Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5010 W Vliet St, Milwaukee, WI 53208
Phone: (414) 476-7700
Website: https://caradaroclubpizza.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Caradaro Club Pizza | The Original Thin Crust Pizza Recipe of …
Welcome to Caradaro Club Pizza … The Original Thin Crust Pizza Recipe of Milwaukee’s First Pizza Establishment! Celebrating 80 …
The Original Caradaro Club Pizza | Milwaukee WI – Facebook
Caradaro Club Pizza has been serving the Milwaukee Community for 75 years. We have been able to be successful, not only with, Quality, Price and Convenience, …
Milwaukee’s First Pizzeria is Now Behind a Façade of a Café
Caradaro Club started serving pizzas in the late 1940s, making it the first pizzeria in Milwaukee. Since its founding, the original Caradaro Club went through …
Reviews
Matt
Stopped in a few minutes after opening at 4:00 p.m. the phone was ringing off the hook. I ordered a large cheese sausage black olive, onion pizza and crispy garlic bread sticks. The pizza was thin and crispy and the toppings were delicious. It’s big enough to feed at least 4 people. The garlic bread sticks were the pizza dough fried and we’re so light and crispy and had the right amount of garlic. I spoke with the gentleman who took my order and he told me that this was the original recipe since 1945. This is an excellent representation of a great thin crust pizza. Get some!
… moreCarri Torcivia
We ordered pizza delivery tonight and everything was fantastic! The order arrived right on time and the driver was super friendly. The pizza had the perfect balance of crispy crust, fresh toppings and a nice tomato sauce — you can really taste the quality ingredients. My husband also ordered a side of chicken tenders with french fries and he loved them….and he is super picky about his chicken!
It’s hard to find delivery that’s both fast and consistently good, but this place nailed it. Definitely our new go-to for pizza delivery nights! Thank you, Caradaro Club, for a delicious meal❤️
… moreIt’s hard to find delivery that’s both fast and consistently good, but this place nailed it. Definitely our new go-to for pizza delivery nights! Thank you, Caradaro Club, for a delicious meal❤️
J D
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Caradaro Club – Milwaukee’s First Pizza and Ongoing Community Partner
Caradaro Club holds a special place in Milwaukee history as the city’s very first pizza restaurant, opening in 1945 thanks to founders John Caravella and Joe Todaro. Known for its thin, crispy Milwaukee‑style crust and mozzarella sticks, it remains a local classic worth the trip. But what makes Caradaro Club stand out even more is its ongoing commitment to neighbors. Wally printed flyers and attached pizza coupons to support our Annual Martin Drive Neighborhood Association Rummage Sale. During a difficult time for both the restaurant industry and families fighting COVID‑19, Caradaro Club gave away *160* free pizzas to Martin Drive residents—a generous thank‑you that built on years of partnership. Most recently, they gave away *160* pizzas to help raise funds for the Bob Uecker plaque at American Family Field, proving that their generosity continues today. And they still support community events like our Outdoor Movie Nights, showing up as a trusted neighbor as well as a local business.
Caradaro Club has proven itself as both a Milwaukee landmark and a genuine community ally, combining historic roots with lasting generosity and true neighborhood spirit.
Its hot, tasty pizza and appetizers are just as consistent as their community support.
… moreCaradaro Club – Milwaukee’s First Pizza and Ongoing Community Partner
Caradaro Club holds a special place in Milwaukee history as the city’s very first pizza restaurant, opening in 1945 thanks to founders John Caravella and Joe Todaro. Known for its thin, crispy Milwaukee‑style crust and mozzarella sticks, it remains a local classic worth the trip. But what makes Caradaro Club stand out even more is its ongoing commitment to neighbors. Wally printed flyers and attached pizza coupons to support our Annual Martin Drive Neighborhood Association Rummage Sale. During a difficult time for both the restaurant industry and families fighting COVID‑19, Caradaro Club gave away *160* free pizzas to Martin Drive residents—a generous thank‑you that built on years of partnership. Most recently, they gave away *160* pizzas to help raise funds for the Bob Uecker plaque at American Family Field, proving that their generosity continues today. And they still support community events like our Outdoor Movie Nights, showing up as a trusted neighbor as well as a local business.
Caradaro Club has proven itself as both a Milwaukee landmark and a genuine community ally, combining historic roots with lasting generosity and true neighborhood spirit.
Its hot, tasty pizza and appetizers are just as consistent as their community support.
Erika Comdohr
By far in the top 3 pizza places I have had in Milwaukee. The crust was perfectly crisp throughout and didn’t have any sogginess in the middle. The pizza was perfectly seasoned. We were going to only eat half of the pizza and ended up eating the whole thing in one sitting because it was so good!
I can’t comment on the atmosphere of the restaurant since we got take out, but our pizza was ready right on time when we expected it to be.
… moreI can’t comment on the atmosphere of the restaurant since we got take out, but our pizza was ready right on time when we expected it to be.
Morgan Trokan
Best thin crust around! Worth any wait on a busy night. I didn’t catch his name, but the nicest man even offered to carry my pizzas to the car across the street, thank you! The mozzarella sticks are wonton wrapped topped with Parmesan cheese & spices, SO good. 10/10 recommend & be nice to the pizza dude.. or no pizza for you!
… moreMaureen Kearn
These guys are the best! Order all the time! Our delivery guy is great! Tonight he bought the dog xmas advent toy calander! Seriously that’s care !
I cant thank you enough
Soooooo yummy. ❤️
… moreI cant thank you enough
Soooooo yummy. ❤️
doglvr895
Excellent pizza from Milwaukee’s oldest pizzeria! We chatted with an older gentleman who took our order – mentioned we visited because of the Secret Milwaukee book – he is an absolute TREASURE! Pizza excellent!
… moreAmy Meyer
Great pizza .. Milwaukee style at its finest! Cheese bread is amazing!
… moreMark Giuntoli
I’ve been a customer here for17 years and in my opinion it’s one of THE BEST pizzas in MKE. Always consistent. One of the tastiest sauces and some of the best sausage ever! Friendly staff and for an extra treat, try their garlic bread. Delicious! Weekends can be super busy. Best times during the week. Reasonable prices make this my #1 choice for pizza! ❤️
… moreChris Erbes
I wrote this around 4 years ago, and the food here continues to set the gold standard.
Really good thin crust, crispy even in the middle. Ordered a large veg. The sauce is full of flavors, but not overwhelming. Everything was very fresh and you could taste each ingredient.
I’m a big fan of Balistreri’s, Pizzeria Piccola, Maria’s, Pizza Shuttle and Wells Brothers. This is unique to all of them, but close to PizzPicc, though the dough not as chewy.
Big glasses of water given after we sat down.
… moreReally good thin crust, crispy even in the middle. Ordered a large veg. The sauce is full of flavors, but not overwhelming. Everything was very fresh and you could taste each ingredient.
I’m a big fan of Balistreri’s, Pizzeria Piccola, Maria’s, Pizza Shuttle and Wells Brothers. This is unique to all of them, but close to PizzPicc, though the dough not as chewy.
Big glasses of water given after we sat down.