Pasta, calzones & strombolis, plus American sandwiches & wraps served up in a cozy space.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2204 Elliston Pl, Nashville, TN 37203
Phone: (615) 327-3663
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
NY Pie | Where Authentic New York Pizza Meets Nashville Soul
Experience authentic New York pizza in Tennessee – thin, hand-tossed dough (made daily) stretched & backed in a traditional brick oven.
Taste of NY Nashville, TN
Authentic Taste of NY in Nashville Downtown. We’re a family-owned and operated business, and we’re committed to providing our customers with the best possible …
NY Style Pizza : r/nashville – Reddit
Tutti da gio has really good brick oven pizza. They had a location in hermitage and recently opened one in Hendersonville. NY pie is my personal …
Reviews
Paridhi
No Air conditioners (maybe they didn’t turn it on), No music, not a single person, no interiors, no vibe like I expected 🙁 BUT it is right in the middle of the city, surrounded by other cafes and restaurants. Paid street parking right outside, if you get one, we went around 6 in the evening, no crowd at all. Not sure if it’s wheelchair accessible, but there are a few vegetarian options. We had the new york style thin crust cheese pizza and it tasted really good! The best part is that it’s open until 5am so I might want to take away for a late night pizza party!!!
… moreErik Petersen
As someone from NY, your advertisement of “NY pizza” could not be farther from accurate. To start, you didn’t even use cup n’ char pepperoni. No big slices, and barely any seasoning. At most, this is Little Caesar’s with extra cheese. For $14, the pizza was fine, I guess, but to claim you sell NY pizza is hella funny to me. Change ya name or change your recipe.
Overall, 1/10 when comparing to anything I’ve had in NY. 5/10 when comparing to most pies I’ve had in the south. 4/10 when comparing to other pizza in a similar style.
… moreOverall, 1/10 when comparing to anything I’ve had in NY. 5/10 when comparing to most pies I’ve had in the south. 4/10 when comparing to other pizza in a similar style.
Ami Ami
The marinara was cold and tasted of tomato paste. The cheese was poor quality on my calzone, and the crust was bready. And who puts marinara inside a calzone? Would not eat here again, I don’t recommend. That calzone went in the trash.
… moreNouman Hashmi
I ordered a small vege extravaganza pizza while the dough would be hand tossed along with a diet Coke. Expected a bit better taste and quality from a $15 meal however the first pizza that was given to me was burnt specifically from the sides and bottom. Upon complaining, I was told that they use brick oven to give the crust a crunchy taste. However, the staff acknowledged their mistake and replaced it with a new one however there is a serious need to work on the taste and the quantity of cheese on it. It was below average and I don’t see anyone giving it a shot.
… moreAngel Nicolodi
Pizza looks good but it’s the wrong pizza they don’t have hand tossed and just gave me what they have. For 14 it should have some flavoring I had to put salt on it to taste something!!! Step up your game and the pizza crust is too done
… moreAceR2905
This joint is AWESOME! Best pizza I have had. My 5 year old says”mom this is the pizza ninja tutles eat”. There you have it. A nice whole in the wall to enjoy an New York style pizza.
… moreMohsen
Absolutely the best pizza in town. Me and my family order from this place every Sunday. Very clean place. Amazing staff, amazing food and amazing prices. This place is just WOW. If you haven’t tried it, place your order now. If your looking at this review, don’t waste your time looking at different reviews. place your order now!
… moreRicky Ricardo
Bought 2 Tennessee cheesecakes, 1 strawberry. They were not consistent in quality. Told this to the guy at the front .. but he did nothing, despite asking him for a replacement.
To the mgnt team, please take care of those unwanted insects.
Will not return.
… moreTo the mgnt team, please take care of those unwanted insects.
Will not return.
Melissa Lauricello
Was recently in town from NY for a conference and passed this spot a few times before deciding to give it a shot and daring it to live up to its name. I’ve gotta say, it was pretty good! I see other reviews wishing there was more “ambience” or employee presence, but who cares when it’s late and you’re just looking for a good slice of pizza! A co-worker and I each got a pepperoni slice and, while it could’ve been a tiny bit crispier with some garlic, cheese, red pepper shakers out, it passed. I’ve traveled a lot and have seen so many “NY Pizza” spots that are essentially Domino’s by the slice. This place is not that and is definitely worth a drop in, especially if you’re on your way to or from the bar next door!
… moreK H
THIS IS NOT A PIZZA PLACE!!
I guess it used to be. Went here after a concert to order some grub, and they had three cold dishes for me to choose from. I tried to give them a chance, so I chose one, and they didn’t even heat it up. Just bagged me up that old, cold food the cashier just opened and showed me. No signage to indicate whatever food type they are trying to serve now. No menu either. Very confusing presentation… Hopefully, they get it together and get some easier to-go food items for people who aren’t going to go home and microwave their old cold food.
… moreI guess it used to be. Went here after a concert to order some grub, and they had three cold dishes for me to choose from. I tried to give them a chance, so I chose one, and they didn’t even heat it up. Just bagged me up that old, cold food the cashier just opened and showed me. No signage to indicate whatever food type they are trying to serve now. No menu either. Very confusing presentation… Hopefully, they get it together and get some easier to-go food items for people who aren’t going to go home and microwave their old cold food.