Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Pink-accented, nautical-themed restaurant in the Chippewa Hotel featuring American fare.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 7221 Main St #103, Mackinac Island, MI 49757
Phone: (906) 847-3341
Website: http://www.pinkponymackinac.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Pink Pony on Mackinac Island | Bar & Restaurant
The Pink Pony is the best bar and restaurant on Mackinac Island. Thrillist votes it as Michigan’s most iconic bar and grill! Come see for yourself!
Food Menus | Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner | Pink Pony Mackinac
… Mackinac Island’s best restaurant … P.O. Box 250 | Mackinac Island, MI 49757 | 906.847.3341 | [email protected].
Shop | Pink Pony Mackinac
Pink Pony Mackinac · Home · Eat · Drink · Entertainment · Reservations · Shop · Shop All · Gift Cards · Reviews · 800-241-3341. Select Page. © 2025 Chippewa …
Reviews
Amanda M
This place is a classic tourist trap but is good for what it is. We came for lunch, we were not provided the option to sit with a view of the lake so for us this was just a normal restaurant experience.
I ordered the whitefish dip. It was OK but somewhat fishier than other ones I’ve tried. The pita chips were crunchy and yummy.
The French dip I ordered with caramelized onions and mushrooms. I wouldn’t do that upgrade again. The French dip was good and had a lot of meat but nothing to write home about. Upgraded to fries cost $4.
Beers range from $11-13 and cocktails $20-$30, I would not order alcohol here unless you’re ok with those prices.
Our server was a bit standoffish and efficient but not very friendly. Overall, I likely wouldn’t come back and would try a different restaurant but there is nothing wrong per se with this restaurant. It’s just very mid.
… moreI ordered the whitefish dip. It was OK but somewhat fishier than other ones I’ve tried. The pita chips were crunchy and yummy.
The French dip I ordered with caramelized onions and mushrooms. I wouldn’t do that upgrade again. The French dip was good and had a lot of meat but nothing to write home about. Upgraded to fries cost $4.
Beers range from $11-13 and cocktails $20-$30, I would not order alcohol here unless you’re ok with those prices.
Our server was a bit standoffish and efficient but not very friendly. Overall, I likely wouldn’t come back and would try a different restaurant but there is nothing wrong per se with this restaurant. It’s just very mid.
Vicki Horton
The Pink Pony is such an iconic spot! My mom kept telling me I had to go, and now I can see why! The place was packed, and we had to wait a little over an hour for a table, but it was worth it. We just shopped around until we got the text that our table was ready.
We were seated outside right by the water, and the view was incredible. Everything was clean, the music was great, and the staff was super friendly. The atmosphere was lively and fun—everyone around us seemed to be having a great time.
For food, we ordered the fish tacos and the whitefish sandwich, and both were delicious! The sweet potato fries were the real standout, though—so good.
The only downside is that they never played Pink Pony Club while we were there, which would’ve been the cherry on top! Lol
Overall, this place lived up to the hype and then some. I would absolutely come back next time I’m on Mackinac Island!
… moreWe were seated outside right by the water, and the view was incredible. Everything was clean, the music was great, and the staff was super friendly. The atmosphere was lively and fun—everyone around us seemed to be having a great time.
For food, we ordered the fish tacos and the whitefish sandwich, and both were delicious! The sweet potato fries were the real standout, though—so good.
The only downside is that they never played Pink Pony Club while we were there, which would’ve been the cherry on top! Lol
Overall, this place lived up to the hype and then some. I would absolutely come back next time I’m on Mackinac Island!
Tim Rose
Cool atmosphere and good drinks, but food was disappointing for the price – came at exactly 11:30 (start of lunch) and had them add me to waitlist which was about 35min.
Good: They got us outside on the deck and the server Harry was polite and quick. My wife tried the Rum Runner (frozen which she wasn’t expecting) and dirty martini – both good. Kids liked the kids meals and the French onion soup was good as well.
