Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
Review notes:
• “The ‘Whatever’ omelet was decent but below my (inflated) expectation.”
• “Don’t eat the salmon patty”
• “I know it’s delicious”
• “Overall it was fine. The omelet was satisfactory. The goetta was disappointing because it did not have much texture indicating a low proportion of oats. It was also not cooked to be crispy.”
• “Service was friendly and prompt.”
• “Goetta was mushy AF, don’t recommend”
• “Gravy had nice big chunks of sausage”
• Slightly disappointed compared to previous visits.”
• “The largest portion of any of the sites this week!”
• “Meat omelet was solid. Love the vibes here. Staple of the lunch rotation.”
• “The food was decent. Toast had a little extra butter – but not dripping.”
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 6 AM–1 PM |
| Wednesday | 6 AM–1 PM |
| Thursday | 6 AM–1 PM |
| Friday | 6 AM–1 PM |
| Saturday | 6 AM–1 PM |
| Sunday | 7 AM–1 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2036 S Co Rd 825 E, New Point, IN 47263
Phone: (812) 663-8980
Website: https://m.facebook.com/Midtown-Diner-222172221129427/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Midtown Diner | New Point IN – Facebook
Midtown Diner is a little restaurant located in New Point. We serve homemade breakfast and lunch. American Restaurant · $.
Midtown Diner – Visit Greensburg
2036 S Co Rd 825 E, New Point, IN 47263 (812) 663-8980 Midtown Diner 1/3 Map Description American Restaurant
Midtown Diner: Cozy, Historic Breakfast Spot with Homemade Pies …
Discover Midtown Diner, a charming converted house diner in New Point, Indiana. Enjoy fresh, home-style breakfast and lunch with friendly service, …
Reviews
Mary Byrne
We drove over a half hour to try Midtown based on friends’ recommendations, and it did not disappoint! The decor give the homey feeling of breakfast in grandma’s kitchen. The food is hot, fresh, and tasty. Service is fast and friendly. It was well worth the drive! We will be going back very soon.
… moreThe Pagano Perspective
Server was friendly. Food was really good. We got 2 omelettes and biscuits and gravy. All were good.
… morecassandra jenkins
If you’re looking for a hole in the wall hidden gem then this is your place! It’s a converted house into a diner. It’s small and the waitresses know their customers by name and treat you like a long time friend. They have several homemade pie options and they are delicious! We stop here frequently and always have a great meal!! There are daily specials for breakfast and lunch. It’s not a well publicized location and we learned about it by word of mouth years ago. You should definitely make this a place to go if you’re between Indianapolis and Cincinnati.
… moreMelanie Stahley
Just had lunch at midtown diner, ribeye steak sandwich lunch special was delicious. Servers were very friendly and seating area was very clean. Highly recommend
… moreBatesvilleCulinary ReviewBoard
Review notes:
• “The ‘Whatever’ omelet was decent but below my (inflated) expectation.”
• “Don’t eat the salmon patty”
• “I know it’s delicious”
• “Overall it was fine. The omelet was satisfactory. The goetta was disappointing because it did not have much texture indicating a low proportion of oats. It was also not cooked to be crispy.”
• “Service was friendly and prompt.”
• “Goetta was mushy AF, don’t recommend”
• “Gravy had nice big chunks of sausage”
• Slightly disappointed compared to previous visits.”
• “The largest portion of any of the sites this week!”
• “Meat omelet was solid. Love the vibes here. Staple of the lunch rotation.”
• “The food was decent. Toast had a little extra butter – but not dripping.”
kristi Eckart
The cook gave me raw potatoes when I asked for well done so I told my waitress. She said well we can’t take them back. So I said I specifically asked for well done potatoes and bacon and you wrote it on the ticket. She ended up telling the cook who made me more the same way… With a attitude about it. Told me the grill wasn’t hot because the eggs on it. Well keep them on there longer. If that’s your excuse.
