Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 452 Oliver St, North Tonawanda, NY 14120
Phone: (716) 389-0052
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mayors Pizza – CLOSED, 452 Oliver St, North Tonawanda, NY …
Get more information for Mayors Pizza in North Tonawanda, NY. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
What happened to Mayor’s Pizza in North Tonawanda? – Facebook
Did they change phone numbers? It’s now called Family’s Pizza. Supposedly the same owners. |Give family pizzas a try.
Mayors Pizza: The Perfect Destination for Pizza and Wings Lovers
Discover Mayors Pizza in North Tonawanda, NY, where you’ll find mouthwatering chicken wings and delectable pepperoni pizza. Enjoy delivery, takeout …
Reviews
Daniel Malanowicz
Great pizza! Tried it out because I had never been. The owner was super friendly and talked about his specialty pizzas. The pie has a sweeter sauce, flavorful cheese and the dough has a great bite. Crust is crispy and fluffy but not too much. Cup n char pepperonis cooked to perfection. Well balanced pizza, will be coming back.
… moreDiana W
We tried here for the first time after my son played a basketball game in N.T. The customer service was top notch and our food was delicious. The breaded wings were the best we’ve tasted in a long time. We will definitely order from here again.
… moreRobert R
Haven’t found a good wing place in the area till now . Got the Cajun regular wings and hot breaded wings, and they were amazing. And perfectly cooked by an Army Vet. Thanks for your service.
It’s a great place for great food. Will definitely be back. I’m not sure how they get their wings cooked so perfectly, but their consistent and damm good.
… moreIt’s a great place for great food. Will definitely be back. I’m not sure how they get their wings cooked so perfectly, but their consistent and damm good.
nick osika
We moved from buffalo to NT. Buffalo has the best pizza anywhere in the planet but rather than make a trip to the city my mom stopped here at Mayors to get a pizza so she can see our new house. I was shocked the pizza was good and she said they were very nice in there! We ordered again yesterday and again it was good and they treated us really well on the phone. I highly recommend this Pizzaria and will continue to order here weekly.
… moreMegan Woods
I don’t usually have a problem with their food. I come from Niagara Falls just for food. But last night I got 2 subs and they were not good. The pizza sub I got had sauce that was so thick like paste. The other sub the meat was dry and had a wierd taste. Very disappointed.
… moreFrancesca Diaz
Phenomenal food and a great group of people! My absolute favorite sauce. My kids LOVE the breaded wings and sweet sauce combo. Subs are always consistent and tasty. Highly recommend
… moreCelia Eckstein
Love, love, love their pizza. The sauce is amazing and they don’t skimp on toppings. This is my new go to place. Haven’t tried the breaded wing yet but that’s next. Turned my Sister and Brother onto Mayor’s and we’re all believers. Glad they have opened up on Sundays for football season. Keep doing what you’re doing!
… moreBF IYT
Great service over the phone when ordering. Food is always good. The delivery is fast. Even my husband who is picky about pizza since he didn’t grow up in this area said it’s good. He especially likes the fingers. I turned my mom onto this place too and it’s her new favorite.
… moreKelsey Lee
They seriously have the best everything, everything! The food is amazing. It’s always hot. The pizza is delicious. We have not had one bad thing from there. The only thing that really sucks is your hours. But I’m assuming that’s due to not having much help which is completely out of your control, we only used to order Brando’s, but they have gone so downhill that we started thinking about checking this place out and boy am I glad we did. This is my new favorite place to order !! you guys are killing it.! Brandos should be extremely worried right now because with you in town they’re on a fast track to going out of business.
… moreHeidi Chase
Can’t get enough of their delicious pizza although it isn’t good for my diabetes. Wings are yummy too with their unique flavors. Just hope they don’t use the vendor with the baby wings.
… more