Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Come check out our expanded dining room. Semi private for parties. Lent Specials daily and Best Friday fish fry! Shrimp Po boy, fresh fried calamari, homemade potato pancakes and eggplant. Good food and good times! Family owned and operated. Come enjoy some of the best pizza in carol stream, bbq ribs, SMASH BURGERS, Pizzalata, salad , pasta , breaded steak Parmesan sandwich, Italian sausage burger and so much more. Be sure to ask about our John’s beef and gravy pizza , pizza of the month and homemade cannolis, Italian ice and tiramisu! BEST martinis and old fashioned in the area!! Full bar , dine in , take out , or delivery! We can’t wait to meet you ! WE DO NOT USE UBER OR DOOR DASH- ONLY OUR OWN DRIVERS !
Address and Contact Information
Address: 158 N Gary Ave, Carol Stream, IL 60188
Phone: (630) 532-9888
Website: http://eatlegendspizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Legends Pizza: Best Carol Stream Pizza
Discover the best carol stream pizza at Legends Pizza, offering delicious options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery.
Legends Pizza | Carol Stream IL – Facebook
Details. . 100% recommend (25 Reviews). . $$. . Closed now. . 158 N Gary Ave , Carol Stream, IL, United States, 60188 ; Links. . linktr.ee/legendspizzacs …
Legends Pizza 158 North Gary Avenue – Order Online
Legends Pizza 158 North Gary Avenue. 158 North Gary Avenue, Carol Stream, IL. LENT SPECIALS. SOUP. SALAD. APPETIZERS. WINGS. SMASH BURGERS! SANDWICHES. PIZZA OF …
Reviews
Jenny Castillo
Legends Pizza is, we’ll, Legendary! The owner Michelle is the hardest working woman I know and she does it all with a smile and amazing customer service. Her staff is friendly even when they are super busy and the food is delicious.
Pizza of the month…always look for ward to what they come up with!
Fish Fry for lent…delicious and plentiful.
A town gem!
… morePizza of the month…always look for ward to what they come up with!
Fish Fry for lent…delicious and plentiful.
A town gem!
Jeff Seiffert
This place is amazing! We randomly dined in on a Sunday night and I am SO happy we did. The food was phenomenal! We tried the pizza with vodka sauce, and the standard cheese. It was cooked to perfection and flavorful. The soup and chili was outstanding. The server Natalie was charismatic and made us feel at home right away! The owners talked with us as well and gave us their story and also made us feel like family. Don’t forget the decorations!!!! This place is decked out Christmas decor. It looks like a holiday pop up! So much time and effort put into the aesthetic of this place. 10/10 would recommend. We will be back soon to try more items. What a find!
… moreTania
This place is a gem in the suburbs. The staff is amazing and the owner Michelle she’s very friendly and takes the extra mile to make you feel welcome. I had the meatball sandwich with salad. Was a good size and very well made. My friend had a hot dog pizza she said was delicious good for two. I recommend it and for sure come back soon. #supportingsmallbusiness
… moreKaleb Vick
Phenomenal pizza joint on the Gary at North Center. Too reasonably priced for these ridiculously giant slices of piping hot melted heavenly deliciousness. (Card for scale) Fantastic service, impeccable family vibes. Check this place out if you haven’t and remember to visit every time you’re in the area – Legends is a gem! So glad I got hungry
… moreTracy Check
LEGEND’S PIZZA has nailed the phrase: YOU’LL COME IN AS A CUSTOMER AND LEAVE AS FAMILY!
ABSOLUTELY love this place! Family owned and the food and service show this! The food is wonderful! Michelle makes almost everything homemade from the pizzas to the wonderful dessert! Did I mention great cocktails!
Legends totally embraces each holiday from the decorations to her awesome themed Pizzalatas, Drink specials and of course the dinner specials for all your holidays. The Lent menu is fantastic! Hand breaded calamari, homemade potato pancake, and hand battered fish are out of this world. Next month she is adding corn-beef and cabbage! Oh and the first Sunday of every month is Breakfast pizza!
LEGENDS PIZZA is definitely my happy place to be!
… moreABSOLUTELY love this place! Family owned and the food and service show this! The food is wonderful! Michelle makes almost everything homemade from the pizzas to the wonderful dessert! Did I mention great cocktails!
Legends totally embraces each holiday from the decorations to her awesome themed Pizzalatas, Drink specials and of course the dinner specials for all your holidays. The Lent menu is fantastic! Hand breaded calamari, homemade potato pancake, and hand battered fish are out of this world. Next month she is adding corn-beef and cabbage! Oh and the first Sunday of every month is Breakfast pizza!
LEGENDS PIZZA is definitely my happy place to be!
Team Cahill
We found the great local establishment for getting a variety of different pizzas. The Sunday special for bloody Mary’s was fun and it is definitely enough for at least two people. Definitely try their beef and gravy pizza. You won’t be disappointed! #Pizza #BloodyMary #Sunday #Food #Establishment #legendspizza_cs
… moreNicole Hovey
We can’t thank Legends enough for hosting the Martinez Fox Valley Elite Wrestling Club after our Regionals! They were extremely accommodating, the service was top notch and the food was amazing! Thank you for everything you did, and for allowing us to walk through your doors as customers and walk out as family! We look forward to coming back again! ❤️
… moreMr & Mrs K
Legends Pizza absolutely knocked it out of the park. Growing up in Elmwood Park, I know good food when I taste it—and this brought me right back home.
Michelle was phenomenal: friendly, warm, attentive, and genuinely made the experience even better! The place is very cozy and extremely clean.
We ordered the Italian breaded steak sandwich just WOW—phenomenal doesn’t even cover it. The sauce was rich and amazing, the meat was cooked to absolute perfection, tender and flavorful in every bite. You can tell this is the kind of food made with pride, not shortcuts.
