Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
MAMMA’S PIZZA of Wellsville – Facebook
… (380 Reviews). . $$. . Open now. . 5 York St, Wellsville, PA, United States, 17365. Links. . mammaswellsvillepa.com. Services. . Specialties. Curbside …
MAMMA’S PIZZA of Wellsville – Facebook
Cover photo of MAMMA’S PIZZA of Wellsville. MAMMA’S PIZZA of Wellsville. Best pizza anywhere. Italian Restaurant · $$. . Follow · See all About.
Mammas Pizza of Wellsville – Grubhub
Order delivery or pickup from Mammas Pizza of Wellsville in Wellsville! View Mammas Pizza of Wellsville’s February 2026 deals and menus.
Reviews
Miranda M
Original review below, updated review as follows! I didn’t hear anything back from this review so I took to their Facebook page. They responded swiftly and offered a free pizza to replace the one they sent Tuesday. We picked our pizza (and side order of loaded fries up) and both were delicious and filling. Thank you for working with us, and we will definitely continue to order from Mamma’s in the future.
We typically love Mamma’s, they have something for everyone and they deliver from Wellsville all the way out to us in Dillsburg. We’ve ordered from them many times. Tonight we placed an order for a medium chicken alfredo pizza, a medium four cheese pizza, and a large loaded seasoned fry. We waited about an hour to recieve our pizza, no big deal there. However upon opening the chicken alfredo pizza to say it was disappointing would be an understatement. They apparently ran out of grilled chicken so they put a bunch of fried chicken on top and the alfredo sauce is almost nonexistent. They didn’t take my phone number when I placed the order, or inform us when they delivered they did not have the ingredients to make the correct pizza. Never having had to check before, we didn’t check before they left. Moving forward I suppose we’ll leave a number and ask if they have all the ingredients BEFORE placing the order.
… moreWe typically love Mamma’s, they have something for everyone and they deliver from Wellsville all the way out to us in Dillsburg. We’ve ordered from them many times. Tonight we placed an order for a medium chicken alfredo pizza, a medium four cheese pizza, and a large loaded seasoned fry. We waited about an hour to recieve our pizza, no big deal there. However upon opening the chicken alfredo pizza to say it was disappointing would be an understatement. They apparently ran out of grilled chicken so they put a bunch of fried chicken on top and the alfredo sauce is almost nonexistent. They didn’t take my phone number when I placed the order, or inform us when they delivered they did not have the ingredients to make the correct pizza. Never having had to check before, we didn’t check before they left. Moving forward I suppose we’ll leave a number and ask if they have all the ingredients BEFORE placing the order.
Colleen Neidrauer
Great food, super quick and delivered right to your car. We are from out of town, and camping in the area. What a find this was. I cannot finish the giant sub, so lunch tomorrow. The freshed baked rolls were awesome. If you are near York PA, go to this place.
… moreJoe Kay
A beautiful small town and they have this amazing Italian restaurant. We had the special of a lg 1 topping pizza and 12 wings. The pizza was perfect! And the wings are the best wings I’ve had in a long time. Keep up the great work!!
… moreEric Filler
My buddy told me about this place and their “hot honey” pepperoni pizza. Unbelievable! There are very welcoming and the food is fantastic. I also saw on their FB page that they were helping the unfortunate with free meals which is simply just amazing . Ive been spreading the word about this place…if you havent tried it, youre missing out!
… moreJared Backus
Nice, little restaurant, the restaurant is under new,ownership since I was last here.. The teamwork and attentiveness to our needs were remarkable. Impeccable service in a very unassuming restaurant. The food was very good as well with a nice presentation.
… moreDominic Mattis
The chicken cheesesteak here puts All of the other ones I have had to shame. They absolutely crushed it. The perfect amount of toppings and chicken and sauce. If your coming here you need to try this phenomenal sub.
… moreDavid Miller
Possibly the best pizza shop in the area, Ron is a great guy and his pizza shop makes amazing food! Great prices and specials too! Definitely recommend!
… moreharold garcia
This is a great family owned business with great hospitality and delicious food. I had a personal pizza and it was incredible. I was treated like family with lots of love and respect everyone seemed to be in a great mood. All smiles from them and all smiles from me as I exited the restaurant. The owner Ron and his family are great people with attention to detail. I will recommend this place a million times. God bless this business
… moreWayne Trump Jr.
Excellent as usual. Great family atmosphere and well operated pizza joint. So many great foods on the menu and specials posted daily on Facebook.
… moreBrian Miller
Great food for a great price with a great atmosphere, and a wonderful crew running it. Had heard nothing, but great things about the place before this, and I can see why. We got a pan of Lasagna and 50 boneless wings for New Year’s Eve. Both things were delicious to say the least. Layers upon layers in the lasagna, and layers of flavor as well. We drove 27 miles one way to pick up our food, and we are more than willing to do it again after our experience.
… more