Address and Contact Information
Address: 425 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795
Phone: (631) 661-7646
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Stuff a Bagel
Our Locations. Stuff a Bagel Farmingdale 234 Main Street Farmingdale, NY 11735 516-420-4287. Stuff A Bagel Bethpage 350 Broadway Bethpage, NY 11714 516-933 …
Order Stuff-A-Bagel – West Islip, NY Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Stuff-A-Bagel at 425 Montauk Highway in West Islip. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Stuff-A-Bagel (Montauk Hwy) Delivery Menu – West Islip – Grubhub
Order delivery or pickup from Stuff-A-Bagel (Montauk Hwy) in West Islip! View Stuff-A-Bagel (Montauk Hwy)’s March 2026 deals and menus.
Reviews
Tom Redmond
I been coming here for a number of years. Service people always good and pleasant. HOWEVER the food quality going DOWN and building inside out is dirty and deteriorating.CHRISTMAS day get 13 bagels, cream cheese, coffee and thirty three dollars later rewarded with family pulling bagel out with hair BAKED IN. A hair that was baked in and hanging out. Terrible. Tried not to judge the book by its outside cover dirty, weeds etc but now it hit the food.
… moreScott
Great spot for bagels and really good cream cheese. Not the spot if you’re looking for a specialty coffee but they’ve got all the staples. We grabbed a bit of lox too and that was excellent.
… moreRC
$2.00 charge for extra cream cheese today. Last time for me.
Last year ordered a ham and cheese on a bagel and the ham was not only bad, it was actually grey! Smelled horrific and they actually served grey rancid meat.
It’s a shame bc I work close and it would be convenient, but I will NEVER return to this dump.
I miss the old owners!!
… moreLast year ordered a ham and cheese on a bagel and the ham was not only bad, it was actually grey! Smelled horrific and they actually served grey rancid meat.
It’s a shame bc I work close and it would be convenient, but I will NEVER return to this dump.
I miss the old owners!!
anthony madonia
This bagel store has fallen off dramatically over the last few years. Really disappointed
… moreMary McGarrity
I never write reviews unless something is so extraordinary or awful it needs to be heard. I stopped by for a blt on an egg bagel and got yellow lettuce and the hard center of the tomato. The bacon was cooked but fresh out of the refrigerator. Why are they serving this? This was entirely unedible.
… moreFrank Daconta
The food is good. Fast service I feel priced a bit high
… moreAnthony C
Asked for a BLT, and I got very little bacon and huge tomato slices..come on wheres the bacon
… moreChristina Costanzo
I’ve been here numerous times and some of the girls that work there. Just don’t know how to make a sandwich or a bagel. I’ve never seen a bagel with so little cream cheese that I’m actually complaining about it. Usually, you complain there’s too much cream cheese. I don’t wanna pay ten dollars for a bagel with no cream cheese. Let’s get it together n serve what we pay for. From one repeat customer who won’t be coming back. Its just been happening too much I only give so many chances.
… moreFlori
I only post a review when I think some other consumers should be warned. Be Aware: I have been going to Stuff-A-Bagel in West Islip for years as I am a resident and live down the block from the store. Bagels used to be wonderful there, and the owners and staff were professional.
Now, the bagels taste bad, you must buy six bagels at a time, the staff is rude, I hear the owner is a bully with his employees, the place is dirty and the bagels are very expensive.
Need I say more? So Be Aware!!!!!
… moreNow, the bagels taste bad, you must buy six bagels at a time, the staff is rude, I hear the owner is a bully with his employees, the place is dirty and the bagels are very expensive.
Need I say more? So Be Aware!!!!!
Joan Joseph
1st time I went ordered a sausage, mozzarella and tomato omelet. I got a mozzarella and tomato omelet. Today ordered egg onion bagel with bacon. I received a onion bagel. The people handling the orders are preoccupied and do not pay attention to detail. I can see if it was busy but both times I was there was just myself and maybe one other person in there. In addition they are very slow and the area is not very clean. I go at 6:30 am before work on a weekend. I will not be going back
… more