Mid: Tacos were good and matched what the other peoples pictures showed but sat under heat lamp too long and the tortillas were hard and stiff. I’ll give them the benefit of the doubt since it was busy and other people seemed to have good luck with it.
Bad: My $21 Prime Rib French dip was not Prime rib (see picture) and on par with the Arby’s version for flavor. I was so looking forward to some nicely slice ribeye on there. This is a wild price for this level of sandwich – would not order.
Overall it wasn’t bad, but I would choose a different spot next time and recommend against the roast beef sandwich.
… moreGood: They got us outside on the deck and the server Harry was polite and quick. My wife tried the Rum Runner (frozen which she wasn’t expecting) and dirty martini – both good. Kids liked the kids meals and the French onion soup was good as well.
Mid: Tacos were good and matched what the other peoples pictures showed but sat under heat lamp too long and the tortillas were hard and stiff. I’ll give them the benefit of the doubt since it was busy and other people seemed to have good luck with it.
Bad: My $21 Prime Rib French dip was not Prime rib (see picture) and on par with the Arby’s version for flavor. I was so looking forward to some nicely slice ribeye on there. This is a wild price for this level of sandwich – would not order.
Overall it wasn’t bad, but I would choose a different spot next time and recommend against the roast beef sandwich.
Robert Kovach
It was the best prepared food and best service that we have had in a long time. The Prime Rib, vegetables, and mashed potatoes were all fabulous. My wife had Beer Battered Whitefish which was great.
The harbor view was beautiful.
The service was terrific. Food came out very quickly. This place is VERY well managed.
Thank you, Pink Pony, for a terrific dinner.
… moreThe harbor view was beautiful.
The service was terrific. Food came out very quickly. This place is VERY well managed.
Thank you, Pink Pony, for a terrific dinner.
Tim Stevenson
We chose here to eat outside on the enclosed deck. We were apprehensive at first as it was the day before the Grand Hotel shuts down for the season and was a bit chilly out. To our pleasant surprise they had several pyramid outdoor heaters that kept the area toasty and still enjoy the fall colors! The food was even better than the last time we ate here. The white fish sandwich hit the spot!!! Very glad we made the decision to stop here and eat.
… moreJoby Jerrells
The Pink Pony is a must stop when on the island. A fun, eclectic atmosphere with great food, drinks, and more. We loved sitting in our booth streetside. Great for people watching! The Patty melt with sweet potato fries was a great choice for lunch.
Came back on day 2 and the beet salad was fantastic. Best pulled pork sandwich I’ve had!
… moreCame back on day 2 and the beet salad was fantastic. Best pulled pork sandwich I’ve had!
Al
Was highly recommended this place for lunch or dinner when we went to the island and it didn’t disappoint. The drinks were strong and delicious and the food was great. We got the flatbread appetizier, a salad with goat cheese and apples, and the whitefish tacos. Our waiter (sadly I can’t remember his name now) was amazing and hilarious.
We got to sit outside on the back patio near the water. It was a relaxing lunch with delicious foods and drinks. Highly recommend.
… moreWe got to sit outside on the back patio near the water. It was a relaxing lunch with delicious foods and drinks. Highly recommend.
Joyce D
Outstanding experience from start to finish! From the friendly service at the bar while waiting for a table to the delicious meal, drinks, and excellent service from Cory, everything was perfect. The broiled whitefish was moist and cooked to perfection. My husband loved his whitefish and chips, and the rum runners with a rum floater were outstanding! We highly recommend this restaurant
… moreMaria Vences
We came for my grandads birthday and we had the most pleasant time. We have been here several times and I have to say that. Cornell is the best waiter here, hands down. He was so sweet and on top of everything. We can’t thank enough for the way he treated us
… morepaula jones
I know most people seem like this place, but we found it a little lackluster as far as the food having much flavor and we thought the prices were high, especially for the food we received. However, the sweet potato fries did not disappoint, but my husband didn’t care for the sweet sauce on his burger.
… more