Adam Dungan
First time trying this place and it was awesome! Friendly staff and great menu choices will get us back in there soon. I had to try the pizza and it was the ! Our kiddo devoured some spaghetti and meatballs and the creamy bolognese was super flavorful
… moreBen Danile
The pizza here is amazing! The crust is different than any other place i have had and i love the toppings under the cheese. The bread on the garlic bread gets a bit soggy under all the cheese and the cinnamon bread is a little doughy. But all tasty overall
… moreKevin F
Love a good neighborhood Italian spot that’s reliable, affordable, and down to earth. Nicolo’s is doing just that here in Lakewood. They offer up some good gluten free items free items including a tapioca dough that IMHO is better than their too doughy normal dough. Really enjoyed the hot Italian beef sandwich. Service was prompt and courteous. The space itself is pretty simple but it seems like they have some great deals on happy hour. Would come back.
… moreKevin Anderson
Nicolo’s Chicago Style Pizza is hands-down our favorite pizza spot in town! My wife and I go a few times a month, and every visit is consistently fantastic. The deep-dish is rich, cheesy, and loaded with flavor—exactly what you’d hope for in authentic Chicago-style pizza.
The staff is always friendly and welcoming, and the atmosphere is cozy and relaxed, perfect for a casual night out or a quick bite. We’ve tried several items on the menu, and everything—from the crust to the toppings—is top-notch.
It’s clear they care about quality and their customers. We always leave full and happy. Highly recommend Nicolo’s to anyone who loves great pizza and great service!
… moreTink Rabey-Hall
We have enjoyed the Bucket of Spaghetti takeout many times with local friends…love it except that recently you have been scrimping on the sauce . We all decided to come in and try the new menu. Friends say they really liked the new look and cleanliness. Food: Salads were large but housemade Italian was not very flavorful, seemed like it was all oil. Calzone was well-received; lasagna was well-received; Build Your Own Pasta left something to be desired (chicken was small chopped up pieces that had an odd flavor, not grilled and marinara had several enormous pieces of whole tomatoes that I did not like). 121 draft rootbeer was liked though it should be served in a frosted mug not with ice. Mountain Dew tasted flat. Service was reasonable. We’ll probably try again.
… moreCassie Ortiz
Food was amazing!! 10/10 but our service was horrible. Not only did it take 15 for them to bust a table 1 table…. But our waitress barely checked on us. No refills. We didn’t have silverware, boxes or our check for the longest time even after asking. The waitresses name was Skylar and I’m sorry but this was the worst service I have ever gotten. Which is unfortunate because the food was so good. There was a dark haired waiter that helped us and did amazing. Better service better tip
… moreLisa Brown
If you like a neighborhood spot to have pizza and Italian food, dine in or take out – this is the place! I’ve been coming here on and off for years. The new owners have taken it to the next level. Food still tasty and fresh, the atmosphere is casual and modern, updated. But what is exceptional is the vibe. Kinda chill but not lazy, friendly. Wait staff are friendly and conversational. They say goodbye when you leave and thank you for coming in. Thanks Megan and Justin – big fan! Keep it up!
… moreAlan Ksionek
Our favorite pizza and pasta joint in Lakewood. Gluten free products are the best in the metro. I love the slow burn from the fettuccini Alfredo. Nothing like it anywhere else.
… moreKloudn9N3
Gina is amazing!!!! Pizza tasted great and fresh and the customer service is excellent and very welcoming I’ll be telling everyone about this place!!!!
… moreNOOS
This place has an old school feel to a pizza restaurant – redefining Mom and Pop pizza shops. The menu here is also different than other pizza shops – that alone is worth stopping in to check out not just the business itself but also the delicious smells the restaurant also emits. I also can’t forget that this business serves alcoholic beverages! Wow! The only thing missing here are TVs, salad bar and an actual bar!!!
The calzone was incredible. So was the fettuccine Alfredo. The sandwich was also absolutely incredible – the Italian Beef.
Courtney’s Pizza to-go was also fire. I also might recommend that the calzones, pizzas and subs and possibly the wings be well done for the best overall review.
Thank you Avi for making our first dine in experience worth remembering. Avi was very attentive and gave us the best customer service in the corner of the pizza shop. Always refilling soda and always checking to see how we are doing!
I am also curious to see the delivery service here to see if it is as great as the dining in.
Much love to the Niccolos Pizza and we very much look forward to supporting this local small business!
From a well known local reviewer and fan of all pizzas alike,
Chris & Christina
… more