The Grayback
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 3.8/5 – “Tasty, but could use a little more heat and crunch”
The cheese was thick and flavorful, and the pepperoni had a nice, savory bite. The pizza overall was tasty, but it could’ve used a few more minutes in the oven. The crust wasn’t doughy — more like soft bread — but it lacked that crunch or little bit of char that makes a great pie really shine.
The breadsticks were also good, flavorful but soft. The marinara sauce had solid flavor, just served a bit too cold — straight from the fridge.
Big plus: they packed plenty of plates, forks, napkins, crushed red pepper, and Parmesan. That extra care goes a long way, especially for takeout.
Not a bad experience at all — just needs a little more heat and crisp to hit perfection.
… moreClifford Poessnecker
This was one of the best experiences I’ve ever had at a Valentino’s! The main person working that night, Jarrod, made the whole experience 100% worth while! He kept me informed of where the order was the entire time and did an excellent job of managing the constant flow of customers while also preparing food!
… moreMelissa Gerardo
The pizza is amazing and expensive for such a small pizza. The bread was amazing as well. Very soft and yummy, bursting with flavor! I will eat here again.
I ordered curb side pick up, but didn’t really read the signs so I was parked in the wrong spot. I went in and told the lady as much, and she looked up my order which was waiting for me. I tried to make a joke of not being able to read today but she wouldn’t even crack a smile. Customer service goes a lo g way with me so that’s why I only gave 4 stars.
… moreDenver Doty
As a visitor to Lincoln, I found Valentino’s Deluxe Pepperoni with cream cheese pizza to be quite intriguing. It was very delicious – plenty of toppings and sauce, and the crust had a thin, crispy exterior and a soft inside. And while the breadsticks at most pizza parlors are iffy, Valentino’s garlic breadsticks were soft, fluffy, and seasoned incredibly well!
… moreBrandon May
This is a smaller Valentino’s and doesn’t have a buffet. The food was great! You can dine in but the food will be packaged to go. I will eat hear again.
… moreAmy Peterson
I dont understand why it takes 2 hours!!! For delivery or take out. Management should start managing…and they charge for delivery after 2 hours. Make me understand. The owners of Val’s would not be ok with this either.
… moreJoseph Near
If you like dough pizza with zero crunch then this is the spot. Holy hell I don’t even think it’s fully cooked!
… moreTodd Lehn
Great pizza! The only downside is you’d better pay close attention to the fine print in the coupons, or you’re going to get a surprise with your bill. I mean, just make the coupons simple! We ordered 7 large pizzas, and only the first two were at the coupon price, but that was never mentioned on the phone when we placed our order.
… moreAnn Kerrey
Order often. We always order for the evenings before holidays. They are always VERY nice and have excellent food.
… moreJon Streich
Pizza was good, BUT evidently it’s okay for the staff to let their friends or family come in and be loud, childish and hang out at the counter while others try to eat.
… more