We finished with their mini cannolis, which were the perfect ending—light, sweet, and just indulgent enough to leave you feeling soo good, food is the way to the heart. I was so pissed at myself for not ordering a cannoli shake to go as I live and hour and 25 away.
Legends has officially earned our patronage. This is the kind of place you come back to again and again.
— Catalina Vena & Chad K.
… moreMichelle was phenomenal: friendly, warm, attentive, and genuinely made the experience even better! The place is very cozy and extremely clean.
We ordered the Italian breaded steak sandwich just WOW—phenomenal doesn’t even cover it. The sauce was rich and amazing, the meat was cooked to absolute perfection, tender and flavorful in every bite. You can tell this is the kind of food made with pride, not shortcuts.
We finished with their mini cannolis, which were the perfect ending—light, sweet, and just indulgent enough to leave you feeling soo good, food is the way to the heart. I was so pissed at myself for not ordering a cannoli shake to go as I live and hour and 25 away.
Legends has officially earned our patronage. This is the kind of place you come back to again and again.
— Catalina Vena & Chad K.
Doreen Anderson
WOW ! So I’m going to provide a lot of details here which may come across like I know the owners —- promise I just met Michelle & Natalie yesterday – BUT they make you feel like Family in their home when dining with them.
First off – who knew there was so much creativity and passion happening at Legends ?
Six of us dined in and we went for a tapas style of eating sharing everything so that we could try as many things as possible which was a ton of FUN !
Hearing that their drink menu changes monthly as well as a monthly special pizza rotates on the menu means we already need to go back for May’s Mexican pizza. (We did try 3 of the May cocktails though)
We ordered –
chicken Caesar Pizzalata (longest prep lead time so ordered immediately)
APPS – fried pickles – cheesy giardiniera bread – garlic parm wings – bbq wings
MAIN – johns beef n gravy pizza (giardinera on the side vs on it) – breaded steak sandwich – 1/2 slab of ribs w/rings
Dessert – tiramisu (both regular & lemon berry) – lemon ice – cannoli (2 regular 2 peanut butter / chocolate)
YES it was lots and lots of food – BUT having read quite a few reviews in advance we had the unique pizzas and cheesy giardinera bread on our MUST TRY list and then filled in with other choices.
I don’t recall the last time we dined anywhere and made to feel like family from every staff member in the place. You just don’t find that.
Honorable mentions –
Johns beef & gravy pizza surprised all of us with just how delicious it was.
If you are a salad lover and like pizza crust – give a Pizzalata a try – the quality parm used on the Caesar was perfect.
HOMEMADE BBQ sauce – pretty certain I’ve never tasted a BBQ sauce with the depth of flavor this one has. It is not sweet – it just is yummy.
I got so involved with trying everything – didn’t get photos of everything.
One quick item to note – I had only looked at the menu on their website in advance by scrolling – I hadn’t clicked on the “order now” button going to the toasttab link – many of the monthly menu items as well as the soon to be famous Johns beef & gravy pizza are not on the website.
Also note – they just expanded taking over the 154 address for additional seating. We dined at 5:30 to make sure we could get a table with ease (round table is added bonus & perfect for familia dining)
… moreFirst off – who knew there was so much creativity and passion happening at Legends ?
Six of us dined in and we went for a tapas style of eating sharing everything so that we could try as many things as possible which was a ton of FUN !
Hearing that their drink menu changes monthly as well as a monthly special pizza rotates on the menu means we already need to go back for May’s Mexican pizza. (We did try 3 of the May cocktails though)
We ordered –
chicken Caesar Pizzalata (longest prep lead time so ordered immediately)
APPS – fried pickles – cheesy giardiniera bread – garlic parm wings – bbq wings
MAIN – johns beef n gravy pizza (giardinera on the side vs on it) – breaded steak sandwich – 1/2 slab of ribs w/rings
Dessert – tiramisu (both regular & lemon berry) – lemon ice – cannoli (2 regular 2 peanut butter / chocolate)
YES it was lots and lots of food – BUT having read quite a few reviews in advance we had the unique pizzas and cheesy giardinera bread on our MUST TRY list and then filled in with other choices.
I don’t recall the last time we dined anywhere and made to feel like family from every staff member in the place. You just don’t find that.
Honorable mentions –
Johns beef & gravy pizza surprised all of us with just how delicious it was.
If you are a salad lover and like pizza crust – give a Pizzalata a try – the quality parm used on the Caesar was perfect.
HOMEMADE BBQ sauce – pretty certain I’ve never tasted a BBQ sauce with the depth of flavor this one has. It is not sweet – it just is yummy.
I got so involved with trying everything – didn’t get photos of everything.
One quick item to note – I had only looked at the menu on their website in advance by scrolling – I hadn’t clicked on the “order now” button going to the toasttab link – many of the monthly menu items as well as the soon to be famous Johns beef & gravy pizza are not on the website.
Also note – they just expanded taking over the 154 address for additional seating. We dined at 5:30 to make sure we could get a table with ease (round table is added bonus & perfect for familia dining)
Jeffrey Hurd
I knew right away when they made their dressings for the salad I was very happy with the ranch dressing. Salad is simple and delicious. The setting is simple and very clean. The staff is friendly and treated me like they knew me.
Pizza just arrive and it smells wonderful and guess what they cut in squares. I love square cuts. Wonderful flavor. Crust is perfect slight crunch and I don’t have to fight with it Recommend you check it out
… morePizza just arrive and it smells wonderful and guess what they cut in squares. I love square cuts. Wonderful flavor. Crust is perfect slight crunch and I don’t have to fight with it Recommend you check it out