Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Family-owned and operated pizzeria serving classic New York–style pies, crisp salads, and Italian favorites in the heart of Cedar Grove, New Jersey. We use fresh ingredients, generous toppings, and recipes passed down through our family to create a warm, welcoming neighborhood spot for dine-in, takeout, and local delivery. Whether it’s a quick slice, a family dinner, or catering for your next party, we’re proud to be Cedar Grove’s go-to place for great pizza and friendly service.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 465 Pompton Ave, Cedar Grove, NJ 07009
Phone: (973) 566-1083
Website: http://celestinoscg.com/
Related Web Results
Celestino’s Cedar Grove
Celestino’s Pizza & Ristorante in New Providence, NJ Serving Pizza and the best Italian Food.
Home — Celestino’s
Old-School Recipes, New-School Vibes. Order Now. Cedar Grove · New Providence. Premiere-00028-68.jpg. Premiere-01827-70.jpg. Celestinos 1.jpg.
Order Celestino’s Pizza & Ristorante – Cedar Grove – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Celestino’s Pizza & Ristorante at 465 Pompton Ave in Cedar Grove. Order online and track your order live.
Reviews
S I
I tried Celestino’s and I’m officially hooked.
I ordered the spinach Philly cheesesteak wrap and it was SO good. I asked for mayo on the side, but honestly… I didn’t even need it. The wrap was already packed with flavor and perfectly seasoned. Everything tasted fresh and balanced.
On top of that, the staff is super cool and genuinely kind, great energy all around.
Definitely found my new go-to spot for wraps 🙂 Shoutout to Jessie, the guy who took my order great energy and super helpful.
… moreI ordered the spinach Philly cheesesteak wrap and it was SO good. I asked for mayo on the side, but honestly… I didn’t even need it. The wrap was already packed with flavor and perfectly seasoned. Everything tasted fresh and balanced.
On top of that, the staff is super cool and genuinely kind, great energy all around.
Definitely found my new go-to spot for wraps 🙂 Shoutout to Jessie, the guy who took my order great energy and super helpful.
Jai Lee
Ordered a ‘lightly cooked’ Grandma pizza (since it is still the same as when it was Espositos) for the 3rd or 4th time under Celestinos. The guy taking the order over the phone even repeated the ‘lightly cooked’ part. Was craving the pizza… unfortunately it was well done…big disappointment. For what it’s worth, the older guy that cooked the pizza the other times was not there and this review is based solely on today’s pizza experience. If the pizza did not cost $25, I probably would not be writing this review…will not be ordering again for a while.
… moreAlfredo Carratala
Just ordered lunch for my family and some workers we have at the house. Everyone agrees the food is great, the level of service the gentleman behind the counter gave me is superb and this is a constant. Service and food are always 100%
Thank you for always being on your game
… moreThank you for always being on your game
Ankit Limbachiya
Last night, I arrived just moments before closing, uncertain if I’d still be able to order. To my pleasant surprise, the staff warmly welcomed me, assured me it was no trouble at all, and graciously accepted my order. Despite being ready to end their shift, they prepared my meal with genuine care and cheerful professionalism. Every team member I encountered greeted me courteously and went above and beyond to make the experience enjoyable. Truly exceptional service—10/10 in every respect.”
… moreSandra Noseir
Ordered takeout for a birthday party and everything was delicious! We tried the penne vodka, the calamari and their cheese pies. Everything was delicious and their attention to details is awesome. Sent in all the sides and sauces without us even mentioning it. On time delivery and very courteous staff. Can’t wait to try other menu items soon!! Thank you. We will be back.
… moreDylan Lopez
10/10 food, service and atmosphere! Highly recommend for anyone looking for the best Italian food and pizza in Cedar Grove!
… moreCarey Guido
Delish! We ordered a 1/2 & 1/2; Margarita & White Pie. Chef’s Kiss The Short Rib Ragu was so decadent and decent amount of short ribs nibs. For my kids they had the Grilled Chicken Vodka wrap with handmade potato chips and sorry I don’t have a picture because it was gone before we could start eating. Same goes for the Bacon Cheeseburger. Chicken Fingers & Fries was loved by my youngest he dint even want ketchup. The fries are thick steak cut fries but battered and really yummy.
This is our new go to for pizza night and the best in the Cedar Grove/ Verona area for Italian food with more exciting items than your average menu. Definitely picky-kid friendly food. Our family’s new favorite and same goes for my parents too. They made the switch! Best of luck and hope Celestino is around for the ages!
… moreThis is our new go to for pizza night and the best in the Cedar Grove/ Verona area for Italian food with more exciting items than your average menu. Definitely picky-kid friendly food. Our family’s new favorite and same goes for my parents too. They made the switch! Best of luck and hope Celestino is around for the ages!
Cynthia Robbins
The food is quite good. Pizza very good, particularly the thin crust. It’s not so thin as a cracker but not doughy either. Nice sauce. Excellent customer service, much better than many places around here. Clean space for dining, which we did invece and enjoyed. Delivery is speedy.
… moreVictoria Gunn
Its been awhile since I tried a new pizza place. I had my favorite and never thought the need to try others. I was pleasantly surprised as I didnt think pizza could possibly get any better. Celestino’s ingredients are so fresh and their food is made with love. The portion sizes are generous and very satisfying. I had to try other dishes and I am totally hooked. The Chicken Franchise was absolutely divine and the zeppoles like butter just melted in my mouth. I admit I am a foodie but rarely go out of my comfort zone when it comes down to pizza. They did not disappoint!
… moreMeagan Sullivan
Holy Stromboli! This was the first time we’ve ordered here, and it certainly won’t be our last. The cheesesteak, grandma pie and Stromboli were all delicious!
… more