Inspired by the Italian New York Pizzerias found in Little Italy, in 1993, Goodfella’s Pizza was born with the aim of bringing a slice of deep pan. Ever since then we have focused on making pizza the proper way; with respect. Each Goodfella’s pizza starts its life as an individual dough ball, which is rested to develop the texture and flavour before being baked on real Italian stone and then topped with the highest quality toppings for an authentic taste of New York. Goodfella’s Pizza. Made with Respect!
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Monday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–3 AM |
| Friday | 11 AM–3 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–3 AM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4906 Covington Hwy, Decatur, GA 30035
Phone: (404) 549-7202
Website: https://www.goodfellaspizzaandwings.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
goodfellas pizza and wings
Made with Respect! GOODFELLAS PIZZA AND WINGS … GOODFELLAS PIZZA AND WINGS DECATUR 4906 COVINGTON HWY DECATUR, GA 30035 www.goodfellaspizzaandwings.com PHONE …
Goodfellas Pizza and Wings | Best Pizza in Decatur, GA
Goodfellas Pizza and Wings Official Website. Save Money Ordering Directly Here. Healthy Options. Fast Service. Friendly Team. Top Rated.
Goodfellas Pizza and Wings | Best Pizza in Town | Pizza near me
Goodfellas Pizza and Wings: the best Pizza in Town and other locations … Decatur, GA 30030. Contacts. (470) 823-3452 · [email protected] · Get …
Reviews
Quasheeka Miller
[Sunday]
{February 1, 2026}
(5:49 p.m.) est
#GoodFellasREVIEW
1. Thank you for replacing PizzaHut.
2. Thank you for the extended hours.
3. The pizza is good, I’ll give it that. (I appreciate a pizza establishment who isn’t stingy with the cheese.) #ijs
4. Since, this was my first time ordering the wings; maybe not fry/bake them so hard/crispy. (Since they are on the SMALLER scale.)
5. The fries….deep sighs (maybe I came too late in the day, for some fresh grease fries.)
… more{February 1, 2026}
(5:49 p.m.) est
#GoodFellasREVIEW
1. Thank you for replacing PizzaHut.
2. Thank you for the extended hours.
3. The pizza is good, I’ll give it that. (I appreciate a pizza establishment who isn’t stingy with the cheese.) #ijs
4. Since, this was my first time ordering the wings; maybe not fry/bake them so hard/crispy. (Since they are on the SMALLER scale.)
5. The fries….deep sighs (maybe I came too late in the day, for some fresh grease fries.)
Dede Hayden
I ordered a 10-inch Buffalo Chicken Pizza from Goodfellas Pizza & Wings on Covington Highway, and I was honestly disappointed. When I opened the box, all I saw was cheese and chicken — no visible buffalo sauce, no blue cheese crumbles, just a regular pizza. Then I noticed what looked like red sauce, so I went back around to the window and asked if red sauce was supposed to come on a Buffalo Chicken Pizza.
The lady at the window was super nice and took the time to explain that marinara is the only base they have — which, respectfully, is psychotic if you’re serving a Buffalo Chicken Pizza. I also asked about the blue cheese crumbles listed on the menu, and she said they’re “cooked in there.” I ate two slices and didn’t taste or see a single hint of blue cheese. I even asked if I could just buy some blue cheese crumbles to add myself, and they said they couldn’t sell them separately because they only have them as a topping.
The customer service was honestly great — the lady really did take the time to explain things — but the pizza itself completely missed the mark. Between the marinara base and the missing blue cheese flavor, it just wasn’t giving Buffalo Chicken Pizza at all.
And to be completely honest, I was so disappointed that I ordered a Buffalo Chicken Pizza from Mellow Mushroom on the way home through Uber Eats — and that’s how I knew I wasn’t crazy. Because theirs actually tasted like what I ordered.
Goodfellas, I really wanted to like y’all, but this ain’t it. Please either change the recipe or the name on the menu so people know what they’re getting.
Edited to add photos of pizzas from both restaurants for context.
… moreThe lady at the window was super nice and took the time to explain that marinara is the only base they have — which, respectfully, is psychotic if you’re serving a Buffalo Chicken Pizza. I also asked about the blue cheese crumbles listed on the menu, and she said they’re “cooked in there.” I ate two slices and didn’t taste or see a single hint of blue cheese. I even asked if I could just buy some blue cheese crumbles to add myself, and they said they couldn’t sell them separately because they only have them as a topping.
The customer service was honestly great — the lady really did take the time to explain things — but the pizza itself completely missed the mark. Between the marinara base and the missing blue cheese flavor, it just wasn’t giving Buffalo Chicken Pizza at all.
