Social Profile: 
![]()
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Looking for the best pizza in Polaris? Rejoice, you aficionados of all things pizza pie – the seemingly endless search is finally over. From thin crust to deep dish to gluten-free options and beyond, we’ve got you covered. We at Cottage Inn Pizza pride ourselves on serving the Polaris community with superior products using only the finest ingredients available. Not to mention, we’re always listening to our customers to provide the best possible service around. The result? Decadent, delicious, delivery-ready gourmet pizza. Located on Lazelle Road along side of the Lazelle Woods Park, makes it easy to enjoy fast and fresh after any time no matter if you are at your house or staying at one of the amazing hotels in the Polaris Area.
Long-running Midwestern chain serving deep-dish & thin-crust pizzas, plus subs, salads & more.
Hours
| Monday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 8317 Market Exchange Dr, Columbus, OH 43081
Phone: (614) 888-8488
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Cottage Inn Pizza Polaris
We at Cottage Inn Pizza pride ourselves on serving the Polaris community with superior products using only the finest ingredients available. Not to mention, we’ …
Pizza Delivery Near Polaris, Ohio | Order Online Cottage Inn Pizza
Pizza Delivery in Columbus / Polaris. “Looking for the best pizza in Polaris?” Rejoice, you aficionados of all thing’s pizza pie – the seemingly endless …
Cottage Inn Gourmet Pizza | Delivery & Carryout Pizza, Wings …
Fresh handmade dough. Premium ingredients. Gourmet flavor in every bite. Cottage Inn Gourmet Pizza delivers handcrafted pizzas, wings, pasta, and more.
Reviews
Noah Yinger
Let me paint the picture for you, I’m leaving my apartment when it starts to absolutely downpour into what closely resembles a small tsunami. My cottage inn order is going to be ready in five minutes and I have a decision to make… My wife and I have never had it and had wanted to check it out for sometime. I finally got to my car looking like I just went for a quick swim and made the five minute trek to the restaurant. Let me say this, it was completely worth it. The kids working in there were so nice, and even threw an extra ranch in there for me, if you are from Ohio, you know that is so clutch. We ordered a large thin crust pizza, which was fantastic, and the breadsticks were also excellent. $20 for everything which I would say is a great deal.
… moreV-Man
Everyone needs their own nearby go-to pizza joint. I’ve been on the look out for mine for too long considering there’s a several competitors in my area. I realized I’ve been sleeping on Cottage Inn pizza! Seriously, wake up folks!
Let me straight out say that Cottage Inn has the best deals on their website out of all the pizza spots in my area, which I absolutely utilized. I seriously sat down on my computer, pulled up different menus on different tabs, and compared them & did the math to figure this out. Best part is that you don’t have to use 1 deal per transaction. I paid $15.99 for 1 large Pepp Pizza with bread-sticks and garlic cream cheese, which was awesome!
I also used their $21.99 for 2 Large 2 Topping pizza deal. I customized both pizzas to my liking, so it ended up being $32.99 (about $16.50 per pizza) for both of them but I seriously made these the best pizzas I’ve had ever! Like reference my pictures and tell me those aren’t scrumptious looking!
The first one I built with Bacon and Grilled Chicken with a Pesto Drizzle and Garlic Parmesan crust. The second one I made was Hawaiian themed with Bacon, Ham, Black Olives, Pineapple, Red Onions with Everything crust and Tangy Gold drizzle (I had to pay a little bit extra for the additional toppings since deal was supposed to be for only 2 toppings). Both pizzas tasted like a specialty pizza (typically $18.99), except they cost me way less due to the amazing deals!
I’m not even at the best part yet; THEY HAVE APPLE-PIE PIZZA. For $7.99, you literally get an apple pizza! The only other place that I know that made dessert pizzas is East of Chicago Pizza in Marysville, so I was really happy to find that Cottage Inn made these too! It’s the perfect dessert!
… moreLet me straight out say that Cottage Inn has the best deals on their website out of all the pizza spots in my area, which I absolutely utilized. I seriously sat down on my computer, pulled up different menus on different tabs, and compared them & did the math to figure this out. Best part is that you don’t have to use 1 deal per transaction. I paid $15.99 for 1 large Pepp Pizza with bread-sticks and garlic cream cheese, which was awesome!
