Matthew Diederichs
Me and my wife usually love this Sammy’s. But the last two times have been subpar or worse. I ordered it online and showed up 25 minutes later and it was already done, I thought, “Great timing!” But no, it was already getting cold, and when I got home with it, one pizza was overcooked, the other was even worse and seemed like it was old. I think they had a medium pepperoni pizza sitting in the hotbox and just decided to use it. The other pizza was edible, but we just couldn’t fight through the pepperoni one. Long day at work and didn’t have time to stop and eat and this was my dinner. I even tipped five dollars I found earlier that day, I don’t have ton of money to spare and don’t get pizza often. We wanted to treat ourselves with what was one of our favorites and were met with disappointment. I only give 2 stars overall because I know what it’s like when it’s good. Best pizza in our area bar none. But if they can’t pull it off anymore I’ll just stop coming. I wouldn’t offer this to a homeless guy!
… moreDanika Miller
We had placed an order for a scheduled time, but when we were finished with errands a little earlier than we thought, we called and asked the staff if they could start the order now. They were very accommodating and nice, and it took about 10 mins for them to complete. The food was so good it was our first time. When I walked in I was greeted immediately and warmly. And the garlic butter is to die for. Will definitely be back!
… moreThomas Predhome Jr
Sammy’s Pizza is very good. We’ve tried the pizza, subs, and bread so far. If you want a quality pizza that is better than the more common chains I’d highly recommend it.
… moreMadeline Romatowski
Whoever worked last night was incredible! The food was amazing, as always, and they surprised us for our The Summer I Turned Pretty watch party!
Team Connie Baby!! ♾️
Thank you for making our watch party even more special 🙂
… moreAlexis Long
I ordered takeout for a watch party for The Summer I Turned Pretty. All the food was great. I requested they write “Team Conrad” and they went all out. Thanks to those working around dinner time on August 27th
… moreCarolyn DeRoo
One of our favorites in the area! The pizza is consistently delicious and always satisfying. The staff is friendly and welcoming every time we stop in. The deep dish is sooo good, but even the traditional hand tossed pizza never disappoints!
… moreJessica Anderson
Every last piece of lettuce was brown and orange, the beets, onions and tomatoes were super weird and slimy. My husband didn’t want to call to complain so I will just leave the photos here for everyone to see. There is no way the person making this salad didn’t see the ingredients were trash. My husband is such a fan of the pizza here, it’s a shame because we will never order here again because of it.
… moreLonely Sparrow
All around great place to eat! Hardly any wait time , great food! The staff working there bring great vibes and are very helpful! KEEP UP THE GREAT SERVICE!!!
… moreSteven Utter
My whole family jokes that everyday I have off work is “Sammy’s Day” . Do you really think I would be at visit number 85 if it wasn’t that absolutely amazingly good. Cheese bread 3x mozzarella cheddar cheese extra Parmesan well done 3x cinnamon sugar extra icing that is the order and I eat it twice a week and it’s the best food you can get. And it’s the thing I look forward to the most throughout the work week. Xoxoxo Sammy’s Pizza
… moreJoan Marie
First of all the young lady that answered the phone was pleasant and helpful. They delivered the pizza and wings hot and fast. The pizza was very good…I did ask for extra sauce and it didn’t seem like there was extra. Next time I would stress a bit more that I need extra or a side of extra sauce. If I lived near by we would definitely stop often
… more