Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Indiana, PA, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Indiana pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Indiana or stop by 1386 Oakland Avenue for carryout to order the best pizza in Indiana, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
1386 Oakland Avenue – Indiana, PA – Papa Johns Pizza Locations
Call us for pizza delivery in Indiana or stop by 1386 Oakland Avenue for carryout to order the best pizza in Indiana, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Papa Johns Pizza Delivery & Carryout – Best Deals on Pizza, Sides …
Enjoy the ease of ordering delicious pizza for delivery or carryout from a Papa Johns near you. Start tracking the speed of your delivery and earn rewards …
papa johns stores in indiana, pa
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in Indiana, Pennsylvania to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Last Updates
Reviews
Juan Gracian
Can you guess how many toppings this za is supposed to have, just by looking at it? Me Neither!
This papa pairings “deal” allows you to buy multiple items for the low price of 6.99/item! The two items were only 25.76, how affordable! I got a medium new York style, EXTRA DONE pizza with pepperoni and bacon, and a side of garlic knots. I realize it’s generally accepted that second toppings cost more, so I understood that to be the case at the time of purchase. Doing the math it came out to 12.88 for each item. That’s a whopping 84.26% MORE than advertised. Granted though, at the end of my receipt, before additional fees and taxes, they dropped it down to $23.24, how generous, truly.
The whole mess of a meal cost me $33.42, $5 of which being a delivery fee(15%). As much as I feel these exorbitant fees are merely another case of corporate greed, I understand them. What I don’t appreciate here is not just the abominable math, but the fact that I didnt really even get what I ordered!
The pizza was soggy and undercooked,and I have maybe 7 or 8 pieces of pepperoni on a pepperoni and BACON pizza. This is an insult, and I remember why I stopped buying from this papa John’s in particular. And frankly the garlic knots, should knot exist, they’re terrible, taste like plastic and seemed to have been baked dry having only had some cold, garlic seasoned, “butter” concoction squirted on them last minute in an attempt to make them palatable.
What a horrendous crime scene of a meal, I hope next time I am exhausted and in need of a “cheap”, quick meal, I’ll see this review and remember my vow to never purchase from this particular location.
Thank you for ruining my evening.
… moreThis papa pairings “deal” allows you to buy multiple items for the low price of 6.99/item! The two items were only 25.76, how affordable! I got a medium new York style, EXTRA DONE pizza with pepperoni and bacon, and a side of garlic knots. I realize it’s generally accepted that second toppings cost more, so I understood that to be the case at the time of purchase. Doing the math it came out to 12.88 for each item. That’s a whopping 84.26% MORE than advertised. Granted though, at the end of my receipt, before additional fees and taxes, they dropped it down to $23.24, how generous, truly.
The whole mess of a meal cost me $33.42, $5 of which being a delivery fee(15%). As much as I feel these exorbitant fees are merely another case of corporate greed, I understand them. What I don’t appreciate here is not just the abominable math, but the fact that I didnt really even get what I ordered!
The pizza was soggy and undercooked,and I have maybe 7 or 8 pieces of pepperoni on a pepperoni and BACON pizza. This is an insult, and I remember why I stopped buying from this papa John’s in particular. And frankly the garlic knots, should knot exist, they’re terrible, taste like plastic and seemed to have been baked dry having only had some cold, garlic seasoned, “butter” concoction squirted on them last minute in an attempt to make them palatable.
What a horrendous crime scene of a meal, I hope next time I am exhausted and in need of a “cheap”, quick meal, I’ll see this review and remember my vow to never purchase from this particular location.
Thank you for ruining my evening.
T Kring
Genuinely so beyond sick of getting my order sent to DoorDash every single time I order, and yes I tip well. I worked at papa john’s before and I know personally that you’re not supposed to be using DoorDash as a first response, utilize your delivery drivers like you’re supposed to. I’ve delivered pizzas up until closing, what’s your excuse? I’m 6 mins from the store, y’all don’t have the time? Lazy establishment, dominos in town does WAYYY better. The pizza here also sucks, y’all use old dough that’s clearly been sitting out all day long, once again I know that’s not the food safety practice you should be using. Literal cardboard. Hardly any sauce on the breadsticks. Seems like they skimp on toppings too when there’s a literal visual representation to show how much to give. Y’all give papa John’s a horrible name, the food is actually good when made by other stores that care about their service. The papa John’s I worked at would neverrrrr. Take your service elsewhere.
… moreIsaac
Pizza is under cooked and barely palatable. Garlic sauce is also awful it’s just oil. Gross
… moreOvO
The staff are Wonderful, very kind, very patient, and helpful (I was using gift cards) Thank you all for your work ethics and always making some great pizzas
… moreJoe
I have never failed to get good pizza from this location on Oakland Ave, for years now. They have a very good variety of crusts to choose from, which is very nice. My fav is the New York style crust. The wings are also excellent. Prices are reasonable too, especially with the coupons they always have, plus “Papa Dough” for regular customers. Friendly staff as well. It may be the best pizza joint in town!!
… moreKimberly Rager
We lived in apts right behind Papa John’s .I loved all the pizzas and chicken strips the cheese sticks me and my son ate a lot .great people worked there too when we lived up there .
… moreDustin Griffith
Just had my order cancelled without a good explanation. I’m guessing short staff or lack of competent employees. Have ordered from this location in the past and was satisfied. Wasn’t even offered anything for the inconvenience. It wasn’t a small order either.
… moreTim Pickens
Called in for an order placed it gave me card information was told that it would be 40-45 minutes
Almost an hour passed by I called the store to see when I was going to receive my order
The dude that answered the phone straight said “we are closed” then just hung up on me
So I called back same dude answered again and had to give the phone to someone else
Totally unprofessional right there
If dominos was open I wouldve just ordered there
Cheaper and faster time and friendlier
… moreAlmost an hour passed by I called the store to see when I was going to receive my order
The dude that answered the phone straight said “we are closed” then just hung up on me
So I called back same dude answered again and had to give the phone to someone else
Totally unprofessional right there
If dominos was open I wouldve just ordered there
Cheaper and faster time and friendlier
Christian Norfolk
Service is always terrible here, walk in and wait about 5 minutes to be spoken to. The manager or who seems like the manager, Brandon, was vaping in the store while food was being made. Seems unsanitary to me
… more