James Justice
Out of all the pizza restaurants in our area where we live Pizza Plus is my wife’s and of course my favorite.. specialty pizza with everything thin crust extra sauce I can’t leave out the ham and cheese hoagie which completes the meal for me .. always hot and fresh
… moreAutria Jenkins
Pizza Plus in New Tazewell is truly a hidden gem! From the moment you walk in, you can tell this restaurant takes pride in everything they do. The place is spotless – clean floors, shiny tables, and a welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel comfortable right away.
The food is absolutely delicious! Their pizzas are always fresh, perfectly cooked, and loaded with flavor. Every bite is hot, cheesy, and satisfying, and their buffet offers so many tasty options that it’s hard to pick a favorite. Whether it’s the pizza, pasta, or desserts, everything tastes like it was made with care.
What really makes this place stand out, though, is the staff. The workers here are incredibly nice, professional, and attentive. They always greet you with a smile and go above and beyond to make sure you’re happy with your meal. It’s rare to find such genuine hospitality, but Pizza Plus in New Tazewell delivers it every time.
If you’re looking for great food, outstanding service, and a clean, friendly environment, this is the spot. Highly recommend – Pizza Plus never disappoints!
… moreAllen Daniels
Had the buffet and they even asked what kind of pizza we wanted and made it for us very nice staff
… moreSteve Marlow
I remember this place from when I was growing up. The spaghetti and meatballs used to be the best thing on the menu
… moreKelli C
The new manager is totally awesome!! The food and service were amazing!! Highly recommended.. yummy!!!
… moreTina Belanger
We are staying in Tazewell and were visiting over Memorial Day weekend 2024. Came back in from Knoxville and was trying to beat a serious storm heading to the area. Wanted to take pizza back to our place. Ride out part one of the storm waiting for the pizza. Getting back to the pizza itself, thin crust was a little too thin. Not cut evenly. Taste was ok. We would have to compare this pizza to other pizza places in the area to see if this is better, comparable or worse than others. The staff was super nice though.
… moreann devivo
It was a Mother’s Day Pizza buffet I think they’re not usually open on Sundays but they had one pizza out that they would replace often but not any choice, whatever they put out was what they put out. Small salad bar was pretty good. The server never came back to pick up plates even once. The pizza was fresh because it was usually gone in about 3 minutes so when you did get some it was good. They also had cheese sticks up there that you could usually get.
… moresusie welch
I used to love this place. Loved the salads and now not at all . A large salad is the size of a small and it costs around $9. You can’t no longer get everything on it. I recently ordered large one with everything all I got was the size of a small and it only had lettuce, tomatoes, green pepper, broccoli, and cheese where’s the egg, bacon bits and the rest of the stuff they used to put on them.
… moreDJ Templin
Fantastic. We were first time customers today and have been impressed. Pizza has plenty of ingredients and their weekend deal was a good price. The sweet tea was the sweetest and very fresh tasting. Workers seemed chipper and there was plenty of staff.
… moresherry mcgeorge
Waited 40 minutes for our food. Had to go in finally and it was just sitting there. They were doing other stuff. Then it wasn’t worth eating. 37.00 down the drain…. Never again Pizza Plus….
… more