Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
The Magpie Bakery is a beloved, locally owned bakery specializing in artisanal baked goods, handcrafted pies, custom cakes, and exceptional coffee. Renowned for its inviting atmosphere and outstanding customer service, it offers a delightful array of sweet and savory treats, perfect for any occasion. Every item is freshly baked with love daily!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2-14 Riverside Square, Bloomingdale, NJ 07403
Phone: (973) 291-6756
Website: http://www.magpiebakery.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Magpie Bakery – Bloomingdale, NJ 07403 (Menu & Order Online)
Online ordering menu for The Magpie Bakery. The Magpie Bakery is a cozy neighberhood bakery filled with delicious treats. We specialize in sweet and savory …
The Magpie Bakery | Bloomingdale NJ – Facebook
From football-themed cakes to crowd-pleasing cupcakes, we’ve got the desserts that show up ready for kickoff. Perfect for watch parties, office pools, or just …
The Magpie Bakery
Welcome to Magpie Bakery, a delightful haven nestled in the heart of Bloomingdale, New Jersey, where every confection tells a story and every bite is a journey …
Reviews
Doris Martinez
My husband got cupcakes made for my birthday which were delicious & beautiful! Typically I use another bakery for custom cakes but decided to give them a try for my daughter’s birthday. It came out exactly as I requested. My daughter was so happy!! Not to mention that they accommodated a pick up a day earlier due to the snow storm for us. Great customer service too!!
… moreCollin “CEphotoArt” Erickson
I recently had the absolute pleasure working with The Magpie Bakery to create two custom cakes for my wife’s surprise birthday party. It was really great sitting down with Melanie to discuss the cakes and to hear her suggestions even though it was a very busy day at the bakery. They took time to make the cakes perfectly for our occasion. Thank you so much for such a great experience and the cakes were delicious. We had a 10” vanilla cake with buttercream and a strawberry jam interior. The 8” cake was a carrot cake with cream cheese frosting. As you can see, we went with a November theme. Thank you again.
… moreN. Sedaghat
We ordered cupcakes and a cake for my daughter’s birthday- frozen themed… and we couldn’t be happier. The interaction was easy as always and the end result was beautiful! Thank you again!!
… moreGabby Davis
We got my sisters birthday cake from Magpie Bakery and it was absolutely delicious! Both women in there were super kind and helpful in helping us get the perfect cake for her! The cake was beautifully decorated and tasted amazing. 10/10 would recommend. Shout out to the lovely ladies Cheryl and Wendy for making her birthday end on a sweet note!
… moreLisa Rino
What an incredible experience! I went in this morning to pick up vegan treats for my co-worker’s birthday and regular pastries for the rest of my team. It was such a pleasure— the women there were so kind and helpful. The treats were out of this world! I honestly haven’t had a donut that delicious. Everything I brought to work was a huge hit with my colleagues. Thank you so much for making it all so special!
… moreBrian Minarovich
Small family owned friendly, first time trying mag by today trying to expand my espresso options after seeing them on Instagram I figured I’d give him a shot after looking in to them. I took my dog car and headed there for a doughnut and a Cortado. Consistent flow of customers we were greeted at the door with a friendly hello and good morning. It took me longer to figure out what I want than it did to whip my order up. I was very pleased with both, but I do have to say this was hands-down. Donut was sooooo fresh. The Donut was so soft it paired perfectly with the sweet icing that all seem to evaporate in my mouth like a fine cognac. Confidently i will say that without a doubt this was the best donut I have ever eaten in my life . Too good to share ….sorry Cardi Beagle.
Went back after writing this review to grab another doughnut but with chocolate drizzle, still too good to share. Can’t wait to bring people here.
… moreWent back after writing this review to grab another doughnut but with chocolate drizzle, still too good to share. Can’t wait to bring people here.
Evgeniya Kavun-King
Absolutely disappointed. Dry pastry layers and “cream” seemed like a stick of chocolate butter smeared on top of it that was separating from the layers. They knew it was my 40th birthday cake and still sold it to my husband.
… morepatrick postiglione
I work in the Riverdale area 2 days a week and while on my lunch break i decided to do a search for coffee shops. I was fortunate enough to come across this little gem in Bloomingdale. Its not often you find a bakery that makes lemon bars, (at least that is my opinion) these were incredible! The other pastries and doughnuts also looked fresh and amazing! I did grab a chocolate brownie and a blueberry custard tart. The coffee was also nothing short of amazing. I like when I find unique menu items for coffee, and I had this cold brew with Strawberry foam, of course now I can’t remember the exact name but the pictures show how amazing it looks! The coffee was ice cold, smooth and delicious. In addition to the amazing cupcakes, pies and pastries, they also have Potpies, Shepard’s pie and a few others! Another place I highly recommend for coffee lovers and people with a sweet and savory tooth alike!
… moreSethington
A lovely little bakery tucked in the back of the mini mall. The squares and scones are lovely and flavorful, and the hand pies make for a tasty light lunch. Everything has always been excellent.
… moreErin Blasi
I ordered a gender reveal cake without much notice and Magpie exceeded our expectations! Not only was it ready within a few hours (on Father’s Day no less) but it looked exactly like our inspiration photo! Not to mention it was also delicious☺️ Thank you for being a part of our gender reveal!!
… more