I also used their $21.99 for 2 Large 2 Topping pizza deal. I customized both pizzas to my liking, so it ended up being $32.99 (about $16.50 per pizza) for both of them but I seriously made these the best pizzas I’ve had ever! Like reference my pictures and tell me those aren’t scrumptious looking!
The first one I built with Bacon and Grilled Chicken with a Pesto Drizzle and Garlic Parmesan crust. The second one I made was Hawaiian themed with Bacon, Ham, Black Olives, Pineapple, Red Onions with Everything crust and Tangy Gold drizzle (I had to pay a little bit extra for the additional toppings since deal was supposed to be for only 2 toppings). Both pizzas tasted like a specialty pizza (typically $18.99), except they cost me way less due to the amazing deals!
I’m not even at the best part yet; THEY HAVE APPLE-PIE PIZZA. For $7.99, you literally get an apple pizza! The only other place that I know that made dessert pizzas is East of Chicago Pizza in Marysville, so I was really happy to find that Cottage Inn made these too! It’s the perfect dessert!
Sri surya shankar Neerukonda
Delicious…yummy….tasty…..crispy and crunch crust. I had a Calzone here. This is my first visit to this place. Nice small place with pleasant ambience. Very professional and friendly staff welcoming us. This is my first Calzone and it looks like a stuffed croissant cut in to 4 pieces but tastes more like a pizza. But should be eaten when it’s hot. Yummy and juicy garlic ranch with garlic butter is a great side to have with this. Love to visit them again. Thank you!
They also raise funds to good causes around the world. Keep doing this!!
… moreThey also raise funds to good causes around the world. Keep doing this!!
Mallanagouda Patil
It’s great pizza place with traditional pizza. They have wide variety of pizza including create your own. I am being vegetarian tried Mediterranean veggie pizza it was great and one more thing I liked is you can customize main pizzas. The best thing is they add olive oil which made pizza very juice and tasty. Must visit
… moreNewNeoMasterExtreme
In these dire times, a delicious pie is needed and this place delivers! From the crispy and tasty breading to the zesty sauce, you can’t go wrong with this fine establishment. Count on me to return!
… moreAnton Melek
It’s the greatest pizza I eat ever
Test good, enough and fresh toppings and nice costumer service
… moreTest good, enough and fresh toppings and nice costumer service
PALMA RAPP
The pizza and salad were really good. Service was super friendly and fast. Not much dine in seating, but perfect for our lunch. Lots of pizza varieties we’d like to try next time.
… moreMissa
First time ordering from here, and the food was delicious!! Would come-back again of I’m ever in Columbus!
… moreJessica R (TrinityRisky)
Ordered through a third party for delivery. It took over an hour to get delivered. We ordered the BLT, bread sticks, cinnamon desert thing. The BLT pizza was absolutely disgusting, the lettuce had gone brown and mushy, so much ranch (maybe put it on the side), the flavor was all around gross. Bread sticks weren’t terrible but man the grease was horrible. The only thing worth getting again would be the cinnamon desert thing. Personally I wouldn’t bother trying this place again, I’m not sure what the hype is about
… moreBrian Carr
Cottage Inn is a unique pizza brand, there’s definitely nothing like it, it’s not one of the big 3 pizza styles – Chicago, Detroit or New York, it’s just great pizza. The ingredients are top notch, and Cottage Inn is the only pizza restaurant with truly great sausage.
When we lived in Columbus we ordered Cottage Inn regularly, alternating pizza nights between Cottage Inn and Romeo’s. Now that we live out of state, when I fly into Columbus, I pick up a few to take home.
Cottage Inn Pizza is one of the best in the area. Definitely skip the national brands you are familiar with and give this one a try, you won’t regret it. Don’t forget to add the pizza crust seasoning!!!
… moreWhen we lived in Columbus we ordered Cottage Inn regularly, alternating pizza nights between Cottage Inn and Romeo’s. Now that we live out of state, when I fly into Columbus, I pick up a few to take home.
Cottage Inn Pizza is one of the best in the area. Definitely skip the national brands you are familiar with and give this one a try, you won’t regret it. Don’t forget to add the pizza crust seasoning!!!