Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Family-owned and serving Florida’s Treasure Coast since 1996, Goodfellas Pizza is known for handcrafted pizzas, hot wings, subs, fresh salads, and homemade pasta. With nine locations across Port St. Lucie, Jensen Beach, Fort Pierce, Palm City, and more, we offer fast delivery, takeout, and reliable corporate catering. Whether you’re craving a meatball sub, Caesar salad, or the best pepperoni pizza around, Goodfellas brings bold flavors and quality you can count on.
Casual restaurant offering NY-style pizzas, subs & pastas, with delivery available.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
goodfellaspizza5.hrpos.heartland.us
Related Web Results
Goodfella’s Pizza Pasta Subs | Family Pizza Restaurant near me
Goodfellas Pizza serves fresh pizza, pasta, subs, wings, and family meals across the Treasure Coast Florida. Order online for pickup or delivery from your …
Goodfella’s Pizza – 103 US 1, Jupiter, FL 33477 – Slice
… SUBSHOT SUBSPASTA DISHESPASTA DISHES BAKEDENTREESDESSERTSBEVERAGESSPECIALSMISC ITEMS. appetizers. APPETIZERS. Available from 10:00 AM – 10:15 PM. Buffalo …
Review of Goodfellas Pizza in Jupiter, FL – Facebook
OCR: Itae MA SALADS WINGS Goodfella’s Est, 2.1996 1996 PIZZA EY SUBS PASTA IN. TAKE OUT CATERING DELIVERY DINE Order Online GoodfelasPizzaOnline …
Reviews
Sean King
I was dashing and it was my first time in here. I saw the stuffed pie in the window for single slices. I took cold cause I actually live an hour away, OMG! It is so good! Sure it’s a touch greasy, but anyone that knows proper pizza, that grease comes from a higher fat content cheese or cheese blend. So that grease is a very good thing! And absolutely massive! I will be driving back to Jupiter for a whole one and a Sicilian for a gathering I’m having. Yes I did cut it into 3, I can eat that much myself so it was 3 meals for a little guy like me
… moreLaura
This is so random but boy does this place make a mean greek salad!!! Get it with the grill chicken. It’s a big hearty salad, lots of feta and a great greek dressing. YUM! The mezzanine luna (their version of mozz sticks) are to die for, crunchy with incredibly fresh mozzarella. Always nice staff, love supporting this business!
… moreElizabeth Curtin
We ordered EIGHT pizzas from here for a company lunch and they gave us a hard time about asking for napkins and plates…I work for a large local corporation and order many lunches which is great for business. We will not be ordering from them again. If you cannot cater to a good customer (who is capable of generating a lot of business for your establishment) something is very wrong. We’ll happily go to another grateful small business.
… moreWinnifred Jones
I was picking up a DoorDash order to deliver.
The order wasn’t ready yet which was great because it gave me a chance to try this delicious pizza I’ve been hearing so much about I had a slice of the margarita the best New York style pizza in South Florida hands-down the gentleman at the counter with the beard was so helpful and friendly with my DoorDash order. Highly recommend this place.
… moreThe order wasn’t ready yet which was great because it gave me a chance to try this delicious pizza I’ve been hearing so much about I had a slice of the margarita the best New York style pizza in South Florida hands-down the gentleman at the counter with the beard was so helpful and friendly with my DoorDash order. Highly recommend this place.
Melissa Owens
Yummy pizza, bright sauce, and nice proportion of sauce to the cheese, a little greasy, but didn’t bother us. We popped in for a nice, quiet lunch and then dinner another time. We got slices of cheese for lunch (and then had seconds it was so good), and a large cheese another night for dinner. Our 1y/o loved the pizza so much she danced in the high chair as she ate it lol we picked up a large cheese and brought it to the beach one evening and had it there on a park bench for an easy, inexpensive weeknight date with daddy 🙂 a solid go-to for good pizza!
… moreShawn Cook
The best ny style ive had around here. It’s very good. Slices are the bomb cause twice baked pie is the best but we’ve gotten whole
Pies as well.
… morePies as well.
George P.
I’ve become a regular at this pizza location due to the proximity of my office and let me tell you the food quality is unmatched! The food here is consistently phenomenal and my guy Joe always brings the great vibes.
… moreMichelle Jordan
They delivered rancid and undercooked food and refused to give a refund.
Been here a few times and it was good. Tonight was the last time. We ordered two subs, a stromboli, and chicken wings. They forgot the blue cheese sauce we paid extra for. Not a big deal, but annoying. I took a bite of the Italian sub and it tasted weird. Upon inspection, the salami was grey and green, looked slimy, and smelled awful.
I cut off one end of the stromboli and what I thought was a golf ball sized hunk of cheese was actually uncooked dough.
We called the store and said they could come pick up the rancid sub and raw stromboli to see for themselves. The manager declined and offered a $20 credit instead. We said we would prefer a refund because we would likely not be using that credit. He said we could come into the store, but they would just give us a gift card. What?! Really?! We ordered over $50 of food for delivery, you forgot something we paid for and could have potentially sent me to the hospital, but you won’t put $20 back on my credit card? I’m still sitting here grossed out and hoping I don’t get sick.
That’s the last time we will spend our money there.
… moreBeen here a few times and it was good. Tonight was the last time. We ordered two subs, a stromboli, and chicken wings. They forgot the blue cheese sauce we paid extra for. Not a big deal, but annoying. I took a bite of the Italian sub and it tasted weird. Upon inspection, the salami was grey and green, looked slimy, and smelled awful.
I cut off one end of the stromboli and what I thought was a golf ball sized hunk of cheese was actually uncooked dough.
We called the store and said they could come pick up the rancid sub and raw stromboli to see for themselves. The manager declined and offered a $20 credit instead. We said we would prefer a refund because we would likely not be using that credit. He said we could come into the store, but they would just give us a gift card. What?! Really?! We ordered over $50 of food for delivery, you forgot something we paid for and could have potentially sent me to the hospital, but you won’t put $20 back on my credit card? I’m still sitting here grossed out and hoping I don’t get sick.
That’s the last time we will spend our money there.
Christopher Thomson
Nice sub and pizza place in the plaza corner. Brooklyn vibes. Great subs and salads. Everything cooked to order
… moreShaun Spadafora
There are TONS of pizza places that are adorned with pictures of NYC, and this place is no different. However, Goodfellas Pizza actually tastes like authentic NY pizza. It’s uncanny. I had two slices of pepperoni and it felt like I was sitting in Manhattan. They also have bottled beer for sale which is a plus. Would highly recommend!
… more