Nadine Asfour
We just moved into the area a few months ago and came across Valentinos. By far, the best pizza we’ve had around here so far, made to perfection! The crust has a slight crisp to it, and the wings have a nice kick. Everything was so flavorful! My family and I will definitely be going back!
… moreKayode Odepe
A local gem & a great family-friendly hangout nestled in the heart of small town Flanders/Mt Olive. They have a good variety & range of dine-in & take out options available. The staff were very nice & friendly. Service was like clock work from the time they take your orders & when it’s ready. You can tell it has a legacy/heritage dating back years just from the generational range of the patrons who come there, I.e. grandparents, parents & grandkids
… moreNicholas Magone
By far the best pizzeria around. No other Ria has been able to compare to my Nonno’s. Great dinners and sandwiches too. Everything is authentic. The Owners are incredible and the most gracious and welcoming people you can find. We dont eat pizza anywhere else. Everything else is a distant 2nd rate.
… moreLisandra Mazariego
Wow , the service and food were truly so incredible. Our server was so sweet and attentive.
We came very hungry and left very satisfied. Crust on the pizza was perfect thin and crisp . Mussels dinner was delicious , sauce was rich and flavorful. Ended with a cannoli, which was very tasty. Was a 10/10 experience.
… moreChuck Mound
I could have selected any Pizzeria in the surrounding towns this afternoon, but I selected Valentino’s. Speaking or some sort of communicate with your customers would be nice. How may I help you? How was your pizza? Is there anything else? Not a word. Just took my money and handed back my change, which of 25 cents. Basically $5 for a soda and a slice that was served on a regular plate, which was a nice change from always having slices served on paper plates. No, have a nice day… thank you…. Nothing. I would have ordered on line, but even then at least I would get a Thank You for your order. Probably would have given 3 stars, with the average pizza that was served here, but the lack of any interaction at all, left me with a bad taste. I will gladly spend my pizza money somewhere else when given the proper courtesy of saying Thank You for your business. For this reason, I will not be going back. Thank You.
… moreStefanny Marrero
I always get a few slices of pizza and sometimes a veggie roll or chicken roll. I was going to try the chicken parm dinner I ordered it and she told me the total, $25 is WAYY overpriced I called the lady back and canceled it right away, in less than a minute after placing my order.She didn’t even tell me if the order was canceled she just said bye and hung up, I see now why they are slow Sundays. Its because of this enthusiastic worker who loves the heck out of her job.
… moreJulia Bresney
My family and I have been coming to Valentino’s pizza since I was 10 years old. The staff has watched me grow up, stopping in after soccer games, concerts/ events after school and the occasional Friday night when Mom & Dad didn’t feel like cooking.
I’m currently in Venice, Italy with my husband and we just had our first Italian slice of pizza. Couldn’t help but compare it to Valentino’s… New Jersey has my vote this time! Thank you all – 5 stars for food, service and atmosphere.
… moreJam B
So disappointing how the quality of this restaurant and so many others have gone down hill. I got the eggplant parm meal and there was barely any sauce on it. They put a pile of sauce under the eggplant but not nearly enough to even cover the spaghetti. Please fix this valentinos. We’ve been giving you service for more than 10 years. I’d actually appreciate my money back for this meal that was not cheap. In this picture I mixed the sauce the best I could.
… moreThomas Montesano
Plain pizza is good as always but given hard garlic knots with my order. They also changed the Buffalo chicken pizza to this atrocity and will never be coming back for it. Absolutely appalling.
… moreVivianLynn Taylor
Extremely professional and food is delicious.
Thank you for 2025 your service was exceptional fir all my events.
… more