of a traditional pizza than the other places from a Midwest perspective. Will definitely have to return!
Price was very reasonable at under $20 for a large 3 topping pizza. Service for carry out was immediate with no wait.
… moreThe toppings were very good, though fresh sliced mushrooms would have been preferred over the canned mushrooms.
That was the only criticism as the pizza was really good. I did prefer it to other pizzas available in the area as the crust elevated it to the top position. Definitely more of a traditional pizza than the other places from a Midwest perspective. Will definitely have to return!
Price was very reasonable at under $20 for a large 3 topping pizza. Service for carry out was immediate with no wait.
Celeste Rice
I’ve been traveling all day and I was really craving some good pizza. The front desk lady at my hotel suggested this place.
If you are in the area, order from here!
This is probably the best pizza I’ve ever had. Or at least top 2!
The crust was crispy on the outside, warm and chewy on the inside. Perfect tasting sauce, a well balance of sweet to savory.
And the cheese was very fresh and delicious.
I’ll be traveling back and forth to Westpoint the next few years and I will 100% make it a point to stop in and get this pizza.
I’m posting a picture, but the pizza is a little lopsided from me tipping it over. Not from the pizza place.
… moreIf you are in the area, order from here!
This is probably the best pizza I’ve ever had. Or at least top 2!
The crust was crispy on the outside, warm and chewy on the inside. Perfect tasting sauce, a well balance of sweet to savory.
And the cheese was very fresh and delicious.
I’ll be traveling back and forth to Westpoint the next few years and I will 100% make it a point to stop in and get this pizza.
I’m posting a picture, but the pizza is a little lopsided from me tipping it over. Not from the pizza place.
Dylan Jones
Wanted to try some new food while I was in Grove City. Ordered a nice and simple pepperoni pizza, and got it after only 10 minutes. The workers seemed to be having a great time with one another while I was inside, which I love to see at places I visit. I unfortunately had to drive home afterwards, and didn’t get to enjoy my pizza while it was still hot. It was still phenomenal, a typical pizza place pizza, which isn’t a bad thing at all! I would definitely stop by again if I’m in the area.
… moreBrittany
Spent 40 bucks in burnt food, pizza with green peppers, breadsticks, calzone, cheese sticks. Cheese sticks were cold had to be the first things made, the rest burnt and cold. Was told 25 minutes i showed up in 15. Cant believe what i received.Was my first time going there being new to grove city and will be my last. Wont spend money out to people who arent even caring to make good food and take their time. To even think that was right to box that up looking like that.
… moreCassandra Nelson
We really like their pizza and have never had issues with it. Our neighbors even get 10-15 pizzas delivered every year for their annual holiday party and it gets devoured. Everyone has their own pizza style, but we really like this one!
… moreRicky
They have the best pizza in Grove City!!! Wonderful, hard working staff! This is me and my boyfriend’s favorite pizza place! It is heavenly goodnesssss, try the cheesy bread!
… moreWhitney Mertz
If I could give 0 stars I would! By far the worst pizza establishment in the area! They treat their customers like trash! My family got a pizza and a bug was cooked into the cheese and they refused to do anything (mistakes happen we weren’t even angry) but told us they didn’t want people like as customers… no worries we will never give them another dime! Don’t recommend
… moreJason Keith
Absolutely delicious! I was in the area for a night and Coffaros’ Pizza was highly recommended.
This is one of THE best pizzas I’ve had! The crust is chewy, crunchy, and flavorful. The cheese is buttery, silky, and obviously very fresh. The pepperoni is spicy (not hot), and very meaty. It is not your typical store bought sausage.
The ONLY thing that I can suggest is to request some extra sauce on the pie, or on the side. (They have what is meant by “Awesome Sauce” )
… moreThis is one of THE best pizzas I’ve had! The crust is chewy, crunchy, and flavorful. The cheese is buttery, silky, and obviously very fresh. The pepperoni is spicy (not hot), and very meaty. It is not your typical store bought sausage.
The ONLY thing that I can suggest is to request some extra sauce on the pie, or on the side. (They have what is meant by “Awesome Sauce” )
Steven FinGado
I was at a conference in Grove City on 8/2/23. I stopped in for lunch and ordered a large stromboli. I must say, it was probably one of (if not) the best strombolis I have ever eaten and the price was very good. The owner seemed very proud of his work and made us feel welcome. The next time I am in Grove City or passing through hungry, I am definitely stopping in for another large stromboli without ham.
… more