… moreJames A Hawkins III
Absolutely wonderful. The kind of place you can’t find in a city. Great food, wonderful service, really cool setting! We told our server it was our son’s 6th birthday. She brought his egg sandwich with a candle and sung happy birthday to him. . The old photo is what the building used to be. Cool history and a wonderful breakfast. Hope to return when I’m in the area.
… moreDennis Errichiello
I stopped here for lunch at noon on a Thursday and the place was full of people, there were only a few seats open. This place was busy and most likely because it’s one of the only restaurants around. It is very much off the beaten path from the expressway.
I took one of the few tables that were open, and my server came right over and took my drink order and gave me a menu. The menu was a little bit of a disappointment, I was expecting some good old dinner favorites and really it was heavy on breakfast items and lunch was mainly hamburgers and sandwiches.
I ordered the BLT sandwich along with a cup of potato soup. The BLT was served with French fries.
After a short wait, approx. 5 mins, she brought me my lunch. She served the soup with the meal, and I really would rather have my soup first so neither one gets cold. The soup lacked flavor, not completely, but it was rather bland.
The BLT was fantastic, it was very flavorful, the bacon was crispy, and the tomatoes and lettuce were very fresh. The only thing I wished they would have offered was a BLT club sandwich as the sandwich left me a little hungry.
Now the French fries here are on another level. They were cooked PERFECTLY, they were on the fat side, but very crispy on the outside, but fluffy on the inside. They were WONDERFUL… I would come here just for the fry’s…
My only complaint came at the end of the meal when it came to paying my bill. It dawned on me when I brought my check to the register, that they might not take credit cards and I was correct they didn’t. I had to leave my driver’s license with my server while I ran several blocks down the road to go to a convenience store to use the ATM. THAT WAS A PAIN.
I personally don’t understand an establishment not taking credit cards today, this is 2023. Everyone has a smartphone and can use PayPal or square. I am more than willing to pay an additional 3% for credit card processing fees, just post that is your policy for accepting credit cards. At least that way, it is our choice, right now you are not giving us a choice at all.
I will only go back if they start accepting credit cards.
… moreI took one of the few tables that were open, and my server came right over and took my drink order and gave me a menu. The menu was a little bit of a disappointment, I was expecting some good old dinner favorites and really it was heavy on breakfast items and lunch was mainly hamburgers and sandwiches.
I ordered the BLT sandwich along with a cup of potato soup. The BLT was served with French fries.
After a short wait, approx. 5 mins, she brought me my lunch. She served the soup with the meal, and I really would rather have my soup first so neither one gets cold. The soup lacked flavor, not completely, but it was rather bland.
The BLT was fantastic, it was very flavorful, the bacon was crispy, and the tomatoes and lettuce were very fresh. The only thing I wished they would have offered was a BLT club sandwich as the sandwich left me a little hungry.
Now the French fries here are on another level. They were cooked PERFECTLY, they were on the fat side, but very crispy on the outside, but fluffy on the inside. They were WONDERFUL… I would come here just for the fry’s…
My only complaint came at the end of the meal when it came to paying my bill. It dawned on me when I brought my check to the register, that they might not take credit cards and I was correct they didn’t. I had to leave my driver’s license with my server while I ran several blocks down the road to go to a convenience store to use the ATM. THAT WAS A PAIN.
I personally don’t understand an establishment not taking credit cards today, this is 2023. Everyone has a smartphone and can use PayPal or square. I am more than willing to pay an additional 3% for credit card processing fees, just post that is your policy for accepting credit cards. At least that way, it is our choice, right now you are not giving us a choice at all.
I will only go back if they start accepting credit cards.
Jaclyn Fitzgerald
This place was so cute! I work nearby and have heard great things about it. I decided to stop in for breakfast to go. Wonderful service, cozy atmosphere, will definitely be stopping by for lunch. It is cash or check only, which I have no problem with, but keep that in mind if you want to make a visit.
… moreJillian Schmidt
Adorable place with great service! The people are incredibly nice. Truly a great little cafe with great service.
… more