Sue Montana
I’ve order the Cowboy pizza many times but this was this first time ordering a custom pizza. The toppings were very generous a great value for the price. And their Mediterranean salad is good too.
… moreVeronika Mazur
I recently tried the 14’’ stuffed crust cheese pizza with garlic crust, and unfortunately, it fell well below expectations. What I received wasn’t remotely close to the quality you’d expect from a pizzeria—or even a halfway decent frozen brand. This pizza was more reminiscent of something you’d find under heat lamps at a rundown gas station or languishing in a school cafeteria.
From the first bite, the cheese slid off in one sad, rubbery sheet, the crust was overly doughy, and the whole thing was drowning in grease. As for the flavor—there wasn’t any. The garlic crust tasted like plain bread, and the “stuffed” portion was so bland I had to check twice to confirm it was actually filled with anything at all. Visually, the pizza looked promising, but the flavor simply didn’t match the appearance.
To be blunt, this was worse than anything I’ve had from Domino’s, Pizza Hut, or Papa John’s—and that’s saying something. I’d never heard of Papa Murphy’s before, and now I understand why. This pizza would struggle to compete even in the frozen aisle.
To make matters worse, there was a shady billing issue. I selected a specific tip amount in person, only to discover later that exactly 20% had been added to my bill without my consent. No receipt was provided at the time, so I only caught this when reviewing my credit card statement. That’s not just poor service—that’s a serious red flag. If you still choose to order from here, check your receipt closely… assuming they even bother to give you one.
… moreOlivia Seitz
Love the pizza here. Easy to get a discount when ordering online. Pickup is easy, they always get our order right & done quickly. Love the flexibility of picking it up when it’s convenient and then making it at home.
… moreDennis Halejak
Great people, great product, great service, and the ordering system absolutely SUCKS. Whoever came up with the online and phone ordering system must have their head where the sun don’t shine. This system is definitely designed to drive business away… I’m gone!!!
… moreSadie Hug
Awesome pizza and thats alot coming from me who’s from NY and Italian
… moreThe Good Greek
Easy to follow instructions and the pizza is great! Highly recommend the Mediterranean one.
… moreChristina Mantych
The customer service was warm and friendly, and I truly enjoyed the overall experience. The pizza itself was tasty — the crust, cheese, and toppings were all very good. However, my only concern was with the sauce. On both pizzas we ordered, there was noticeably too little. The regular red sauce was barely detectable, and the creamy red sauce on the second pizza was almost nonexistent. When we pulled back the cheese, there was very little sauce underneath. While everything else was great, a more balanced amount of sauce would have made the pizzas even better.
… moreAnne B. Wilkins
Delicious food, great service, and a great price!! Will definitely be going back!
… moreCrissy Lee
Pizza was perfectly topped. Online order was ready when I arrived. And staff even gave me a few tips to make sure I baked my pizza right. Can’t wait to go back next time I’m in town I will be sure to stop by.
… moreSkip Dyer
Debra and her team at Papa Murphy’s in Cary are fantastic. The pizza is always delicious, but what sets them apart is their customer service. There aren’t many places where EVERY person working there is pleasant, happy, and focused on doing a great job for their customers. This is that rare place. I’ve been going there for years and have never had anything less than a positive experience and terrific pizza.
… more