Easygoing pizzeria offering plentiful sandwiches, plus wraps, burgers & calzones.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1512 E 7th Ave, Tampa, FL 33605
Phone: (813) 248-1845
Website: http://nynypizzeria.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
New York New York Pizza | Authentic Pizza in Florida
Enjoy authentic New York-style pizza at New York New York Pizza! Visit us in Tampa, Ybor City, Wesley Chapel & more. Order online or dine in today!
New York New York Pizza – View Menu & Order Online – Slice
Gourmet Pizza · Best seller. Meat Lover’s Pizza · Buffalo Chicken Pizza. Chicken, hot sauce mix, mozzarella. · Grandma Pizza. This seasoned crust, plum tomatoes, …
New York New York Pizza | Tampa FL – Facebook
New York New York Pizza, Tampa. 4265 likes · 51 talking about this · 15420 were here. ALWAYS FRESH ALWAYS FROM SCRATCH! Try one of our 8 locations…
Reviews
Chris C Controls Engineer
Been here a couple of times and they have excellent pizza, maybe the best in the city. I have eaten pizza everywhere and this place has the flavors worked out at prices that are excellent too. Patrick helped me discover a new pizza, Grandmas pizza, a delicious change from my normal meat lovers I very much enjoyed. They are open late after the crowds and downtown in the club district so when you are out on the town and need a quick bite that won’t let you down, check this pizza out, like I said it may be the best in town! No fooling, it was that good. 5 star service from Patrick he’s very knowledgeable about pizza, friendly and his upbeat personality that gets 5 stars too! Thanks Patrick I will be back!
… moreBryan Hutcherson
This was my first time here. I ordered the 2 slice pepperoni with a diet Pepsi. The pizza was perfectly cooked and full of flavor. It wasn’t floppy like other NY style pizzas I’ve had; the bottom of the crust had a gentle crisp to it. I wasn’t really sure what I even wanted to eat as I just flew in and I wasn’t craving anything. I’m so glad I chose this place! It absolutely hit the spot and wasn’t heavy on the stomach.
I also thought the decor was neat, especially the walls of newspaper headlines!
… moreI also thought the decor was neat, especially the walls of newspaper headlines!
GatorJosh01
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️½
I recently visited NYNYPizzeria in Ybor City and it was a delightful experience from start to finish. The service was warm, attentive, and genuinely friendly—our server made us feel welcome and made great suggestions. The food itself was outstanding: perfectly crisp crust, rich and flavorful toppings, and cooked just right. The atmosphere was lively yet comfortable, with the right balance of casual fun and inviting energy. Whether you’re looking for a relaxed dinner or a fun night out, this place is a winner. Highly recommend it—I’ll definitely be returning.
… moreI recently visited NYNYPizzeria in Ybor City and it was a delightful experience from start to finish. The service was warm, attentive, and genuinely friendly—our server made us feel welcome and made great suggestions. The food itself was outstanding: perfectly crisp crust, rich and flavorful toppings, and cooked just right. The atmosphere was lively yet comfortable, with the right balance of casual fun and inviting energy. Whether you’re looking for a relaxed dinner or a fun night out, this place is a winner. Highly recommend it—I’ll definitely be returning.
Anand R
Pizza Slice very great size…. XXXL Size New York style.
The crust was soft enough but the Cheese Pizza was not so tasty.
I ordered a Cheese slize and it was reasonably priced. The toppings can be added which are again reasonable.
They have lots of seating arrangement outside and inside its a huge place and spacious.
Parking is difficult to find and it’s paid Parking during daytime.
The guy who took the order in the counter situated outside was friendly and knowledgeable about the menus.
Otherwise it was a great experience and I would recommend this place to anyone.
… moreThe crust was soft enough but the Cheese Pizza was not so tasty.
I ordered a Cheese slize and it was reasonably priced. The toppings can be added which are again reasonable.
They have lots of seating arrangement outside and inside its a huge place and spacious.
Parking is difficult to find and it’s paid Parking during daytime.
The guy who took the order in the counter situated outside was friendly and knowledgeable about the menus.
Otherwise it was a great experience and I would recommend this place to anyone.
Brittany Santillan
Great pizza, perfect place for sharing. I went here not long ago with some classmates and we split 2 big pizzas. The staff was nice empuro split the bill into accurate amounts. Would recommend to try at least once.
… moreRebecca Baggett
This was the first time ever trying this kind of pizza and now I know why New Yorkers fold their pizza in half lol. The pizza slice that I got was very good and all the ingredients was real not some fake shit but the best part was the sauce I will be coming here for now on and if I could give more stars then I would definitely. But for me I can say this I give u a 10/10 the best
… moreVanity Duran
Uff, NY NY Pizza has got to be my favorite pizza in Tampa. They made me a half-and-half chicken Alfredo and supreme pizza—not a lot of people would do that, AND it was cooked to perfection. The service was great. I jammed out with one of the pizza makers, which was great. I’ve been coming here since my early Ybor days, so seeing how they revamped the place was neat. I love the ambiance, little details, and that newspaper wall is epic!
… moreCarl Moore
Pizza taste great. Great ingredients. Pizza comes out very hot! Word to the wise – give your pizza a few minutes to rest and it’ll be easier to eat. I prefer my pizza crust a little thicker, but this is NY style!
… moreRaeann Butler
This place was amazing. Prices were competitive & pizza was so delicious. We got the grandma pizza, white pizza, & pepperoni. The staff was kind & attentive. The place was clean. I have an extremely sensitive stomach when it comes to rich or greasy food & I ate both my slices (which were pretty large) && didn’t have any stomach issues all night. Looking forward to visiting Ybor again just to eat this pizza!!
… moreBritni Mixon
I moved to Ybor in December and this has quickly become my go to pizza spot. The pizza is easily the best around and the service is always amazing. Bobby is incredibly attentive and accommodating and always makes sure my experience is great every time I come in. I recommend New York New York to anyone I talk to and it’s the first place I bring friends when they come to visit.
… more