And to be completely honest, I was so disappointed that I ordered a Buffalo Chicken Pizza from Mellow Mushroom on the way home through Uber Eats — and that’s how I knew I wasn’t crazy. Because theirs actually tasted like what I ordered.
Goodfellas, I really wanted to like y’all, but this ain’t it. Please either change the recipe or the name on the menu so people know what they’re getting.
Edited to add photos of pizzas from both restaurants for context.
Raiven Stewart
I got a personal pan pizza and 6 honey hot wings with lemon pepper sprinkles. The pizza wasn’t anything spectacular and it barely had any sauce on it. The sauce on the wings was like a gel like consistency and not spread evenly on the chicken. I most likely won’t be coming back.
… moreKiki Ramirez
The order was incorrect. The order was half pepperoni and half mushrooms with spinach! The cook put pepperoni on the whole pizza. Not good considering my sister don’t eat pork. The wings were half teriyaki and mild but they were mixed in the same box. Wing size smaller than a pinkie finger.
… moreJared Williams
I was so excited and was waiting for the opening of this location i’m old-school Good fellas from the early 2000s the location that used to be across the street from the varsity that stayed open till 5 o’clock in the morning. Let me say the pizza taste and quality is nothing like that. Very disappointed needs heavy training. Biggest problem was my pizza was incorrect. The young lady who I assumed what’s new at taking orders had two older ladies standing next to her whom one of them took over taking my order and it was still incorrect. I asked for feta cheese and they just gave me a whole lot of mozzarella cheese which ruined the pizza. I’m talking about caked up cheese. If anything this pizza to me was a 2 out of 10, but maybe in the future they will be able to produce a better product.
… moreAustin Pope
As of today. They have small but regular sized wings please keep the small but regular sized wings. I would’ve took a regular picture but these mild lemon pepper wings hittin no need for all flats
… moreBarbara Camper
1. They use an automation to take your order and they got it wrong even after repeating it
2. The employee who was visible taking orders did not acknowledge that I was at the drive thru window after being there for a few minutes. I hate I did not get her name,
3. When she did wait on me, she handed me my pizza and quickly said have a good evening, closed the window and walked away. I glanced at the pizza and waited until she looked my way again and asked for some cheese and peppers, Instead of her just giving them to me she said I put some in the side of the box. There was none and I proceeded to show her.
4. I get home and upon eating the first slice, It lacked any flavor and the crust was not crispy but rather doughy and had mushrooms on it and I did not order more like mushrooms.
5. I called up to the restaurant and tried to voice my concerns to the “manager” who was the employee who waited on me. Instead of listening to me she proceeded to be argumentative, talking over me and trying to justify her actions.
6.Based on both the food quality and customer service, I will not be returning and would not recommend this establishment
… more2. The employee who was visible taking orders did not acknowledge that I was at the drive thru window after being there for a few minutes. I hate I did not get her name,
3. When she did wait on me, she handed me my pizza and quickly said have a good evening, closed the window and walked away. I glanced at the pizza and waited until she looked my way again and asked for some cheese and peppers, Instead of her just giving them to me she said I put some in the side of the box. There was none and I proceeded to show her.
4. I get home and upon eating the first slice, It lacked any flavor and the crust was not crispy but rather doughy and had mushrooms on it and I did not order more like mushrooms.
5. I called up to the restaurant and tried to voice my concerns to the “manager” who was the employee who waited on me. Instead of listening to me she proceeded to be argumentative, talking over me and trying to justify her actions.
6.Based on both the food quality and customer service, I will not be returning and would not recommend this establishment
TL Mickle
We have tried this restaurant twice and were pleased with both orders. I wish I had taken a picture of the Greek salad. It was very generous with toppings and a lot of food for the money. The young lady running the business was very pleasant and friendly when we picked up our orders and that type of positive service makes a big difference. We don’t have a lot of good choices in this area so I am happy to support a new business in this neighborhood. Keep up the good work and we will be back again. Thank You!!!
… moreKimberly Erdossy
Ladies at the counter were very nice, the inside is very clean. My food looks so pretty i don’t even wanna eat it, i just wanna admire it. will be back
… moreDavente “Recon World” Harris
Great prices. Food was great. That being said I ordered one Stromboli and one calzone. They gave me two Strombolis but the topping were right as if it was my calzone and they are the same price so I still ate it. And last thing the dough is good but it would be great if it had some garlic sauce or seasoning on the dough. Overall will definitely be back this might be my new pizza spot!
… more