Deborah Weigle
I had chicken Marsala sandwich today . The chicken was plentiful and the bread is phenomenal. This picture is showing as almost gone. Yum. I’ve also had their cheesesteak sandwich and cheese fries. Did not disappoint. Their pizza for me is just the right everything! If you’re just looking for a pizza shop atmosphere this place is for you. Try it, you’ll like it!
… moreMario Ibrahim
First time at Nick’s and we’re hooked! The regular slices were spot on with a perfect crust, but the Grandma pie stole the show…authentic flavors, robust sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, and garlic all on a great crust. Friendly Italian staff made us feel at home, and we loved being able to enjoy it outside with our pup Moose. We’ll definitely be back!
… moreJeffrey Austin
Great food. Love the mussels marina.
Awesome pizza. Blows the old pizza places near him away
… moreGiover Rodriguez
I have been looking for a new go-to pizza place in Manahawkin since moving from NYC, and I finally found one!!!!. The pizza here is excellent; you can tell by the freshness that they use high-quality ingredients. I ordered spaghetti with mussels, which was delicious and satisfying. Thank you Marco
… moreJennavie rivera
Amazing atmosphere, I Moved to Barnegat from Brooklyn NY, and have been looking for a place that matched the NY Feel/taste, And this place is it!! It’s the best pizza i’ve had since i moved. Definitely will be a regular!
… moreKaren Handel
Owner takes pride in his food and his customer service! Everything including pizza has been great! We order tooo often! lol but it’s easy, convenient, from a friendly staff and DELICIOUS! Win win!!
… moreCathy Callanan
Nicks has the best pizza and food in NJ and NY. The pizza is outstanding! Perfect crust, sauce and cheese. It will take you back in time to when Pizza was what it was created to be. Perfect! The dinners are amazing as well. I love the chicken marsala, made with real marsala wine, not in thick soupy gravy that some restaurants sell, and call marsala. This is the real deal. Pasta is always al dente, when requested. The bread tastes like its from Arthur Ave. And a delicious side salad always comes with dinner. This is an authentic pizzeria and restaurant. The staff are always courteous and generous portions are served. I never write reviews, but Nicks certainly warrants rave reviews!
… moreKeith Nunes-Quattrone
Im 51 years old and in all my years ive never ordered from a place that messes up the order on take out every single time. Chicken caesar salad got it with no chicken, chicken caesar salad asked for extra dressing got no dressing, chicken caesar salad got a chef salad with chicken and Italian dressing, chicken fingers with honey mustard got it with no honey mustard. These are all separate orders by the way. The food is good but maybe if the guy who takes the order doesn’t rush you off the phone like youre bothering him and checks the order before it leaves maybe just maybe this wouldnt be an issue.
… moreNathalie Rodriguez
My family loves Nicks Pizza! The new owner is kind and makes great food. Staff is friendly and always goes above and beyond!
… moreJeff Bray
Nick’s never disappoints. we have gotten many different dishes and they have all been very good. One of my favorites is linguini with clam sauce. From entrees to sandwiches to pizza, we have never been disappointed!!
… more