Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Step into Keyhole Pizzeria, a brand new independent pizza restaurant in the heart of North Manchester. Since opening its doors in late 2024, this eatery has been delighting the community with its distinctive and delicious pizza creations. Keyhole Pizzeria is dedicated to crafting each pizza with fresh ingredients and a passion for flavor. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this inviting spot on Main Street promises a memorable dining experience that celebrates the art of great pizza.
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 2–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 210 E Main St, North Manchester, IN 46962
Phone: (260) 321-7667
Website: https://www.keyholepizzeria.net/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Best Pizza in North Manchester, IN | Keyhole Pizzeria | Keyhole …
Enjoy handmade pizzas, fresh toppings, and family-friendly dining at Keyhole Pizzeria — the best pizza spot in North Manchester, IN.
Keyhole Pizzeria North Manchester – Facebook
Pizza with a purpose-a wonderful treat for a snowy Sunday! So don’t cook, call Keyhole! 210 E Main Street 260-204-1833.
Keyhole Pizzeria Pierceton 301 1/2 N First Street – Order Online
Sign in for a faster ordering experience. Only accepting scheduled orders. Keyhole Pizzeria …
Last Updates
Reviews
Kelly Frank
We tried Keyhole Pizzeria for the first time the other day. They have a friendly and helpful stay and watch to ensure the dining is clean and tables are wiped down. If you’re dining in they have fountain soda or water . Carry out has bottles .
One perk of dine is , a sauce is included at no cost with the breadsticks . They have good garlic Parmesan breadsticks , 6 to an order. The pizza comes in three different crusts. We ordered the original , similar to a hand tossed. They do not skimp on the topping to cheese. It’s a good quality pizza, but doesn’t quite hit a home run for us, but you can be the judge.
… moreOne perk of dine is , a sauce is included at no cost with the breadsticks . They have good garlic Parmesan breadsticks , 6 to an order. The pizza comes in three different crusts. We ordered the original , similar to a hand tossed. They do not skimp on the topping to cheese. It’s a good quality pizza, but doesn’t quite hit a home run for us, but you can be the judge.
Grant Miller
Delicious pizza!..among the very best! I had them use garlic butter in place of tomato-based pizza sauce, the crust was soft with crispy areas, and it was entirely delectable!! The eagerness of both Matt and Martha to make it a delightful pizza, and experience is unsurpassed! Great people, great pizza; what more can you ask for?!
… moreJoe Chenery
Really great pizza. Delicious slightly sweet flavor for the crust and sauce had a perfect bite. Generous amount of very fresh tasting cheese and great fresh toppings. With very competitive pricing on a super high quality pizza the keyhole pizzeria is the best around.
… moreRobert Bentley
This is a must try if you ever make it to North Manchester. The pizza was phenomenal and the owners are great. I will be making this pizza parlor one of my regular visits and would recommend to any pizza lover.
… moreLaurie Everitt
We stopped for a late lunch on our way through Indiana, and the pizza was fabulous! Crispy crusts, delicious toppings, and fast and friendly service. What luck for us to stop here!
… moreVince Taweel
I ordered delivery directly through their website. The Supreme Pizza and Mozzarella Sticks were delicious and I saved money ordering directly from their website instead of DoorDash.
… moreLuke Gobel
What a perfect dining experience for our team! The owners are wonderful. The pizza is wonderful! I highly recommend. The mushroom pizza was delicious!
… moreOwen Kieler
Pizza is worth the price, really good, don’t complain about price if you want quality
… moreRhonda Gilleland
Made 1st pizza wrong. 2nd pizza came out cold, even cheese was not melted. Not good. Asked for box took it home to cook. Um No
… moreCrystalina Alaghwani
Amazing pizza great taste better than Pizza Hut and dominos. Every bite is a mouth full of flavor and deliciousness. The owners are amazing especially Martha great customer service and lovely place to eat in
… more